Your Paper Bitcoin Is Basically Worthless | George Bodine | BIS #210
George Bodine joins the Bitcoin Infinity Show to talk about Bitcoin self-custody, running a node, and why paper Bitcoin held through treasury companies and ETFs carries counterparty risk that real cold storage does not. Knut and George dig into the Core versus Knots debate, BIP-110, the power law disagreement, and the risks facing Bitcoin treasury companies as financialization accelerates. Along the way they explore creativity as the opposite of productivity, the discipline of dropping your ego, and what a life of integrity looks like through the eyes of an artist and former fighter pilot.
Connect with George:
Connect with Us:
https://www.bitcoininfinityshow.com/
https://bitcoininfinitystore.com
https://twitter.com/BtcInfinityShow
https://twitter.com/knutsvanholm
https://twitter.com/lukedewolf
Thanks to our sponsors - check out their websites for info:
Firefish: https://firefish.io/ - Use Code INFINITY!
Bull Bitcoin: https://app.bullbitcoin.com/registration/infinity
BitBox: https://bitbox.swiss/infinity - Use Code INFINITY for 5% off!
Bitcoin Adviser: https://content.thebitcoinadviser.com/freedom
The Bitcoin Infinity Show is a Bitcoin podcast hosted by Knut Svanholm and produced by Luke de Wolf.
The Freedom Footprint Show is a Bitcoin podcast hosted by Knut Svanholm and Luke de Wolf.
In each episode, we explore everything from deep philosophy to practical tools to emit freedom dioxide to expand your freedom footprint!
00:00 - Welcome and Conference Insights
0:00 George, a warm welcome to the Bitcoin Infinity Show. Nice to have you here. Thanks, buddy. I'm excited. I'm pumped. You know, it was great meeting you in Prague. We had a blast, had a great dinner together. And, you know, Prague is one of those events. Last year, it kind of changed me. And this year, I think it's done the same thing. I cannot impress upon people that are listening to this enough that you've got to get off your ass. You've got to show up. You've got to go to these damn things. not some shit coiner conference, but I mean, like in Vegas, I'm talking about a real Bitcoin conference with Bitcoiners, no shit coins, no crypto stuff. And where people are being called out on the carpet for, uh, you know, basically, let's see, what, what would you say it for, for not being truthful? You know, if you, if you're not able to be truthful, if you can't handle the truth, then you know what, you're going to get called out on it. And I think that's the message is that I'm in a different place mentally right now. And I'm consolidating that position this year. I'm going to continue and nothing's going to stop me. That sounds fantastic. And right back at you, by the way, fantastic to see you. Always a pleasure. And yeah, I hope we see each other again soon. I don't know which conference will be next. But yeah, I agree with the sentiment that people should go to real Bitcoin conferences.
1:25 They are a double-edged sword, though, aren't they? Like, there's always... You can never know what games people are playing at conferences. There's a lot of that going on, like, I love Bitcoin, buy my shitcoin, or buy my whatever. Like, I'm guilty as charged. Like, I love Bitcoin, buy my fucking books. And you are too. I love Bitcoin, buy my art. Like that's there's always that aspect of it. So so it can be tricky for a noob to to navigate what's the real deal and what's what's just a sales tactic. Thank you. You know, one of the best quotes that I use often is from Epictetus.
2:07 He was a Greek Stoic, a slave under the Romans in 100 AD. And he wrote, if you are ever tempted to look for outside approval, realize you have just compromised your integrity. If you need a witness, be your own. And yes, it's true that I'm into Bitcoin and I sell my art. But quite frankly, I don't give a flying fuck if anybody buys it. I don't need to sell my art to anybody. And I don't need any likes. I don't need any clicks. I don't need more followers. I'm starting to realize that basically I've been given the greatest freedom that I could have. And sometimes I'm not using it to good effect. I think where I compromise my integrity is trying to position myself or to not to hesitate to call out people when basically I feel that they're not, you know, they're just not aligned with what Bitcoin's all about.
3:03 And I'd have to say that, again, this conference has given me a renewed confidence and inspiration to get off my butt and start doing that. Yeah, I mean, I've got a renewed sense of hope, too. Of course, there were many sailor fanboys and there were many paper Bitcoin enthusiasts there and various other people that I don't agree with. but I could feel there was a lot of real ones too. Like a majority of the Bitcoiners at the conference are obviously sincere and real Bitcoiners and that's always a pleasure to mingle around with them.
3:46 And that's what I love about these events that we're all just one big happy family but there are black sheep in this family and occasionally we have to flush them out. Yeah. But that's always been, yeah, that's always been, it's why I originally fell in love with the Bitcoin community because so many people weren't scared of calling out bullshit. So the slay your heroes mentality, basically. I prefer slay your heroes ideas maybe. So it can be kind of obvious who you're slaying when you're slaying a certain idea. anyway but there's there's like this this balance between diplomacy and just calling out bullshit whenever you see it because if you're being too undiplomatic let's just say if you've been too aggressive I think there's a risk that you won't be heard as much so there is some like for lack of a better word politicking to be done. I hate that word. So let's just call it diplomacy. What's your take on that?
4:59 So, you know, F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote, show me a hero and I'll write you a tragedy. And I think we've seen that with some of our supposedly, you know, heroes, however you want to call it within the Bitcoin community. You know, I will say to you, Newt, that, you know, I'm beginning to think in my mind that this is a battle that we're in that is for the you know, the future of money. And why I say that is because, you know, for 10,000 years now, ever since we settled down, we've been looking for money. And now we have money, digital money in a digital age that's perfect. I mean, this is a zero to one invention of the wheel. And we are going to get tremendous pushback. You know, why don't we go through all the central banks?
5:47 Let's go through 189 countries. And you show me, you point out the one that's going to embrace or coalesce around Bitcoin or Bitcoiners. You know, they're going to want to control the rails to Bitcoin. They're going to want to control access to Bitcoin, and they're going to want to control you. And the reason this is such an important fight is because Bitcoin is that last escape. It's the last raft off the Titanic. This is it. You got to get on board. And so I understand what you're saying, but I also think to myself that it's time for Bitcoiners to realize, as the financialization of Bitcoin is taking place before your very eyes, now is the time when you need to hone down to Bitcoin basics.
6:31 It's like going through, you know, when I went through boot camp with the fucking Marine DIs. I still don't like Marines. But no, a lot of Navy guys don't though. But anyway, I'm just kidding. I love Marines. But what I was going to say is that, you know, this is like boot camp. You know, you got to get back to the basics. I just think that we're in a really existential fight right now. I'm starting to realize that, you know, just zoomed out and looking at the community, you're right. You know, you go to someplace like Prague and you see all these great Bitcoiners and they're building stuff and they are they're focused. They are wanting to go forward with Bitcoin. And then when you step back and you get into the news cycle, you realize that basically the institutional aspect of Bitcoin is not there to support that same mission.
7:19 And we are on a mission. So again, I say get back to basics, and that's what I'm doing this year. Yeah, I absolutely agree. There's a lot of back and forth. Like this was to mention something very recent here. There was a Luke Dasher tweet about that if BIP1. He said something that might be perceived as very autistic. Something like if BIP110 fails, our only option is to go to a proof of work change. And then the other side immediately clinged on to that, that that would be Luke's endgame and that he really wanted to fork off Luke coin and make that.
8:00 Which is not how I interpreted the tweet at all. I think the day that nodes aren't in charge anymore is the day that Bitcoin is already dead at that point in my eyes. That's the key. You nailed it. That's fiat Bitcoin. It's by decree from miners that we trust it to be Bitcoin and not by running our own nodes. And also I thought if you think deeper about this dictating rules and enforcing rules is really two sides of the same coin in Bitcoin If you enforcing rules you can also dictate them somehow I haven refined that thought entirely There is nuance to it.
8:48 But running a node means not only that you're enforcing the rules, but you are dictating them because you have this nuclear option of signaling for a soft fork, which is very hard to not follow for miners. if it gets enough traction. So what's your stance there? How has your... Let me pose the question in an interesting way. How has your view on BIP-110 and this whole Civil War thing changed since you first heard about it or first understood it? I got into this last year, like February, March in 25.
9:31 And then at Prague last year, I asked Sailor. We had a little kind of a small gathering and I asked them about this controversy. I haven't stopped. I mean, I'm still involved in as far as studying it. I support BIP 110 100 percent. Not only am I running a no, but I'm signaling for it and I run nots and nothing has changed. In fact, everything that's come out since, whether it's HODL nots, exposés in particular, or some of the other writings that I've been reading, they support a lot of what I was concerned about the centralization of power, the lack of quality control, the lack of internal consensus, so to speak, within not just core, I'm talking about within the community. The fact that that core seems to be unable to build a consensus around an issue. And I don't mean consensus in Bitcoin terms. I mean, just building consensus agreement with an alignment within a community.
10:26 I think that they're out of touch. I think they've become a walled garden. I haven't changed my mind about that. We need an alternative. I was interested in production ready, but I'm not sure that that's the way to go. I have no problems with NOTS, running NOTS. I think it's a very good software implementation. Again, I support BIP110. If you're a Bitcoiner out there, you're going to get back to Bitcoin Basics this year, run a node, get off your ass, run a node, and then make your own decision whether you're going to run NOTS or Bitcoin Core. I would not run core. You know, I mean, look at look at the Jack. Look at the stuff that came out of V30. You know, everybody was calling me an idiot and that I didn't understand what I was talking about.
11:11 I don't write code. And what and when V30, the original came out, what did it do? It ended up deleting some legacy wallets and some people actually lost Bitcoin. Did you ever hear any did you ever hear anybody from core come out and say, hey, you know what? We really screwed up. We're sorry. We're going to change our process so that we can stop this kind of nonsense. No. So what comes out in V31? End up exposing some people's IPs. You know, what the hell? How could you do a much more egregious privacy invasion and actually a security violation than doing something like that? So again, you know, if you're going to, if you're going to talk the talk, then you better walk the walk. I want to hear something from Core 30. Tell me again why I'm an idiot. Let's get back in the discussion and figure this out.
12:03 But yeah, I personally, I've made my decision and I support BIP 110 100%. Yeah, to play the devil's advocate a little bit there, I think there was something apology apology like from the official core account. They did mention the bug and said that, please don't do this this way. I don't remember exactly what the issue was. I think it had something to do with if you moved coins from a legacy wallet and didn't have the backup or something like that.
12:47 which you shouldn't do anyway, but it's still sort of unforgivable. Like backwards compatibility has always been a priority in Bitcoin. And it sort of seems like it's not as much of a priority anymore. And that is a slippery slope in itself, I think. Well said. I agree. 100%, Newt. Yeah. So what other takeaways do you have from Prague? What other experiences did you have there? And did you talk to anyone in particular that changed your mind about something or opened up your mind to something new? Well, I really liked the beer there. Enjoyed that. So, you know, I did have an incredible conversation just one on one for about 45 minutes with Giovanni Santastasi, you know, who's brought to the forefront, the Bitcoin power law.
13:41 You know, when that law first came out, I got I did some studying on just physics in general. And, you know, I it's a real slog for me, obviously, to get through something like that. You know, I've got a degree in marketing of all things and, you know, I'm an artist. But I did do a lot of research enough to the point where I actually began to realize that the power law really doesn't have anything to do with Bitcoin. It's really about networks and adoption and scaling. And when I see, when I took a look at the power law, I mean, right away, I probably within months, you know, I thought there's some there's some validity to this. I think where people got kind of bent out of shape or where.
14:23 They didn't they didn't really look at it carefully was the fact that it was in hindsight, looking back, I wish we'd had more people pushing back against Plan B and Plan B's model in the last cycle. That was a mess. And it just would have taken some people to stand up and start calling that out to realize that it was a scam. And there were people that did. I mean, there were people that actually stood up and said, this is not, this is exactly. And you weren't, you weren't alone. There were other people calling it out. but I think that there was a lot of residual pain remembered from that particular event. And I think a lot of people kind of just thought that this is another model that is so predictive that you are going to be betting on it and you will take leverage and you will be assured of a certain price point.
15:14 And I think that was the wrong take. And then the other thing is that You know, people push back because of its variability. I mean, when you look at it, if you look at the model itself, the way to view it is, in my mind, is quantiles. It's the idea of, you know, when it sits at a certain magnitude, a deviation from the mean, when it sits at a certain level in a variation or deviation from that mean, you need to look to see where it sits that amount of time. What is the percentage that it's going to be in that ballpark. And again, I mean, I had a great talk with Giovanni, you know, Giovanni. The other problem with the power of law is Giovanni himself is a little bit of a, you're laughing because you know what I'm going to say. I even, I told it to him to his face. We were sitting there and I just, I mean, we're like, you know, one foot apart. I said, look, Giovanni, I said, you're your worst enemy. I said, you, sometimes the, the, the method that you take in presenting this, but then he said, Look, that's my nature. That is who I am. I'm argumentative. I'm, you know, he didn't say it, but basically I think what he's implying is, you know, he believes in what he has and it's science. For him, it's math. It's science. It's proven. So just get off your ass and either understand it, learn about it, or be quiet. That's Giovanni.
16:38 Okay, I love that you brought this up because I'm going to take the opposite angle here. Because I had a conversation with Giovanni in Bulgaria, I believe it was, where we didn't get to any form of agreement as far as I can remember. And I think the power law is bullshit through and through. And the reasoning is that physics and mathematics have very little to do with praxeology, which I think should be the basis for studying human action, and that all of these models can be destroyed. I am not saying that they're completely valueless. I just saying that they have nothing to do with economics If anything it economic assessment and risk assessment and such and they can have some validity there But conflating that with actual economics is super dangerous.
17:31 And this is where I think that words like scientific are super dangerous in this context, because humans do things with agency, with free will. You have no choice but to have free will. So you can never truly predict what a human being will do in the future. And therefore, all these economic models of what's going to happen in the future with the price of a thing are inherently super flawed and can be like they're always hyped too much. And people attribute too much value to them, I think.
18:14 And I think your soul is more in harmony with nature if you just don't give a fuck about these things. Like you do. You just sit on your stack and do art instead and don't even give a fuck if people buy it. I think that approach is a much more healthy way to live life than to be glued to charts every day and try to time the market, because that's a fool's endeavor in my eyes. So I would love to actually have Giovanni on and talk about this because our differences of opinion are vast, especially since he posted a long tweet.
18:56 Like back in Bulgaria, I don't believe he had any understanding of praxeology. But then he made a long tweet about the power law and how praxeology is wrong and why Mises was wrong and stuff like this. When he didn't even seem that well read up on it in the first place. Maybe I misinterpreted that. I'm not trying to bash the guy here. Just the idea that you can predict markets in that sense and call it economics, because I don't think you can. And I think I can prove a priori that you can't. So I'd love to have that debate with him. Well, we should talk about AI. I'll bet you've got some interesting thoughts on AI. Yeah, I wouldn't call them intelligent to begin with.
19:37 I can, you know, I can predict human behavior using power laws. I mean, I can. It's easy. You know, you can use it to predict the build outs of cities, infrastructure, you know, mammals, just ourselves, human beings. We share many components with other animals all based on power laws. You know, each one of us has about one point five billion heartbeats in us, whether it doesn't matter if it's a whale or a shrew. Obviously, they beat at different rates, but you got about all mammals have about 1.5 and then you just fall over. You're done. I can show that, you know, if you look at something like and I'm talking about scale now, because that's a really important part of the power laws, understanding scale and scale and variance.
20:23 And, you know, you can look at blood pressure, that same shrew and the same whale. They, you know, they have about the same blood pressure. You know, Whale's heart is as big as a Mini Cooper, about a ton. But what I'm trying to say is, the thing to think about, Newt, or just to put in the back of your mind is that markets, you know, and markets psychology, I think they move because of humans and human psychology. And if so, and you, again, you think of Bitcoin as a network and adoption, and you look at how the power law with its own reflexivity, the fact that you can, nobody draws that line that you see.
21:11 When you see that line on the chart that reflects the power law, nobody drew that line. It drew itself. And that's when I say math is math. And, you know, we'll see. I'll tell you what, we'll see in this particular cycle will probably be one of the most important cycles to see how that law goes forward. So you want to talk about AI too? Well, I'm just going to do a rebuttal here because I can agree with everything you said and still say that it has nothing to do with economics. It's risk assessment and not actual economics. And also that the fact that something has happened historically consistently can be a good tool in the human being's toolbox for predicting future events.
22:07 The sun has risen and set every single day of my life, so there's good reason for me to believe that it will continue to do so tomorrow. Sure. However, that is not, and especially when it comes to market, that is not proof of anything, because empiricism has no place in economics. You cannot predict accurately how markets are going to behave, because they're predicated on human beings voluntarily choosing to do one thing over another. So if you throw a human being, if you throw a rock into a lake, physics can tell you how long it will take for the rock to sink to the seabed, right?
22:50 To the bottom of the sea or the bottom of the lake. But if you throw a human being into a lake, you cannot predict at all what the human being will do. It can swim in either direction. It can sink to the bottom. It can bounce up again. It can start talking about, you know, politics in China or something. You don't know what a human being will do, and you can never know that to 100%. So I think the very fact that people call this economics and they call it science, to me, that's a very dangerous and slippery slope towards fiat economics. That's what Keynes did. He looked at the empirical data and said, just because this has happened historically, here's how we quote-unquote fix it.
23:36 instead of looking at it from first principles and take the full and go full Rothschild and say that all theft is wrong, period, and the state is a criminal, which is where I'm coming from. I kind of, you know, I like that. I mean, I do understand and kind of agree with what you're saying regarding markets and economists and attempting to somehow predict markets based upon either human behavior or, you know, past trends. And, you know, you mentioned or you asked originally, I mean, so that was one of the interesting conversations. But, you know, the other thing is, and I can't I don't think I can identify this guy on air because we had a pretty interesting conversation.
24:17 Everybody that is in Bitcoin probably would know who this guy is. But I got to sit or stand one on one at the bar with this guy. And I had the most incredible conversation about hallucinogenic drugs and mushrooms in particular. And, you know, I will tell you right now, it just kind of blew my mind. And I, as an artist, you know, I've thought about in the past, whether I would try something like that. And I think I would. I would just have to make sure that I had somebody, really good energy in a room, somebody that I either trusted as like a sitter or a traveler with me. And I think that in some time in my future, I can see that that's going to happen.
24:59 So that was kind of a mind-changing or altering event. And then, you know, the other thing is- Just a conversation about it? Oh, it was a pretty deep conversation. I mean- All right, yeah, yeah. Yeah, and it was a life, you know, I will tell you right now for this particular gentleman, it was a life-changing moment for him. He got an insight into something that had been so toxic in his life and he actually healed it. I mean, he fixed it to the point where I think it changed his life. So pretty interesting. And then, you know, the other thing is I had some conversations, a lot of conversations with our host, you and I with Tony.
25:40 And I thought that Tony, it's funny because Tony with the Bitcoin way has kind of a lot of my ideas have coalesced around his stance over the last two to three years. And I will tell you initially I kind of resisted Tony message a little bit I thought like Giovanni he was kind of just not ham but kind of like just very much blatant out there in your face kind of a viewpoint Quite frankly I think that he right I think that it just took time for me to understand where he was coming from. And quite frankly, I embrace that whole mindset. And if you're listening right now, I don't care where this conversation goes right now with newt and my mind just as important as running a node is you need to have a wallet you need to be able to interact with your node and you need to have bitcoin in self custody i have a lot of paper bitcoin and that paper bitcoin is basically worthless it's not anything i can ever count on the only thing i can ever count on is what i have in my possession yeah uh i tony and the bitcoin way have been uh based as fuck for the last couple of years i think and yeah thank you guys for the dinner and keep on doing what you're doing I think that's they're absolutely real Bitcoiners all of them I respect them a lot same they're great and Tony is worth listening to
27:13 for sure he has a very based take on what Bitcoin is for and how you should view it I agree with him on most things same yeah so so from one thing to another how how what are you working on art wise at the moment uh i saw this beautiful uh portrait oh no not a portrait what's what's the other one called when when the subject is looking to the side a profile or something kind of a profile yeah of amy edberg the bitsy chick from Stockholm, Sweden. And it's gorgeous. I mean, she's a beautiful woman and you depicted that beautifully, I think.
27:58 So what are you working on now? Well, I've always been a figurative painter, the human figure. And I think one of the reasons it's very difficult, probably the most, it is actually the most difficult thing to paint. And, you know, I follow a lot of classical, traditional techniques and methods of painting. I used to stretch all my own canvas and use white lead priming, but I stopped doing that a while ago. I was worried about health effects from using lead all the time. So I got away from that, but I still am using traditional Belgian primed linens, oil primed. You know, all my materials are archival and I really spend, I mean, I know what I'm doing. You know, after 10,000 hours, they say you can become a master. Well, you know what? I am a master of this craft. And I don't mind saying that because I'm not a master of a lot of things.
28:48 I'm definitely not a master at plumbing. You know, I don't consider myself a master of Bitcoin. I think that that's an even deeper dive as far as being able to understand it. But right now, I'm just really pumped. I just got back. I'm inspired. You know, I'm working with a couple of new models and trying some different techniques and really pushing myself in a different direction. And so I'm excited. And, you know, if you're a Bitcoiner out there, you need to find something that excites you. And it's sometimes it's not going to be Bitcoin. You know, you can only do so much Bitcoin before you just say, hey, what the I'm tired of Bitcoin today. And you need to find something in your life that gives you an outlet, a creative outlet, whether it's writing, music, you know, there's so many different ways to express yourself. Woodworking. I mean, it can be anything, making, you know, duck decoys or something. There are a million ways for you to do something that's just for you. And don't do it for money. Don't do it for likes. Don't do it for clicks. Don't do it for followers. Just do it because it's something inside you that you want to do. So right now, yeah, I'm on fire. I can't wait. As soon as we're done here, I'm going to turn the lights on in the studio. I'm going to get to work. I got something I'm working on right now. I'm really excited about it. Fantastic. I'd love to pick your brain on something that that I've thought of for the last couple of weeks just.
30:07 And creativity in general fascinates me and the creative process. Because as I say, you cannot know when creativeness strikes. You can never, when creativity will hit you, like you can never force it. You have to play. And I've listened to countless hours of creativity philosophy and creativity tips. My favorites are John Cleese and Trey Parker, like Trey Parker of South Park fame and John Cleese of Monty Python fame. I've heard Trey Parker talk about creativity, like they make the South Park episodes in six days before they air the episode, which is just mind blowing to me.
30:52 and he writes the script in two days. And he said a great unlocker for me was when I heard Trey Parker say that he could have worked on the script for two more months and he would have been 5% better. So it's diminishing returns. So instead he chooses to work fast and then get some momentum and get the new thing going every week and thereby getting better at the process. John Cleese had another great tip, which was not only do you need to not be interrupted when you're creative, you need to know that you're not going to be interrupted. And I figured out that that's why I've been writing my books in the mornings, because I know that my family is not up and they're not going to interrupt me. So that's why I work in the mornings and stuff like that.
31:35 So I'm super interested in the creative process. I've also heard Benny Anderson of ABBA say that the only way to write a good song is to be in the room at the piano when the song is there. And then you're like channeling the song, but it's actually in the room. I don't believe that to be literally true, but true creativity, when you really get a lightning in a bottle creative moment, certainly feels like it's not you, it's not your conscious self, it's something else flowing through you. That's how it feels to me. so so i've been thinking a lot about creativity and also yeah this is a long story but i need to i need this preamble to to get to the point where i'm actually asking a question yeah when i was a kid i used to i was a very creative kid so i used to do all sorts of projects but i could never finish them i would for instance uh tell myself that i was going to write a hundred page comic book, which resulted in me like folding and clipping a hundred pages together and then designing the cover and the first page. And then I got bored with it and I started the next project.
32:46 So throughout my adult life, and my parents pointed this out to me all the time, believe that, like, and my teachers and everyone around me, every adult said, yeah, you need to finish what you start and i was never like that as a kid so all my adult life i've been fighting that inner kid and actually uh following through on on the on the projects i start but lately now i'm approaching my it's my 50th birthday this fall so i'm approaching your kid yeah yeah but but i'm uh approaching that point and i'm i'm slowly realizing that i might have been fighting the the wrong side of myself all along because what i figured out uh you're doing talks at bitcoin conferences and stuff and and even writing is the the more i try to force it the worse it becomes so nowadays when i do a talk uh on stage about bitcoin or praxeology i i the less prepared i am the better the talk is usually so so so i've realized that this uh the not giving a fuck is an art form in itself and creativity is actually the literal opposite of productivity so when i write for instance like most of the actual work the coming up with all the ideas is done while i'm not sitting at the keyboard and and and typing the actual letters it's done before way before that and then i have to go into productive mode to to like materialize whatever creative work there is into reality but the actual
34:18 creative part of it, the important part, that's not work, that's not productiveness. It's the opposite. You have to let your mind play and really relax and just not think about anything and not force anything. And that's when you get the ideas. So this productivity being the opposite of creativity, and I've seen this In Bitcoin, there's a great misconception about, still don't worry, I'm getting to a question at the end here, I think. I've seen a lot of people, a lot of artists in Bitcoin, they conflate proof of work with proof of results.
35:03 So they focus on proof of work rather than anything else. So they think that if they just put enough work into something, then that makes it automatically good by some. But to me, that sounds exactly like Mark's labor theory of value and has nothing to do with if it's actually valuable to other people or not. It's rather the opposite. And I view proof of work in Bitcoin as an unfortunate means to a greater end. It would be much better if we could trust our fellow men with a money printer, but history shows that we can't. Everyone abuses the money printer. So we need to keep each other in check, and that's why we need the proof-of-work mechanism.
35:44 But it would be better if we didn't need that, if we could just trust other people to not inflate money whenever they get the chance. So the misconception, I think, is in thinking that proof of work is valuable in itself. And proof of results is sort of one of my favorite Picasso paintings. It's just a sketch of Don Quixote that he probably made in five minutes. but a lifetime of being picasso led up to him being able to just churn out that in five minutes you are touching on so many things so so this is what i love to pick your brain about is it do you agree with the statement that creativity is the opposite of productivity or am i on to something or am i just full of shit here fuck well listen you touched on so many things here I mean, God almighty. All right. Let's just let's go through some of the things that you discussed here. First off, you got to show up. OK, if you want to, again, master a craft, you do have to show up. Even if it's writing, you got to put some time in. Two, I do agree with what you said. It's nice to have a place that is yours alone where you know you won't be interrupted and you can concentrate on what you want to do.
37:07 Three, I'd also agree with what you said, touching on being paid or remuneration for what it is you produce and being able to separate yourself from that regime. I'd also would say that when you discuss what has value, then you need to think internally, because if you think about what has value in the outside world, you'll get you'll be twisted in your creativity. I can attest to that because back in the 90s, back in the 90s, I was with a gallery and it was they sold every painting I produced at shows.
37:54 I one time sold 44 paintings with commissions at one show. So what did that do to me? Well, it meant that I became. Twisted. I, the genre that was popular that I was selling meant that I had to stay within that genre. The gallery itself pressured me on prices so that I would keep my prices low and continue to crank out work. Like, you know, go poop me a painting. And it ended up taking the joy out of what I was doing. I can encapsulate the moment that this also occurred was when I painted this incredible scene of this woman standing there, her back to the viewer.
38:40 But in her hand, she had a cigarette. It was set in Europe and she had a cigarette in her hand. And the gallery said basically that, hey, I don't think we can sell that with a cigarette in there. And here's where I knew that I'd violated that first thing that Epictetus told us at the beginning of this podcast. And that is, I thought about painting out the cigarette. I guess the good news is that I didn't. And in fact, afterwards, occasionally I would paint somebody with a cigarette in their hand just because I basically wanted to say, go fuck yourself. And I still sold work there. But finally, I got to a point where I thought I've had enough of this. So all of these things that you've touched on, we're discussing right now. So let's finish up with the most important part, which is trying to conflate what proof of work is with creativity and production versus creativity.
39:32 You know, you mentioned before about the show South Park, but what you also probably should mention is the fact that that show ran for how many years? And that writer showed up. Yeah, they're on their 28th season and it's still the same team, the same core team that makes it, which is Matt and Trey and a handful of other people. And what did he do? he showed up he showed up every week probably when he didn't want to well uh there's a caveat to that he showed up every week for the weeks that they actually did the show which is just a couple of months in the spring and a couple of months in the fall and so so it's not every single day then again trey parker is a super uh work ethic guy like they do a bunch of other things they do movies and and you know this broadway musical and stuff on top of south park of course so so it's not that he didn't show up to other things but i think there was a lot of play involved and a lot of not doing south park for long uh periods time involved uh um what i'm trying to say newt is that if you're going to if you're going to produce something you've got to do you do if you're working you got to show up you got to put in the time and the work and the effort and well uh sorry for interrupting but uh the this is why i've changed my mind uh ever so slightly to the opposite and now pushing 50 and that is i think that's the easy part i think that men working men have that in them
41:07 inherently like it the the real guys i know they're all so semi-workaholic they're they're like default mode is working and then they allow themselves to do other things i know i'm like that and i know most of my bitcoin friends are like that already they work all the time and then they allow themselves to do other shit so so work work mode is sort of the default mode when you're not sleeping it sort of depends on how you define work but but i think that's very much more common than people think. And then people pound their chest because they're working harder than everyone else. But I don't necessarily think for successful people, that's generally not true. Most successful people already have it in them to work all the time. And I think if you want to be creative, you sort of have to get out of that bubble rather than the laziness bubble.
42:03 Well, continuing with what I was saying is that they showed up, they did the work. But the other thing is, what I was going to say is the other side, the flip side of that discussion is this. If you put an artist in front of a canvas and he thinks that the amount of work that he puts into the canvas will somehow increase its value, what you find is, and we've seen this over decades now, this runs in like cycles. You'll find artists that think, back in the 70s, we called it photo realism. And basically what it was is you would have a cadre of artists that would sit in front of a canvas and try to paint every pixel that they could of an image. And of course, almost always these images were photographs. So basically at the end of it, as good as you could ever get, you could produce a fucking photograph. And you know what? Most of that worked from those 70s. Today, it's either in garbage dumps or it's not appreciated. That's not what creativity is.
43:09 So getting back to your discussion and to kind of think along these lines, when you discuss proof of work trying to conflate like Bitcoin proof of work with what creativity is I think probably gets you off on the wrong foot And maybe that kind of what you hinting at is the fact that the creative part doesn incorporate, it's not inside that proof of work. It comes from somewhere else. Now, where, I don't know. And, you know, for instance, I will say, you know, so I'm a lot older than you. I mean, I am a lot older than you. And looking back on my life, one of the things I've learned is, yes, I definitely was more along the lines of what we call in the U.S. a type A personality, somebody that works hard. But you know what? As time has gone by, I'm beginning to realize and understand, maybe you see this too, is that time is finite. It's short. And when you're 50 and you're looking in front of you, you're thinking to yourself, you know what?
44:15 the things that I may have valued as a young man, somehow I need to look, I need to zoom out and I need to look at those. I need to find what is the purpose of life? Where does, and maybe when you're looking at that, that maybe that's where you find creativity. What is my purpose? So I don't know if any of that answers some of the things you were asking about or that you brought up, but that's kind of my take on that uh don't i don't mind if it's not a an answer to the actual question but but it's a it's a valuable answer to me i mean uh i love this discussion because because i find it so fascinating because it differs so much from from human to human what creativity is to them uh I mean, we have super different views of what that is.
45:12 Where was I going with this? I had something on my mind. because you're putting in all this effort just to make something that a camera can do better. Yeah, well said. And the point of art is not to be a camera. Of course it isn't. It's a capture of feeling in the moment and make a time capsule in a way of how you felt at that point in time and conveying that feel. Like to me, my main art form is writing songs and doing music. I'm releasing an album soon, by the way, so you'll hear some of it at some point.
45:52 I can't wait. I'm definitely going to get it. But that, and of course, the Bitcoin stuff has taken a lot from that lately. And I wouldn't say that I'm good enough to call myself a musician or an artist or anything like that. I do it for my own sake. But it's like, to me, it's a way of communicating feelings that you can't communicate with words. Yeah, I love that. I love that, Newt. You know, the thing is that you've said a couple really important things, which is basically, you know, what am I doing this for? You know, that's really kind of the key. I mean, who are you? And, you know, when we talk about work, sometimes we have to realize that, yeah, if you love doing something, then you have to balance that in life with what you can either be paid for. Have you ever, are you familiar with Ikigai, the idea? Absolutely. I wrote an article about that, the Bitcoin Ikigai. It was one of the first articles I wrote. So you understand where I'm going with this. You know, first off, you obviously have a talent. I've heard you play. So you have, there's a talent, your creativity is in whoever you are. If you're listing this, you could be any, I have no idea what your creativity is, but you've got some. So you have your creativity. And then on the other hand, you should probably be
47:25 thinking about, you know, is this something that makes a difference in the world? And it doesn't have to be something that you build that creates a pathway for Bitcoin to be adopted faster. I'm not talking about that. When I say, when I'm saying good for the world, I just mean, just puts, it's a, it's something that the world values or, or almost has a need. Sometimes you don't even know that the world needs it. And art for me, my painting, I think, fills that. I know that I produce work that isn't going to end up in a garbage can. And, you know, I'm working on stuff that's two to 300 years easily before it needs to be cleaned and restored. So for centuries, that model behind me, I've got a painting I just finished there with her. I mean, that model will be, she'll be dead. I'll be dead. You know, everything usually lasts only three, three generations. I don't care if you've got a beer can collection. I don't give a shit if you've got a great photographs collection, whatever. Usually about three generations is where it ends up in a garbage can. And getting back to Ikigai, the reason I mentioned that is because you also have to balance off what you can earn a living with. I'd have to say that this is where people fall down because they they're trying to make their creativity pay. And as soon as you do that again, just fall back to how we started the podcast. And, you know, that quote, if soon as you do that, you've got an issue there. If you can just somehow separate that feeling inside you of being wanting
49:00 to create something just to create. I, you know, for me, just for me, I'll say that's where that's Where it lies When I'm in that mindset Where I'm just doing What I want to do And I don't give a shit What happens with it That's where I'm At my most creative And where I'm having My most fun too So That's just some thoughts Yeah Would you say that You're compelled to paint? Like does it feel like You have to? Is it optional you think? Or do you have This Is the urge to paint so strong That you just can't deny it And just have to do it? That's a good question because then it makes you think to yourself, you know, artists have a reputation for being, you know, temperamental, depressed, moody.
49:51 And I'd have to say, I don't know what it is because, you know, I've been hanging around artists for decades now. And I know from my own personal experience that there's some truth to that. But I also know that when I've become blocked where I just can't seem to work and I think it's never going to come back, it always does. There's some moment in my life when I'm thinking, I got to start painting again. I have a feeling that if you stop playing music or stop writing, you just rage quit. I bet within six months you'd be back because sometimes it's just inside you. I mean, and most people have that new, I mean, some, most people that you talk to, if you really spend time with them and just really listen to them, they'll, at some point you'll realize that there are things that they really want to do that they're just interested in just as a human being.
50:46 It could be, you know, just making pottery or could just be, you know, so many different ways you can express yourself. And I think people need that, especially with the world that's coming, the AI world. I think to express yourself is so important. Yeah, yeah. Real stupidity is our last That's a paraphrasing Terry Pratchett, one of my favorite authors, said that real stupidity beats artificial intelligence every time. And I think it's a very powerful quote. I like that. I view Bitcoin as real stupidity, like defending against AI in a way.
51:28 But anyway, yeah, the thing you were alluding to before, I think like being a sellout is a big, like you should definitely strive to not be a sellout and just do things because you get paid. You think that you're going to get paid to do them. But there's a thing there, I think, that is kind of hard to navigate. And that is appreciation. Because if you get appreciated for some of your work, I think it inevitable that that will influence what you choose to focus on in the future Like if you make something and other people give you appreciation for it and say that it good then they chime in You think it good and they do too Then you going to do more of that And there's a way to view money as nothing but that.
52:14 Money is sort of, I appreciate this with an extra amount of exclamation marks after it. There's really nothing more than that. It's just a way of showing more and more appreciation. Well said. So where's the line? Like where do you draw the line between doing what people want you to do and doing what you want to do? I mean, if you look at artists like musicians and writers and painters historically, this has always been like the struggle, the inner struggle every single artist is battling with, I think. So how do you prevent yourself from becoming a sellout? Yeah, that's the question.
52:56 Yeah, that is the question, isn't it? because I did become a sellout. And you nailed it. That's exactly why. It was the compensation or the, actually, I didn't need the money at the time in the 90s when I was working for that gallery. I was flying as an airline pilot and I was making a good money, had a lot of time off. You know, I was flying all over the world. Things were great. So I didn't need the money, but it was that benchmark of success that you alluded to. And that's a slippery, you know, So it's almost, I mean, you're talking about some really deep philosophical discussions about what it means to be a man or a woman. I don't mean just a man, but the idea of what it means to be who you are inside internally.
53:39 That's a really hard discussion. You know, in fact, speaking of men, I mean, you know, as a man, that's a tough discussion too. I mean, what does it mean to be a man? And how do you somehow navigate the world that has expectations of you or wants to put you in a certain bucket and you resist? You know, Bitcoiners as a whole, we are a group that are, I don't want to just use toxic because a lot of people aren't toxic. But, you know, we have a strong independent sense where we are free thinkers or deep thinkers. and you're touching on the very core of what it means to be internally yourself, to know who you are.
54:27 And the only way to do that is through self-introspection. I mean, I don't know. Do you meditate? Yeah, sometimes. I think there's, yeah, not as much now as maybe 10 years ago, but I was kind of deep into meditation. I did it not for super long, but I did it quite consistently over a couple of years. Just before I wrote my first Bitcoin book and I still had my Fiat job and stuff, there was a ferry ride. I lived on an island, so I had to take an 11-minute ferry every day back and forth, morning and afternoon. So I meditated while I was on that, and I find it very valuable.
55:08 I think there's the philosophical armchair philosopher bullshit I want to spew about that is that I think dropping your ego is the – that's how you find your true self. So the ego is sort of the opposite of the self. And you want to, but this is why it's so fascinating with this whole being a sellout or not, because I think as a man and as a provider, as a family man, if you will, and I'm not going to filter this through any postmodern bullshit. As a family man, you want to provide value to others. And ironically enough, that's how you get successful.
55:51 Like successful people are successful because they add value to others or because they're assholes, which you can be also in fiat land. In Bitcoin, it's harder. But like if you're honestly wealthy, then you have become honestly wealthy because you provided a lot of value to others. So I think that that's inherent in us in some way. And I think art is that too. Like if I write a song or you draw a painting and paint a painting, you want other people to see it. You don't want it to just sit there in your garage. Like you want to show it to the world at some point, right? So, yeah.
56:32 Yeah, you're dropping a lot of truth or not. You're dropping a lot of big thoughts here. So, you know, I have a quote that it's my quote. And I say to people sometimes, you know, the ego seeks windows where the mind builds walls. And, you know, it. Love that. Well, and if you will just let go of your ego, the walls will fall away. You'll be standing outside. I, you know, I, the best thing that ever happened to me was a really, really nasty period in my life about a decade ago. a little bit more in a decade now. And I mean, it, it, uh, kind of like broke me.
57:15 I was at the end of my rope. You know, I told you I was an airline pilot. The airline had gone into bankruptcy. They stole my pension. The great financial crisis had hit. I was living in a dinky house in a kind of a, not a great neighborhood, just trying to get along, just trying. I was actually just trying to get from one month to the next in bills. I'd gone through a really bad, divorce. I couldn't make my alimony payments. I mean, my whole life was just coming undone. And I was heartbroken. I mean, I was devastated. I remember, sometimes I couldn't even, and I'm telling people this because I know I just was talking to somebody. There are people out there that are having a tough time right now. And it was bad enough where I couldn't get out of bed.
58:02 I mean, there were some mornings I just laid there. And what I'm going to tell people right now is the best thing that ever happened to me was going through that period in my life. And in the biblical sense, it was like sitting in your ashes, like sitting in the ashes, you know, the Garden of Gethsemane, that you're out there just going through this pain because you have to. And, you know, here's another thing. if you're going through this tough time, nobody's gonna fix it. Nobody can save you. People will come up to you and they'll say, oh, you just need to do this. You need to do that. It'll pass and all this stuff. It doesn't help. Nothing's gonna help.
58:43 You just have to get through this. You get through it by getting through the next five minutes. Then you get through the next hour. Then you get through the morning. And then someday you find out you've gotten through the day and the evening comes and it's rough. But then finally you get to a point where you get through days. And on the other side of that, on the other side of this, I lost, I, my ego was gone. I mean, my, my ego was just gone. I didn't have it. And I've never, I've never thought, I've never thought the same way about myself. You know, I came from a community where I was a fighter pilot, top gun pilot, you know, airline pilot. I was, you know, I was like top of the mountain, king of the hill. And I really thought a lot about myself. I thought I was pretty important in life. Best thing that ever happened to me was have that ego just destroyed. And then all the walls, they just fell down. I was standing outside. I looked around. I thought, wow, this is pretty cool down here. And now I can just relax. And, you know, I'm talking my ass off here, but, you know, I don't know if you saw me at the concert or conference, but when I meet people, I just be quiet. I just, I love to just listen to people. And it's just, It's such a gift.
59:54 Yeah, I was almost disappointed with that because I wanted to hear you talk. And I'm tired of hearing myself talk. But you asked all the questions when we met in Prague. Yeah, but you know what? I learned a lot from you. You know, the same thing with that one person I was telling you about, you know, the discussion around mushrooms and ayahuasca and stuff. You know, I never would have learned any of his story. And, you know, he kind of maybe changed my life a little bit. So I just was quiet, put my ego away. I didn't have to impress him. And, you know, we talked about being a man. You know, if you're a confident man, and I'm just saying this to the young Bitcoiners out there because I, you know, I'm old. I don't have to worry about it anymore.
1:00:35 But there a lot of young Bitcoiners out there that are dating or not dating or want to date or maybe they given up But you know I going to give you some advice When you find somebody and you want to date them you want to go out and do something together you know be confident Know who you are as a man You don need to impress people You should be talking a lot less You should be listening a lot more and make somebody feel important. You know, get to know their story. And here's another thing, too. If you're smart like that, you'll see if there's any red flags that come up because they'll talk themselves into it. You'll know that person pretty well at the end of a dinner or say you're just out for a walk or something like that, or just meeting somebody casually, maybe in a bar, let them talk. And then you'll learn a lot about them. But if they're really a neat person at the end of that, you know what, they're going to think you're pretty damn cool. And they're going to know that you're confident. You don't need to sit there and brag about yourself and what you've done and what kind of shit you got. I met somebody at the airport on the way back from Prague and I was getting ready to get on the plane and stuff. And this guy was talking to me. And within five minutes, I mean, he had basically told me all of his important things, how important he was, the business he had and his offices and everything.
1:01:45 And I thought, you know what? You're a jackass. You know, you're a whole, you're not anybody I want to spend any time with. And I was thrilled to death when I got on board the plane and he walked past me and went to the back. I was thought, oh, this is great, buddy. Adios. So just remember that. That is such a good story because it sort of reflects this creativity being the opposite of productivity. Like a guy, I can think that that was a productivity maximalist and a creativity minimalist. What do you think? I agree. I mean, yeah. Yeah, there's so many insights here. And this is why I was excited to talk to you because I know you're philosophical like that too.
1:02:28 You're much like me in that sense. Like you like to explore these topics and I love it. Yeah. Yeah, it is so important. You know, the reason I mentioned, we didn't really discuss it much, but the reason I mentioned meditation is because when you meditate, you're not trying to get any deep insight. You're not sitting there trying to fix, you know, you're not, truthfully, what you really want to do is just let your mind go. And, but the reason I mentioned it is because I found out that the more I'm engaging in it, the more I'm able to focus outside of that period. And all you need is 10 minutes. And it allows me to more clearly focus on some of the issues. And quite frankly, like we said, coming back from Prague, this is a chance for me.
1:03:10 I'm going to do a lot of self-reflection and introspection this year. That's my goal. Yeah, I mean, that's, if you've truly learned how to meditate properly, you can get back into that mind state pretty easily afterwards, I feel. That's why the main reason I don't do it that much anymore is because I feel like more zen as a default mode or I can get back to it pretty quickly if I get angry or irritated or something. It's like, oh, no, no, no, maybe you're the idiot here and maybe you should just calm down. Because if you're in an argument, no matter who you're in an argument with, you should have the insight that you can change yourself, but you cannot change the other person.
1:03:57 So you can change your way of doing the argumentation, but you cannot change the other person's mind with anything but that, like that's the tool you have. You can change yourself. You cannot change the situation around you, this whole Marcus Aurelius thingy. Well, I don't think I'm quite at the good point that you are. I think that's probably my biggest failing. You know, I try to live my day every day, honor, integrity, strength. And then I add kindness, you know, four words. That's why I try and live, honor, integrity, strength. But the last word is kindness. And I think I kind of put that one like on the, it's kind of a smaller bucket. And quite frankly, I have to say that's my, if you know, if anybody were asking me, what's your biggest failing or regret, I'd have to say that's the one.
1:04:45 But I'm doing better. I mean, I am doing better. But I don't think they are mutually exclusive, any of these things. If you're truly kind and someone asks you for your honest opinion on something they did, you don't wrap it in ribbons. You say what you think because that's much more valuable to them than someone just licking ass and saying, oh, that's beautiful. like it's funny how you and i our discussion here is really revolved around one word which is integrity yes i mean in my mind in my mind it is integrity which you know everything from whether you're talking about selling out or you know proof of work or artistic creativity or all of these different things you know integrity is it's that it's that key point is that you know it's when you're up there in the mirror shaving and you look at yourself and you man you you feel good about yourself or you really don't, if you were to ask yourself, you know, do I feel good about who I am? And, you know, I've mentioned before, I mean, you're a kid. I don't have that many blocks to mine here on this planet. And when I'm done, you know, I'm going to look back on my life and hopefully I'll have a moment to just reflect before I'm gone. And I hope that I can be honest with myself and that I can feel like it was a life well lived and, you know, that I contributed something yeah i think the the thing you alluded to before the the depression period
1:06:15 there or whatever you may call it like i mean i i don't think i ever had a proper depression i think i was close uh once or twice in my life i mean i've lived for 50 years now so it would be surprising if i hadn't but uh uh when dumped by my former girlfriend and stuff like that like way way back when uh but uh i i did have a couple of near-death experiences where i thought i was going to die a handful of them throughout my life like including hurricanes on the north atlantic so so uh and i think i learned a lot from those because any any reminder you get that you're you're an ant on a spinning rock until you aren't like like you you have your life is super fragile and like then you become grateful for all of it uh and you're reminded that you ought to be grateful for all of it because otherwise you miss your chance of enjoying yourself like if you don't enjoy the moment there is nothing else to enjoy than the moment the future and the past are that they are uh vast and they're one is one direction and one's the other direction and we're in the very intersection that isn't even a point it's it's just a nothingness in between and that's where everything that ever happened in your life happened.
1:07:35 Wow. Wow, dude. So you need to appreciate that. You know, yeah, man, again, I'll just say, you know, I stopped counting at 15, I think, near-death experiences. In fact, I've got, I don't think you can see in the frame, you can see the jet up there above my shoulder, but right below that, there's a little thing in there. It's got a news clipping. It says Navy pilot ejects safely or something like that. You know, I, I, I celebrate that day every year because yeah, you know what? Life is precious and it's short and it's fragile. I mean, it's, it's, and I, you should be able to answer at some point, you know, are you comfortable with who you are, whether it's being a man or, or being a human, I don't care how you want to frame it.
1:08:23 You should be able to be comfortable because that can happen at any moment. You know, I just lost a buddy recently and it was terrible. I mean, you know, it was just instant. He was alive one minute, actually one second, and then he was tragically killed and stupid too, stupid fucking accident, absolutely unnecessary. And, you know, I just, I wish I could somehow give that gift to everybody that's listening right now or watching, if I could give you that gift, that idea of to embrace and how precious life is, I would give it to you right now. And you wouldn't waste any more time. Every day, you'd be looking around and going, you know, I'm enjoying my life. Even if life's going bad and sucks, you know, you still, there's something about it. You just, you are grateful for certain things. If you're walking, you're just grateful that I can walk today. You know, I just about ended up, you know, I could have, I've had some experiences in the Navy, I could have ended up not walking ever again the rest of my life, and I made it.
1:09:31 So, yeah, I mean, you're just touching on a lot of deep things here, buddy. Yeah, as I said, that's why I wanted you on, because I feel a connection here that you're able to talk about these things and enjoy talking about them. Not a lot of people do. So, yeah, we're coming up on an hour and 10 minutes. Before we close this out, which we don't need to do right now, by the way, we could go for another 20 minutes, as long as you want. But is there anything we haven't talked about yet that you'd like to have a conversation about?
1:10:15 Any subjects in particular? Yeah, I think that, you know, I started this out, this conversation with us, you know, discussing about how I think I'm going to be a little bit more forthright. Some people might say that I don't hold back as it is, but I think I'm going to be more forthright about some of the discussions that are going on or need to be happening in the community. And, you know, I think we touched on BIP-110 and Core, which is great. I think also, you know, on these Bitcoin treasury companies, We need to probably touch on that. And, well, you know, they're in the news right now, obviously.
1:10:57 And my focus here is that, you know, from this last cycle, we touched a little bit when we were discussing Giovanni. We touched a little bit about Plan B and that model and the last cycle and how people really got hurt. and as these financial products are being built on top of Bitcoin, you've got to understand that there are some people who are going to get really hurt in this environment. They already have. I mean, if you look at Nakamoto and Naka and where that went, you know, I've got somebody, we follow each other on X, and I mean, he's lost probably, I think, half a million dollars of his own money in that company. And that's a common thread with a lot of people.
1:11:39 and I, at the time, knew something. Somebody asked me about investing about it privately and I said I wouldn't touch that. It was at the time before it came out. I said I wouldn't touch that and I never really discussed it outside of those loops and now we've got another one that's going to be launching here. I think it's BSTR, which is another one of these treasury companies And this one, of course, is Adam Back will be behind this product. And, you know, I don't know if you're following any of the reporting that's been done on that regarding Hodlnott's discussion on the Blockstream mining note, which is, you know, in the past.
1:12:26 This is how they've been raising money. Have you been following that? Of course. Of course. I follow it closely. Yeah. And I love to hear people's opinions about it. I'm a skeptic by nature, and I'm skeptic towards all sides. So I'm skeptic about the, first of all, about the product. I don't really believe in Bitcoin treasury companies in general. And I'm skeptic about the company, Blockstream, but I'm also skeptic about the accusations. I'm skeptic towards all sides of the arguments Let's just say that Well, I'll tell you what For the people that aren't listening there There's been some reporting that's come out recently That the gentleman, their CIO, Christopher Cook For the Bitcoin mining note Was convicted, he's a convicted felon and it was for mail fraud, I believe.
1:13:31 And I don think that ever been disclosed in any paperwork that I am aware of or at least I haven seen it And you know there documentation that shows that he has spent tremendous amounts of money And if you're curious what this what we're talking about here, basically, it's think of it as like almost cloud mining where you're renting out hash rate. Well, if you look at that organization, I mean, their hash rate right now should be off the charts. I mean, they should be producing enough hash rate that we should have no trouble finding that. So you say you're skeptical. So, you know, I would just say that if right now I think what Blockstream needs to do is they need to address this issue, you know, first and foremost.
1:14:18 And, you know, if I'm blowing smoke up people's asses, then go ahead and show the pool account hash rate. Show it. You can show that. It's not hard. You know, show us the power contracts you've got down in Texas and everywhere. Show us the proof that you're actually mining. You know, show us the ASICs that you have in inventory. I mean, do it. You know, give us the give us the auditor reports. Find and show me where if if this is the right cook and he's actually a felon. Show me where this is disclosed. It's a fitting surname, right? so all i'm saying is you know people are going to be hurt i think and already have been and you know i'm not discussing strategy i i don't have you know i still have stock or equity and and strategy so maybe i'm biased and you should just tell me to go you know screw myself but you should probably sell it what's that you should probably sell it and buy bitcoin instead Well, you know what?
1:15:25 Hey, guess what? I'm going to tell you something. That's probably good advice. And if anybody's listening, I would echo that advice. Remember what we said at the start of this conversation. You know, you have to realize because of my history and how the world that I grew up in, a lot of my history involves pension funds, which I still do have pension funds and other avenues. 401ks, which is a very big investment vehicle in the U.S. and equities and stuff. You know, all of it's in Bitcoin, but it's paper Bitcoin. It's basically a promise. I don't have any Bitcoin through those avenues.
1:16:05 None. That's not my Bitcoin. The only Bitcoin I have is a Bitcoin that I have put away in cold storage. That's my Bitcoin. So maybe rather than discussing any of these treasury companies or where they're going, what we should really say to people is if you're serious about having wealth in the future that is yours, that cannot be seized, that has now no counterparty risk. It used to be gold. You used to be able to say that about gold if you held the physical gold. But at the same time, if you want something where you can actually cross borders with it and keep your wealth intact, especially in a digital dystopian prison being built by AI, then you have to have Bitcoin and Bitcoin in cold storage.
1:16:55 You need to run a node. You need to have a wallet that you know how can interact with a node. You are truly sovereign then. And until that, you're just you're like me. You're just, I don't know, virtue signaling with paper products. Yeah. Yeah. All of these paper Bitcoin companies and quote-unquote solutions, they remind me of pension funds that the banks in Sweden used to advertise for like 20 years back. And the ads always featured young women. So they were targeting young women, women in their early 20s, to start saving for their pensions.
1:17:39 And why is that? Well it because women are not as prone to taking risk as men to begin with statistically So it probably easier to sell pension fund FUD or pension FUD to younger women And then, of course, the banks could reinvest that money and guarantee a certain profit that probably wouldn't even cover the inflation in the end. And I think a product like Stretch reminds me of that because it's promising 11% per year unless something goes to shit.
1:18:21 And there's a lot of counterparty risk. But 11% per year so that Saylor can get all the additional percent that would come from every Bitcoin cycle. And that is, to me, buying that product seems very ill-advised because not only are you excluding yourself from the actual super-duper gains that you could have gotten from holding real Bitcoin instead, you're also taking on like three levels of counterparty risk because you're trusting Saylor to not change his mind or die for that matter. because we don't know what happens to strategy's stuff after Saylor's gone.
1:19:04 Like he's a benevolent leader there, I guess. And you're trusting strategy to actually have the Bitcoin they have, which they have custodied with Coinbase. So you're trusting Coinbase to actually have that Bitcoin in custody. And you're trusting whatever American institution that surveys Coinbase. Coinbase, that audits Coinbase, audits is the word. So in the end of the day, you're trusting some guy at Coinbase to hold the Bitcoin for all of these billions of dollars worth of Bitcoin for this guy in three levels of counterparty risk.
1:19:48 And just to get a lower yield than you would have had, had you just taken the Bitcoin into self-custody yourself. So I think it's a totally moronic product and only a very naive boomer would, no offense, but would fall for such a thing. What's your take? That's me. I definitely was a naive boomer because about four months ago, I did have a bunch of cash and I stuck it in there. And then I actually bought it. Remember when Bitcoin first dropped down to 59K? But did you buy a stretch or did you buy MSDR? stretch. And, uh, MSTR went down to about 107 a share and STRC came off the peg, dropped down to about 93. And I bought at the time I had cash and I thought, I'm just going to stick it in here. I'll go through the first dividend cycle and take it out. So it worked out great for me, made a lot of money, but guess what you, I think you're right. I mean, I, I think that cause for instance, now that it's off the peg, I could, if I wanted to, I could raise cash and stick some in there, but I'm not comfortable doing it right now. My pushback to the sailor hero thing is that I think Fong's done a great job and that I almost think that they're in a position now where sailor's not as important. And the other thing is if last year when I stood up there and I asked about core V30 and versus knots, I don't think some people in the audience were happy when I asked sailor that because they were there for something else. It was a small gathering. This
1:21:22 year, I missed the VIP with him because I was down on a panel. Well, guess what? If there's anybody out there that got this guy's ear or strategy, there's two things I was going to ask him and I'm going to ask him. I'll tell you right now, it's not going to stop if I ever get a chance. And those two things are this, you know, I'm a strategy. I hold their stock, MicroStrategy, now strategy. I do hold some of that stock still. And I've been a stockholder for a long time in that company. And there are two things that I'm going to ask Santa to bring me this Christmas. And if not you going to have to explain to me why strategy can do this And that is you already touched on it One self Tell me why strategy doesn have the ability to self Explain it to me like I'm an idiot.
1:22:04 And then two, I want to see published proof of reserves. If you're going to be a digital capital reserve, basically almost like a central bank in Bitcoin, then show me what you hold. And the other thing is, take away that honeypot. Stop using Coinbase Fidelity. So, you know, looking back, I mean, I've, you know, I invested in strategy years ago when they first came into the, you know, their, I guess it was 2020 when they first decided they were going to put Bitcoin on the balance sheet.
1:22:45 And, you know, yes, I agree with you wholeheartedly. You know that I feel Bitcoin and self-custody is the way to go. But for an old boomer like me, and I'm sure there are other old boomers out there, you know, a lot of us have pension funds. We've got insurance products. We've got, you know, 401ks, all kinds of things that we're invested in. And strategy still plays a small part. I'm not using stretch right now. I wouldn't get into that because I'm a little concerned. I want to see that thing, whether it's going to come back onto the peg or not. Yeah, I mean, good luck with all of it. I'm not condemning any of these actions. I just want to speak my mind.
1:23:26 Yeah, but you're probably disappointed in me. You're probably going, that damn Jethro. No, no, no, no, no, not at all. You're still one of the basest boomers I know of, so you get a pass, of course. Thank you. yeah uh what else what else haven't we talked about that that's about you know that's about it i'm gonna get back i'm gonna start painting here in a minute as soon as we're done i'm gonna turn on the lights and guy got my paints out already that painting back there is pretty much finished uh i've got one other that i'm working on that's really cool and uh i can't wait i'm gonna get started on that can we can we see it closer or is it no it's hard to move right now but i'll tell you what, I'll post a picture of it later.
1:24:09 I'm going to be working on it. Fantastic. Fantastic. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Beautiful and hope to see you soon again, man. When will that be? Well, I'm going to do Bitblock Boom. I'm going to do Prague. I've already signed up. I'm going to go to Prague again. I may do one other conference. Also, when Madeira comes up in 2028, I'm going to go to Madeira. And that's probably it. All right. No plans for going to El Salvador anytime soon? Actually, I have thought about that. No, I have thought about that. I want to see it again. I need to get back there. And it's been on my mind. It's funny that you should mention that.
1:24:50 So that might, yeah, that could be definitely a player. I'm going late November, it looks like, for Bitcoin Historical. All right. I think I'm just going to put a little note here to myself and reach out to me as it gets closer, okay? Yeah, sure. All right. Absolutely. Where can people find you online? Just type my name in Google. You'll see me. I come up as two things, a Bitcoiner and an artist. Fantastic. Not an airline pilot then. No, only that. Okay. Yeah. Great chat, man. I absolutely loved it. Thanks very much for coming on.
1:25:32 And always lovely to chat with you and get deep into these subjects. of the self and what artists and all of the other stuff. So take care. I'll see you. Be good, buddy. This has been the Bitcoin Infinity Show. You should brush your teeth and do all the other things. Goodbye. Thank you.
Fountain
YouTube
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
RSS Feed