Why Bitcoin Miners Ignored BIP-110 with Bob Burnett | Bitcoin Infinity Show #223
Bob Burnett joins the Bitcoin Infinity Show to talk about life after BIP-110, from mining the very first BIP-110 signaling block with Barefoot Mining to why he stepped back in June and why he sees no path to success for the Blake2b fork. As Ocean's newly elected chairman, Bob explains why most big Bitcoin miners never seriously considered the soft fork, how FPPS mining pools trade a slice of revenue for predictability compared to TIDES, and why hashrate is shifting from public mining companies toward smaller independent miners using DATUM. Knut and Bob also dig into capping the SegWit discount to fight spam, the difference between miners and hashers, and what corporations might look like on a Bitcoin standard.
Connect with Bob:
Connect with Us:
https://www.bitcoininfinityshow.com/
https://bitcoininfinitystore.com
https://twitter.com/BtcInfinityShow
https://twitter.com/knutsvanholm
https://twitter.com/lukedewolf
Thanks to our sponsors - check out their websites for info:
Invity: https://www.invity.io/ - Use Code INFINITY!
Bull Bitcoin: https://app.bullbitcoin.com/registration/infinity
BitBox: https://bitbox.swiss/infinity - Use Code INFINITY for 5% off!
Bitcoin Adviser: https://content.thebitcoinadviser.com/freedom
The Bitcoin Infinity Show is a Bitcoin podcast hosted by Knut Svanholm.
The Freedom Footprint Show is a Bitcoin podcast hosted by Knut Svanholm and Luke de Wolf.
In each episode, we explore everything from deep philosophy to practical tools to emit freedom dioxide to expand your freedom footprint!
0:00 Bob, a warm welcome back to the Bitcoin Infinity Show. Nice to have you back. Hi, Knut. Great to see you. Nice to be back here. Thank you. Yeah, it's been quite a while since we last spoke. I think we were going to talk about, you know, if mining is possible on Mars or something, and then we cut off the pod just before. So, but we won't, I don't think we'll talk about that this time around too. We'll have to save something. That's a good one though. That's a good one. It is a good one. Yeah, the center of hash and all of that. Now, of course, I want to talk to you about, first of all, congratulations on being elected chairman of the board for Ocean.
0:44 Well, thank you. Thank you. I am excited about it, but, you know, it was not what I sought. But, you know, obviously change was imminent in the organization. And I think what Ocean does, and I'm sure we'll talk about it more, is essential to Bitcoin operating properly going forward. And so it's important that that mission stay on track. And frankly, it got off track. And so we need to focus it. Yeah, I've been looking forward to this conversation for a long time.
1:30 I was pro the fork and so were you at one point I think at least pro the soft fork I didn't make too many predictions about how likely it was to come through or anything I was pro the soft fork for other reasons than just game theory reasons I hoped that more people would buy that narrative and cling on to it and just saw it as a very modest thing to do, like a very small, what mechanic called it, a milk chocolate soft fork. I kind of like that term. It didn't do very much, so why not just implement it?
2:10 But now here we are. Things played out the way they did. I get a lot of comments in my comments from both sides. Of course, the Blake 2 beers now view me as a cop-out. And I see these comments about I'm only having the position that I have because I need the sponsorship money and the views and whatnot, which I giggle at a bit because, first of all, I don't get that much sponsorship money. And also, I was not first and foremost a podcaster, and I will never let any such incentives change my views on anything.
2:55 And if you want proof of that, all I have for you is trust me, bro. But I hope that if you listen to enough of these conversations, you'll understand that these are honest conversations. And I try to pick guests that I view as honest people, including yourself. And so just getting that out of the way, I hope that people from both sides of this can enjoy these conversations and hopefully be able to have a bit more of a neutral view of what actually happened. Yeah, there's a long preamble here, but the way I see it, if Core V30 hadn't been released the way it was released, and if they had just refrained from doing that small change that no one except spammers really asked for, then we would still have had all of those great Bitcoiners that are now forking off on the main chain.
3:57 The soft fork wouldn't have even been a thing. So first of all, do you agree with that view? Was it Core's fault that this happened? Or like, how do you view that? I think that the impetus for the BIP-110 movement, if we might want to call it that, was rooted in that decision to change Op return in Core V30. I think that, and I still think to this day, that the justification for it was technically incorrect that now was it motivated because of you know trying to help spammers uh in citria and i i don't think it's fair for me to to assume anything like that or project anything like like that on somebody because i don't have evidence of that but um i understand why people would be suspicious about it.
5:02 And I think that as Bitcoiners, there's a lot of tendency to leap to conspiracy theorist type stuff. And that happens on both sides, by the way. I've noticed. So, you know, and I've even been the subject of some of those, you know, which we can maybe talk about later with, with is tether taking over ocean or like there's some of that sort of stuff that has happened to me recently. But certainly V30 was the impetus. And, you know, I, if we kind of go to the root cause, there's, there's a fundamental belief, I think that still exists within core and a lot of the people that have been very supportive of core that, that it doesn't really matter and you know we shouldn't we should just acquiesce as as happened so BIP 110 came out of that and you know as you said in your preamble I guess I give a little of mine too is you know I I was a supporter of BIP 110 because I there were several reasons um one reason um was that I think we needed a reset. It was clear that there was a massive divide occurring. And I thought BIP-110 and the temporary nature of BIP-110 was an opportunity for us to maybe come back together.
6:37 I was hoping it would be a coalescing function and not a dividing function. But it obviously ended up being the opposite of that. But other reasons that I supported it, even though I thought it had warts, but because of its temporary nature, I didn't think those, I thought those warts were less ugly than the warts of staying on Core V30. So I supported it and I thought it was a chance for us to kind of come, as I said, kind of come back together and coalesce. I never supported a division of the community, though.
7:18 And this is where I think you were the same way, too. Like, one of the things I said throughout was I'm not going to mine on a minority chain. Like, you know, I will I am expressing my opinion. My support of it was, you know, Bob Burnett's and, you know, my support through my company barefoot. We were supporting it. but not to the extent that, Hey, if this thing doesn't become the heaviest chain, then I can't, I can't go there. Like it, and I don't do that just because I own a shitload of equipment that, that is a shot to 56.
8:01 But, well, I guess that's the proof of work thing, but it's not, it's not, it was not financially motivated for me. It was about the worst thing for Bitcoin, I think, is a fork, is a hard split. I think that's a bad, bad thing. And I didn't want to support that. So the other thing that happened, I think, as you know, I created the first signaling block for BIP110. And And I still think that that was the right decision because one I was supporting it I wanted the world to remember that this was part of mining that part of mining is creating blocks and expressing your support or opinion about potential protocol changes That's part of the process. And I think it's important for miners to remember that because we have this whole thing of miners versus hashers, right?
9:16 Are you a miner or are you a hasher? And I thought, you know, this is a great way to demonstrate to the world that being a miner is something that has power, but it also has responsibility. and that if you abdicate that responsibility to the pool itself, that's when you stop being a minor, when you do those sorts of things. So I continued to signal through May. In early June is when I stopped signaling. And maybe I'll pause there and give you a chance to comment up to that point because it was kind of a pivot point for me right around there.
10:03 Why was that a pivot point? Because what I saw happening, and you may disagree with this, and that's fine. What I saw happening was I saw the BIP-110 movement getting too caustic, first of all. And I thought that it had swayed to where the voices promoting at that point had gotten very adversarial, number one. Number two, to me, I never bought the node thing.
10:49 So not that the nodes don't have a significant say, right? I mean, I think we saw a lot of nodes. But what I wasn't seeing was any support outside of a small group that when I would talk amongst the community, It was either opposition or apathy. And this is everything from, you know, ecosystem, wallet developers, application developers, people at exchanges, like large OGs that owned a lot of Bitcoin. I was just not seeing, outside of kind of the initial group, I wasn't seeing new people come in.
11:37 It was kind of clear to me that the consensus was very much in opposition to a change. And so I toned down my activity and my support at that point. yeah so so uh okay uh the the thing that i'm really trying to get to the bottom of and uh for the most part just to educate myself and get a clearer picture of how how bitcoin actually works under the hood is this uh the the sort of perspective that was given from the pro side I think not in the beginning, but it evolved into that, is that the nodes are in charge and user-activated soft fork, minority soft forks, are possible.
12:30 And that at some point you would trigger this domino effect where you have to anticipate whether the other miner is going to signal or not. and you're also incentivized to signal as late as possible into the game because that gives you an advantage over other miners that aren't prepared. However, I don't think that view is entirely correct because I think there are more factors at play. And also their narrative, as I understand it now, is that some of them, as we've talked about conspiratory thinking, I mean, I'm all pro-adversarial thinking, but conspiracy is another thing.
13:13 And I think a lot of Blake-to-beers think that the big miners colluded to not have to signal for a minor rejected soft fork or whatever, and instead could just ignore this thing. so I'm trying to visualize the factors at play when you're a miner and you have to make this decision whether to flip the bit or not on August the 8th and I think on the one side you have the missed opportunity of all the fees that could have gone through those nodes that would now fork off and on the other side you have every other uh every other economic incentive including you know just as giacomo pointed out the other uh the other day uh inertia that it's uh change change is always costly like it's it's much easier to just stay keep doing what you're doing and also reputational damage from not doing what the other miners wanted and what most users seem to want even though they didn't signal for anything and also yeah there's also the the fees to be gained from from actual spam that's also a factor uh but so so i now see user activated soft for minority soft forks as possible but maybe we didn't go we we never came above the threshold needed and i think
14:45 a large factor in that is that as many pointed out, these new nodes that, you know, Start9 and Umbro were showing great sales statistics, all of those nodes, the fact that they were just purchased and just purchased for this specific purpose to signal for BIP-110, that points to those nodes not having that much economic activity and also not probably they won't have that much economic activity in the future so you're not missing out on that many fees if you're the miner and you're making the decision whether to flip the bit or not so so what went through your head when when the date actually came and what what incentives what factors did you have to weigh in here including your own you know moral stance if you will Well, first, I mean, as an organization, and I'm going to speak, well, I'll speak to it both from an ocean perspective and from a perspective as CEO of Barefoot Mining.
15:51 In both cases, we were completely prepared to go either way. Like in a minute, we could flip a switch and we could be on either chain. Which, by the way, is one of the powers of Datum and the way that Ocean was structured was it gave miners that capability. And that's what we put significant effort in at Ocean to make sure that we could service the miners. I think some of it's with hindsight, but not all of it, that a user-activated soft fork is still possible.
16:36 I think there are a set of circumstances to it, but I think there was, I don't know if this almost sounds funny, there was too much focus on the node directly and not on kind of the supporting part of the system. so um one things like exchanges and i even hate to say it like treasury companies are important like i think there should have been marketing an effort to convince them why this is would have been in um advantageous to them to be part of it because to tell you the truth about the mining community itself there are a lot of suits in mining We'll call them suits.
17:28 And they're not Bitcoiners. They are economically incented actors. They are the reason things like FPPS exist. But see, that in and of itself, I think, is a great clue as to how miners will. So when I'm saying miners, I'm going to be specific. Very large miners, the public companies and the biggest miners. They are on the whole so risk averse and volatility averse that they choose the FPPS-based payout pools versus a TIDES or PPLNS, which pays less over any significant period of time, but they do it because a volatility of a couple percent on a monthly basis is too much for them to take on.
18:29 Okay, so let's get the terminology straight here. I think you're talking about hashers now, not miners, right? Well, I am. Well, yes, I am. And that's bad for me because I'm one of the biggest proponents of defining hasher versus miner. But we have a lot of hashers. The majority of hash rate is controlled by people who only want to hash. They want to be paid for that function. And they want as little volatility as possible related to that. And I think people confuse economically incented, even Satoshi talks about economically incented miners, that sort of thing.
19:18 Well, there is a maximizing your revenue versus having predictable revenue. And they are largely predictable. Predictable revenue is better than maximum revenue. And so that gives you some insight into the way that they think. You know, and I would say, this is my guess, I think somewhere around 28 to 30% of global hash rate sits in the hands of the big publicly traded mining companies today. so and then probably another uh 15 to 25 percent sits in what i would call privately held elephants so really big organizations but privately held they all kind of come from that same that same mindset i will also point out i don't think there was enough marketing to them I think there was too much emphasis on the nodes are in control.
20:26 The miners, if you think about the miners, the miners are going to care about what the exchanges think. Like it's going to be really important to these guys, these big guys, what the exchanges think, because they need that off ramp. Right. That's critical to them. They care about what their shareholders are going to think. They won't care about the nodes that much. They barely, like most of them don't even run nodes, or they may run a node in their finance department where they do some of their treasury management, but they're not running nodes relative to the mining function.
21:12 so i i i think a lot more work should have been done in the broader community to try to gain support because the and i spoke to a lot of big big miners it wasn't even on their radar like they they had put zero thought into it because they felt zero pressure to even think about it. Maybe that's the best thing to say. The only thing a few of them did, and I think we have to even give Foundry some degree of credit for it, when Foundry said, hey, we're going to ask these people to vote, that was the first time some of them even thought about it. Yeah, and I thought that might actually have triggered something because now the other miners would have had to take that into account and then prepare accordingly.
22:09 But apparently they didn't have to. And also, I don't buy that they were colluding behind closed doors because they didn't need to. If they weren't even informed, and I totally buy that, by the way. But as you say, if they now prefer lower gains but more predictable gains, That to me sounds like a high time preference behavior, which is exactly what Bitcoin is trying to fix. It's a product of the fiat system, if you will, that people are that way, to some extent at least.
22:49 And also that they care so much about what the exchanges think because they want to sell their B2C and buy dollars so they can pay their electrical bills, I guess. But how do you see this going forward then? Is it going to be a bigger and bigger problem going forward? And what part does Ocean play in solving that problem? Well, the first part of your question, yeah, it's very complex. I mean, one, these are fiat-minded organizations. It's something I've spoken about a lot, that it's why, it's why, like, barefoot is not a public mining company.
23:34 I used to work in a Fortune 200 company in the C-suite, and I know what hap- as soon as you make that decision to be public, you cannot be a Bitcoin company. And you are forced into a fiat mindset. You are legally obligated, and I guess you could probably even argue morally obligated when you make that step, to be fiat-centric. And you are also beholden to the perception of your investors. And that's what's really scary. Because we live in this litigious society, if you're a public company, as I say, you are subservient to the perception of your shareholders. So if your shareholders think you're going down the wrong route, even if you're making a sage decision, they can still sue you.
24:36 Right. And and you're you're you know, so you you get into this box of being very, very conservative for the most part. Most organizations are led by people who get very, very conservative and they're holding big bags to they. you know, a lot of these guys, we won't have to talk about MetaPlanet or all that, but that kind of behavior where the executive incentive plans are such that it's not necessarily even about them providing great shareholder returns. It's about them thinking the shareholders will not sue them and can they hang on long enough to collect the big bag?
25:17 you know and so so that's where we are i mean there's no way to make it illegal for a um a company a company structure to be filtered out of whether or not they can participate in the mining network or not see i think i think by the way we won't go down this one right now When I watch what's happening with the Blake 2Bers right now, they're upset because the behavior of the miners isn't what they want. And they're struggling with that. Well it the same problem they had on the other side Yeah I think that but here what interesting Canute The public miners are losing power within the Bitcoin ecosystem right now And the big guys are losing power within the ecosystem The timing by the way BIP 110 was really poor in my opinion Like that was pushed too early, that there may have been a time when the world would have been in a better environment to accept it.
26:31 And this is one of those things where, like by my estimates, the U.S. or the big public miners have fallen from about 38% to about 28% of global hash rate just in the last year. And I expect that to continue. And I expect, I don't know if you remember my rabbits, horses, elephants. Absolutely. Well, the horses and the rabbits are rapidly gaining power, but they don't have enough right now. But the public miners are leaving for two reasons. One is they actually can't make money.
27:14 the the economic the pure economics and two they have a savior which is ai and so they're they're leaving rapidly so the ecosystem is kind of self-correcting anyway and and uh there's a lot of activity in the horse class and we i mean if bip 110 did one thing it did help a lot of people run nodes and i think it did help a lot of people start mining again even at the individual level the rabbit level so that's really good yeah uh so i i think we're we're we're gonna see the big miners that they'll they'll calm down the horses and the rabbits are more how should we say they're they're more bitcoin centric companies i think by definition yeah and if you say if what you say is true and and if it will keep on being true that this goes from the elephants to the horses and the rabbits and i think as long as that's that holds true i'm i'm super optimistic um because there are so many levels of irony here because you have irony in the public companies that are most of the hash rate being the most fiat-minded people on earth, really,
28:44 because Bitcoin was created to solve exactly this and to separate money and state, which means that none of this would apply. None of this would make any sense in a hyper-Bitcoinized world, like none of those behaviors. and you would be barefoot instead of wearing loafers, so to speak. You would not be a suit. You would wear a toga. But the other irony is that just as the bigger players here move from real stupidity to artificial intelligence, you get some of the best real stupid ones forking off.
29:28 And that's, in my opinion, that's sad because like, who's going to be on the battlefronts in the next fight? And I really don't like the fact that so many good Bitcoiners have now chosen to separate themselves from this. Because as you say, I think it's inevitable that they will face exactly the same problems, if not worse, probably worse because they're a smaller network. So it's easier to change it. And it's like it's already centralized, in my opinion. I don't view I just don't see it happening. And then we're going to have to rebuild everything and convince everyone that the that the that Bitcoin 2.0 is better.
30:15 and it's just the same futile fight as every other attempt at creating a shitcoin. Even though maybe I agree that the goals are way nobler than with something like Bcash or Ethereum or whatever, Solana. But noble goals is not everything here. Sound money needs to be actually sound. Yeah, I agree. It's not my nature to wish ill on anybody. I think that's a bad, a bad thing, but I, I cannot, I cannot see a path to success for them. And, um, I think the, the centralization is massive there right now. I think they're suffering even to a greater degree from the same issues that Bitcoin itself has.
31:10 has, I think it kind of has the worst of, how can I say this? So I saw, I'll tell you an interesting story. So two, two, two quick stories. So one is I did a show. I have a show I call old man yells. and I did a show in January of 2025 and it was because it's called Collective Denial. It's the title of the show, anybody interested in it. It's about 20 minutes. And the reason I shot that show was at the time I kept finding myself in these battles with Bcash and BSV people and who were insisting that they were Bitcoin, that we were flawed you know kind of the same narrative and uh they struck a chord with me one day so i i did this show on a guy named hiro onoda it's the story of hiro onoda hiro onoda was a japanese soldier in world war ii and um i won't tell you the whole episode obviously but the at the end of the story he and four other guys were um were part of a team on an island in the philippines and they refused to believe that the war was over and i've heard this story yeah and so i go through the detail of it within the show and it's very interesting um and you know at at some
32:44 point like one of the guys uh leaves the group he actually gets lost finds himself in a village in the philippines becomes convinced the war actually was over because it's like a 12 years later or something at that point. And he flies home to Japan and realizes the war really was over. And so he comes back to try to convince the remaining part of the group that the war is really over. And they still refuse to believe him, thinking that it was a conspiracy and a attempt to make him turn them against the war. It was like completely delusional thinking at that point. And Hero, by the way, was the last guy. I think it was like 28 or 30 years he ended up on the island. So part of this though, part of the reason I'm saying this is there's a guy named Brett Weinstein. Have you ever heard of Brett?
33:48 Yeah, I've seen a lot of Brett Weinstein stuff. I think he's a fascinating guy. I don't agree with everything he says, but he's been following him for a long time. Yeah, and he does a show called Dark Horse. He did one recently on fanaticism. And I'll tell you another short story, but I think these are very pertinent to this topic. And what he said was, hey, imagine there's a group of people who come to think that the world is going to end let's just say on August 8th as an example they come to think the world is going to end on August 8th and but it's January 1st but they've come to think the world is going to end on January 8th so as time marches on And there's a thousand people thinking this.
34:49 As time marches on and they get, let's say, to like May, June, there's some of the group realizes that like, hey, nobody else is buying the story. It doesn't feel like it's happening. So 200 people kind of drift away. and then you get a little closer and another 200 people drift away and you get a little closer and another 100 drift away and then you hit then you hit august 8th and it doesn't happen like the world doesn't end and so you lose a few more and so at some point maybe um september 1st the group that remains is like 250 people.
35:41 They are the most bought in to the narrative. And they've lost the counterweight. They've lost the voices that maybe keep them balanced, right? And I think there's some of that that's happened in the Blake 2B group right now, where, you know, the check and balance is gone. Now, to your point about some of those people being valuable in the Bitcoin side, the Bitcoin side lost something, too, which is the Bitcoin side lost some of the people who also were the counterbalance. Right. So there's a there's a there's a loss on both sides.
36:23 And so I'm not I'm not trying to completely just say, oh, the Blake to be guys are idiots or anything like that. That's not the point of my story. I do think they're not going to make it and I feel bad for them because I know there's a tremendous amount of energy and effort and money and emotional I don't know the right word is but emotional energy a lot of effort went into this and it sucks to put that much into something and not have it work but at some point you have to realize it isn't going to work and go try to fix the thing that really matters.
37:08 Yeah, I couldn't agree more. I mean, I've seen it from the inside and from the outside. And as you say, I've seen it on both sides. There's this tribalism. Tribalism is strong in human beings in general. And there's the sunk cost fallacy. And you keep doubling down once you've bought one narrative. you stop asking yourself, what if I'm wrong? And I think for both sides, the thing I heard from the core side when the soft fork was on the table was the biggest argument was, it's not going to happen, therefore I'm against, which is a circular argument.
37:52 So why are you basing your opinions on whether it's a good idea or not on what you think the outcome will be. That's not how Bitcoin is supposed to operate. You're supposed to make a decision because you think it's the right decision, and then you battle test it and see if it works or not. And that's what I did. But that doesn't mean, because on the other side, it's just like, oh, the only explanation for this is that the miners are a cartel and now nodes are worthless. And I don't buy that. I don't buy that at all. Bitcoin is supposed to be hard to change, I think the BIP 110 was a reaction to a very small change in Bitcoin, a mempool policy default change.
38:37 It's small in the sense that it's not on the consensus layer, but in the mempool. It's a big change in terms of the magnitude of a filter that was bytes, and now it's 100 kilobytes. Of course, that's a big change. but in terms of how it changes the functionality of bitcoin is not not that big of a change and i was much more in the i i think the taproot bug and the inscriptions and all that that like op if not being used for anything good whatsoever that was the bigger motivator for me than op return like op return i always viewed as a sort of a there's no judge in the world that is going to care whether your CSAM is in an operator or somewhere else on chain because they don't understand data to begin with. They don't understand computers. And they're all corrupt. I wouldn't trust a judge to have judgment in any part of the world. And not when it comes to things like that. So then again, of course, I thought it was a completely unnecessary and stupid change made for the wrong decisions. I still stand by that. But I don't think it motivated the suggestion of a soft fork, but that doesn't mean it motivated a hard fork. Absolutely not. So, yeah, I'm just trying to, yeah, I talk a lot in these latest interviews because I'm trying to get my thoughts together here. It's kind of hard to have everything in the right place again. I completely empathize with
40:15 that i think that one i think where you and i probably start from and that thing i said about the fanaticism and is that like you and i were more moderate in the the the supporters of bip 110 probably probably me me even uh more moderate than you or or less well i didn't mind any bit on 10 blocks well that's that's a fair point and by the way this is not saying it's good or bad i'm just you know i i like i said i kind of i i never rooted against it because i still supported it right i never rooted against it i never publicly said i think it's bad and you know i you know had foundry flipped or one of the big miners flipped you know okay you know that would have been that would have been fine that would have been i think in my opinion the better outcome but it's not um i never viewed it existential i was i was clear about that you know from the beginning and i think that um i i think that that was actually part of the problem the pr problem that those who were the active promoters really had was i think promoting it as so existential leaning into the the c-sam issue so hard made it more difficult for
41:48 people who were less involved in the community they had less like it just sounds so fanatical like like i i could see them i could see a lot of people just turning off a podcast or just turning off and muting people in their Twitter feed and those sort of things when that stuff kept coming up. And because I think the narrative got lost. The other thing is, you know, RDTS was always proposed as, well, by definition, it was temporary. So the way I viewed it was, well, you know, if it doesn't pass, if it doesn't get accepted, well, then let's just work on what the next thing should have been anyway, right?
42:39 Because it was temporary. I think what the Blake-to-beer group did was they then lost a tremendous amount of credibility by not just hard forking, but proof-of-work change, block header change, even if those are great things that should have been addressed, like, wow, the world will infer that this is what you think, what you were going to try to do on the backside of the RDTS. And I also say too I agree with you you know about things like you know Op and the taproot bug and all that Like one of the things I've said, my biggest issue that BIP110 helped with and that I was hoping the backside would fix is that the abuse of the SegWit discount.
43:49 So you could view that a couple different ways because one way you can look at that is I don't want spam on the chain. I don't, right? And you don't. But another way to look at it is why have we, and this would have, I think, resonated with the miners, by the way. Why are we being forced to price our block space? That is what miners do. Miners produce block space. why are we being forced to give a big discount to these people who are using large amounts of space to be the opposite like hey you want to like if you want to put a really big transaction in then i'm gonna i'm gonna i want you to pay an exorbitant amount for it right so if if if if so anyway i mean i'm still hopeful that we can maybe figure that out i think honestly that's probably the most likely path where we could we could maybe get some consensus within the community to to fight spam is because the the for lack of a better term the v30 crowd or the traditional crowd thinks that economic incentives fix this i i think there are things we could do to be fair or to be honest, but I do think there's a lot we can do with economic incentives.
45:15 And one of those things would be by closing that hole and making the SegWit discount. As an example, one of the things I've been circulating and I'm potentially working on, well, I am kind of working on a BIP, whether or not I'll see the light of day, is to in essence say can we can we have a mechanism where the segwit discount applies only to the first 256 or 512 bytes or something like that and after that you pay full price now we're talking that sounds excellent and i think that this is so funny because i from this conversation i can tell that you and i have very very similar views on on this whole thing uh For instance, like the Blake2B thing, I've not been active in the groups.
46:08 I've been eavesdropping a bit, like I'm still in them and I'm still welcome there, I hope. I'm not trying to bash one side or the other here. But from what I could tell, they did a thing that I've been wanting for a long time, which is reduce the size of blocks. And they just did that. And it's like, oh, but how did you just do that? And it turns out it was a poll on a Discord server between the people. And it's like, yeah, I would want that. But that's not how Bitcoin works, though. Like in Bitcoin, you need to suggest it as a soft fork and then do it when you have consensus for it. Like your principles have turned into we don't care about principles anymore.
46:55 To me, it's completely counter to how this is supposed to work. So it's like, hang on a minute. So I'd like to know where our points of view differ here. I mean, but maybe we won't find that. So instead, let's start from another angle. what Luke would say to Ocean still being important and I believe it is and I believe Datum is one of the most important inventions in Bitcoin the last five years at least he would say that it's no longer relevant because SHA-256 is corrupt now so what would you say to that?
47:44 What would you well I think Luke not even accepting that what the Blake2B group is working on is not Bitcoin. and that what I will call the main chain that's recognized as Bitcoin, I think by 99.9% of the holders of Bitcoin and by every exchange and every treasury company and steak and shake when you want to go buy a burger, you know, like that's Bitcoin.
48:35 And so we have a fundamental issue where when we can't even agree on that, I mean, that's a big problem. And just by the way, a quick sidelight. I think that poll, the manner in which the proof of work change happened, the Discord server, those sort of things. on the Blake2B chain, there are holders of 20 million Bitcoin, if I accept their definition. There's 20 million holders of them that they are serving, including me, by the way.
49:18 I mean, I technically own some coins on their chain, and I think it's, frankly, it's ludicrous to think that because a very small group of people are communicating in very tight insular circles, are making these decisions, and they're making them very rapidly. I mean, Bitcoin is global. There's a bunch of holders in China and Russia and Malaysia and the Philippines and people that don't speak English. And, you know, it takes quite a while for messages to ripple through. And they're just rapid firing this stuff. And I think that that's, you know, I think that's really wrong. And it's part of my fatalism related to their movement.
50:17 Now, as for Ocean, I mean, we're serving Bitcoin. Me and the whole group, we're adamant that what we're working on is Bitcoin, that the chain we support is Bitcoin. um and you know our job is to to be a pool um our our job is not to try to define bitcoin our job is not to tell people what client to run our our our job isn't to tell people what to put in their templates, you know, and, and I know this may be cringeworthy, but if somebody wants to, to create a template using Datum and they want to abuse the witness discount, let people abuse the witness discount and do all those things that, you know, we're, we're, we believe we are obligated to allow that template in.
51:27 We're not going to, because that would just be censorship, right? You know, we're here to be a pool. We're here to give people the opportunity to be a miner and we're here to help them defer and mitigate risk so they don't have to be a solo miner to do this. But that's the role of a pool. So that's what I think, And that's what I think we're doing well. So I don't know if that answers your question or not. Yeah, I think it does. I mean I sort of struggling to find the correct questions here But if we poke on this double click on this where we might differ in our opinions where was I going with that?
52:12 I just had something. Damn brain. Yeah. So one thing from this whole debacle that I've, a conclusion I've made, a personal conclusion, is that I will be more careful in calling people shitcoiners going forward, though because i think the the fundamental underlying thing here regardless of how obvious it is to you that one chain is bitcoin and the other is not is that the right to to define what bitcoin is subjectively is is the most crucial thing like as uh so that's the whole point of running a node and and being a participant in the network is to be able to dictate the rules of the money you use the thing with bitcoin is this is how i view them the most fundamental part is that if i choose the same rules as as the majority of the network i get the network effect if i play chess the way other people play chess i can play chess with all the chess players in the world if i choose to play without queens or if i choose to do bitcoin without spam without this or that possibility to spam in this way, then I will not have as many players to play with. And therefore, it is costly for me to choose the wrong rules. But it's still my fundamental right to choose whatever rules I want. And it is a fundamental right of Luke's to have this view of the world
53:47 where he says Bitcoin and he means something else than everyone else. So the paraphrasing of the Voltaire quote that I came up with is, I don't agree with your fork, but I'm going to fight to the death for your right to fork it. Like, that's my stance on that. Do we differ here or are you of the same opinion? I think there's some gray here. And so a couple things. I agree that you can play by whatever rules you wish that is your prerogative as a human being and if you find a another group of people who are willing to play by your rules wonderful like you have a game to play if Bitcoin is a game though whether that's a game like football or baseball or basketball or, you know, whatever.
55:02 If 99.99% of the people are playing a game and they are calling it basketball, and you decide that when a basket is made, it's worth 10 points, not two points, and you insist with your 0.001% of the world that what you're doing is basketball, and you don't respect the right of other people, the 99.99, who say they're playing basketball, I think that's where Luke is I mean, we'll be specific to Luke but I guess the whole community kind of is in that we talked about the fanaticism, right?
55:54 so the tribalism we're at this point where I think they've gone so hard over there that they're not respecting the 99.99 yeah, so I think what I'm getting at is more an actual semantics thing Because if Bitcoin is truly leaderless and everyone's allowed to define what it is, and simultaneously no one is, then it's not really wrong to call it Bitcoin if you're a minority fork. There's nothing ethically incorrect about that since it is this leaderless thing.
56:38 By definition, leaderless means no one gets to dictate anything for another person. And then you get into this relativism thing, which is ironic, by the way, because relativism is sort of the thing we're trying to get away from with the fork. But anyway, yeah, that's basically a philosophical little nugget of some kind. I mean, I guess so, but I, you know, where my... where my issues with the Blake to be movement are, are I think the vehemence with which I see this.
57:21 And because it, I mean, to me, it, it's misleading to people and confusing to people. And so I guess we each have an individual right to, I guess I can't agree with your, with your stance there but but it has to i i feel obligated to to call it out so that that yeah i mean that's the case you know the opposite is true too like we are as much as they are free to call themselves bitcoiners on another chain uh we are free to call them retards for doing so.
58:06 Yeah. Well, I mean, let's be honest. It's no different than the Bcash or the BSV people, right? I mean, there's to this day in both of those communities, the same thing occurs. For me, it changed my view on those people a bit because I think, yeah, for the most part, they were bad actors. I think it was a takeover attempt. Like it was much more of a blatant takeover attempt. Like the Blip 110 thing and the Blake 2B thing is done with, I don't suspect it's done with anything but the best of intentions. I can't say that for Bcash or BSV. Like BSV in particular where Craig is an obvious scammer.
58:48 There's no doubt about it. Only an idiot would fall for that. Bcash mostly scammers because it was this, or maybe not outright scammers, but people who wanted to be in charge of Bitcoin. you know BitPay and the big miners and the New York agreement people they wanted that and then they forked off and they were cheered on by a handful probably really believed in it and believed it was the real thing including Roger Ver and Roger Ver yeah he probably wasn't lying to him well, in his view, he was probably honest, even though I suspect he was lying to himself in not wanting to understand all aspects of economics and stuff like that.
59:39 But in hindsight, I can't really call them as much. I think there are degrees of shitcoinery. I think Solana and Cardano and all this crap is obviously, that's very much shitcoinery. I think Ethereum is also shitcoinery through and through. I don't believe there were any good intentions there. I believe it was created as a scam. And a lot of Etherheads would... I believe a lot of gullible people, intelligent gullible people fell for it. And the same true for the other forks. Like there's... Well, Ethereum wasn't a fork, but there are intent sort of matters.
1:00:21 I think it was a social fork. It was a social fork. It may not have been a fork in the traditional sense of what happened with Blake2B, but I think Ethereum was a social fork. You know, one of the things, too, I guess, trying to explore things that we may or may not disagree upon is when a lot of the game theory that was discussed around what might happen for BIP-110 centered around activities from the SegWit activation, right?
1:01:03 And the reality is it's a very different world a decade later, roughly a decade later. Bitcoin, for better or worse, and I think some people would say worse, you know, there are, for lack of a better term, there's a lot of Bitcoin by proxy now. Whether that's an ETF, whether that's a... A paper Bitcoin. Well, yeah, I mean, if I go here, I live in South Florida, right? There's a lot of people now who, if I ask them, do you own some Bitcoin, will say yes.
1:01:47 And probing, they own a BlackRock ETF. They own MicroStrategy. When you probe, that's what it is. And I know you and I would say, well, no, you really don't own Bitcoin. However, they think they own Bitcoin. And they do own Bitcoin by proxy. So there's some semantics here, right? But they own Bitcoin by proxy. They can have an influence, but it's indirect, right? They have to influence somebody else to make a difference, right? Because if it's BlackRock, and I know this is probably appalling for people to think about, but I wonder, did anybody in the BIP-110 movement reach out to BlackRock and say, hey, you hold several hundred thousand Bitcoin, what do you think?
1:02:45 Because, by the way, if you get them in, that's a big freaking deal. Yeah, and they can talk to Coinbase. Exactly. Or they're custodian. Right. And I know even talking to Coinbase is probably appalling to a lot of people. But the reality is, I mean, like it or not, and maybe it will change with time, a massive amount of the infrastructure is Bitcoin by proxy right now. So you can influence the people who defer and they can say hey, they can contact BlackRock and they can say hey, either support BIP-110 or I'm out.
1:03:31 I'm selling. There's a certain power that goes with that. But For lack of a better term, you know, the suits are here and they're not going to go away, at least not for a long, long time. And I think it was inevitable, by the way. I think Bitcoin doesn't reach its pinnacle without corporations and financial institutions and nation states participating. That that that is essential to Bitcoin to the world hyper Bitcoinizing. Now, can we keep it so that they don't overwhelm us and overwhelm the rules? That's that's the trick. But whether even the Blake 2Bers ultimately, I think, would face that same problem, if what they think is Bitcoin truly became Bitcoin, the same thing would happen.
1:04:22 yeah here's the thing though if if you can't even convince a person to buy actual bitcoin instead of paper bitcoin or blackrock etf bitcoin then you're never gonna you good luck explaining bit 110 there's there's like bit 110 was hard enough for bitcoiners to understand It's super, super, you know, it took me months to fully understand what the hell they were talking about and why it was a good idea. Like, it took a lot of mental effort. And a person who chooses to buy a BlackRock ETF instead of actual Satoshi is nowhere near that level of understanding.
1:05:09 I don't think that happened. So the question here and the thing I want to explore, because one thing I say often is the final scene of Fight Club. You've seen Fight Club, right? Yes, I have. I just watched it again in the last month. Oh, fantastic. You know, when all the skyscrapers for the credit card companies fall apart and he's just shot himself in the face, but he gets the girl and the wonderful Pixies song comes up. And that's the future I'm looking forward to, you know, because these people who own paper Bitcoin can and will get rugged at some point.
1:05:52 Not your keys, not your coins is just as true now as it was back in 2011. There is no getting around that. And to me, that is the most beautiful thing. Like it turns the entire world on its head. And everything, every ETF, every treasury company is just trying to get this square peg into a round hole. Because Bitcoin is not, it does not fit into the fiat world because it's so different. And it's so based on the individual. Like you've heard my rants about the Satoshis actually living in your head and stuff. Like I think that this beast cannot be tamed by the whole system. And that's the beauty.
1:06:32 So my question would be, So what does that future look like? If the suits come in and then they get rugged every here and there, are we just facing 50 more years of extreme volatility when BlackRock loses all its Bitcoin and Coinbase goes under and some guy at Coinbase buys an island somewhere and Sailor is rugged? How do you envision that? uh i don't know if it's 50 years but i think there is a struggle that continues i mean i i certainly agree with your fundamental premise not your keys not your coin right and and i agree that there will be there has been and there will continue to be tremendous turmoil and pain associated with people who didn't follow that path and letting proxies do it.
1:07:32 But the opposite of that is, if we look at Bitcoin as the ultimate money of the world or the final settlement layer, if the network is the final settlement layer, like these sorts of things, it's it's impossible in my mind to envision a future where um nation states and big corporations and financial institutions aren't actively participating in the network like they they and and you know i i think it's likely that we'll see the big financial institutions as an example that Bank of America and JPMorgan and BlackRock and Fidelity and those sort of traditional organizations figure out ways to participate.
1:08:22 I think they will have to because I think some people will demand it. I also think that new ones will emerge that will maybe be more Bitcoin-centric and approach this from a Bitcoin mindset. and hopefully they will succeed. And for instance, you know, allowing, and I'm just making this up, you know, some sort of financial institution using some sort of multi-sig that doesn't allow rehypothecation of funds and, you know, but still allows you to maybe easily take fiat loans and things like that, you know, against your coin.
1:09:13 I think those sort of services will be important. And they'll even be important for corporate treasuries. You know, like I could speak to it for barefoot or for ocean, like, hey, we have Bitcoin treasuries, but we have needs or we may have cash shortfalls. We need ways of, you know, getting cash and making payroll and paying bills and like these sorts of things. I think this will be really important. But there will be a lot of pain and suffering along the way. I don't think it, you know, I'm 62 years old. I don't know if I'll see it, the end result. You're a little younger, Knut, so, you know, you may. But I think it's in that window yeah so i i agree to a degree because i i think this is all transitory like it's all temporary like because all of these things are are fiat things and and where we're going there is no state and there there are no fiat loans like uh in the long run bitcoin is the remedy to fiat it's like it cannot coexist with the dollar like it will either one of them will win and it remains to be seen which they sure bitcoin can fail for a variety of different reasons but as long as it works it is superior to the dollar and therefore it will win over the dollar in the long run and the dollar will hyperinflate it will all other fiat currencies
1:10:44 will hyperinflate before the dollar, but the dollar is on the same path. Like just now you heard Trump bribing the voters. Like I find it fascinating. People call this guy a capitalist. He's a commie. Like, can't you see that? Free handouts for voting for, what the fuck is that? It's like banana state stuff. Total banana state stuff. I don't know if you, yeah, yeah, yeah. It has been, it's funny you mentioned banana state because I don't know if you've met my wife, Lola. She's from the Philippines. And in the last election, there's a woman named Imelda Marcos. She's very famous. Her husband, Ferdinand Marcos, was a dictator there.
1:11:25 And she's still alive. Her son was running for election. And she was walking through the slums of Manila, handing out, literally handing out the equivalent of $10 bills to people, which is like, you know, several days' salary for the average person there, you know, and just a big stack of money and just handing it out. So just a similar version of that. Well, I think it's cheaper in the Philippines than in the U.S., but I give it that. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. But but see, the thing is, you and I don't disagree. Maybe we disagree on timeline, though, because I mean, I think this transitory state, as you refer to it, We have to go through that transitory state.
1:12:10 We can't skip it. And so I'm talking a lot about this transitory state. But even on the other side, I think there still are corporations. I mean, maybe we disagree with that. I think on the other side of it, I think there still will be corporations. Yeah, but what is a corporation on a Bitcoin standard? The way I see it, it's just a signal group. It's just a group of people doing stuff together. Yeah, I think that's what it is even now. Yeah, but now you have to have all these lube companies. You have to have the accountants and professional services teams and tax lawyers and whatnot. A corporation has to abide by a ton of rules.
1:12:52 All of those rules are gone on a Bitcoin standard because you can do everything without permission. Well, I think this is very interesting. I think the corporation is a group of people. I think that that group of people will impose their own set of rules and own set of behaviors for participating in that group. It won't necessarily be democratic because there, you know, there will be people taking risk. I mean, just because like a corporation, whether it's Bitcoin based or any other currency based that has risk.
1:13:33 It has people that have different incentives within the group and take different risks in the group. So I think all that still exists. Would be wonderful. And we still will have an accountant in that world. We just won't have to do taxes, hopefully. That would be wonderful. We wouldn't have the bureaucracy and the regulation that we have today. That would be wonderful. But we're still trying to accomplish that. And, you know, is that the nation state? And it's very philosophical. Like, is the nation state really just, and it may even be virtual, right?
1:14:16 Yeah, yeah. That there's still groups of people that coalesce around something. And that may be a nation state of its own with its own economic power and rules of engagement and inclusion. Well, for instance, if you're the Coca-Cola company on a Bitcoin standard, it's trivial to just make sure that the sats go to the right person whenever you sell a can of Coke. So 50% of the sats go to the franchise, like the nine people employed at the Coca-Cola company sitting in an office in New York. Like half of it goes there and the retailer still wants it because he can sell the Coke, the can of Coke for more than double the next best thing, which is some local brand of Coke.
1:15:08 So he still chooses to do that. So they still get these massive profits. But the thing is, you can automate that in the product, like in the payment for the product. For instance, I just recorded some music and I put the album up on Fountain and my brother helped me make the album. So I can just split the payments with him by just entering the percentages. And every corporation on earth could just be that. It doesn't have to be more complicated. All of these, you know, shell companies and you move to this part of the company to the Bahamas to do this and blah, blah.
1:15:48 All of that stuff, all of that goes away on a Bitcoin standard because there's no state anymore. There's literally. And I think this transitory phase, though, I think it takes 200 years or something. It's definitely not in our lifetime. So we're not disagreeing. I don't think I get to see that. I hope no, no, me neither. Something positive to help it. Yeah. I want to tell you, there's a, there's a company I'm an advisor to, a small investor and it's called Resolver. And um it is providing some of this infrastructure that you talking about about immediate payment and resolution to the insurance industry And the basic summary of it is it very interesting is, you know, let's say you buy a life insurance policy.
1:16:45 And when you buy the life insurance policy, let's just say it's for a million dollars. Most likely what happens is the insurance company that sold it to you then sells off pieces of that risk to, let's say, 10 other companies, right? And who might even further sell it to another group of 10, right? So you have this kind of tree of risk mitigation. And so when you make a payment against that policy, let's say it's $1,000 a year, that money has to float down all the way to the bottom of that tree.
1:17:29 And then the opposite, let's say you get killed, now the million dollars has to get paid out, you have to retrieve the money from all of those paths. And it's very interesting how archaic and antiquated the systems are for that. Even big, big companies, right? I won't name names, but like really big companies are, they have spreadsheets and monthly phone calls and they're trying to reconcile and who got paid and blah, blah, blah. Well, what Resolver basically did is, you know, moved all that into a Bitcoin standard and using the same sort of tools.
1:18:16 Like that stuff is now essentially instantaneous, you know, using the Bitcoin network. so um you're absolutely right that that same concept can apply to buying a a coca-cola or a hamburger at mcdonald's or you know whatever that that sort of thing is so massive efficiency and maybe i have some hope that the 200 years is a little less because the the impact of ai accelerating some of these things might there might be this other effect in parallel with bitcoin that forces some of this stuff a little faster um i don't know agreed yeah so maybe it's 100 years and not 200 well who knows yeah yeah fun to speculate though it is fun to speculate though speaking of uh i've heard this interesting theory that uh the stock market is actually a form of socialism. So this goes back to the days of the Hanseatic League. So this is like the first stock ever invented. So you have, say you have 10 shipping companies who send ships from Amsterdam to Sydney. And one company, one ship per year is sunk and lost forever, including the crew and the cargo. So one of these companies goes bankrupt every year because of that ship.
1:19:52 They couldn't take that loss. Now they realize that if we instead co-own all the 10 companies and we have a stake in each other's boats, then we can share the losses and it doesn't have to be catastrophic. Now that sounds all swelling good and it was for the most part, but what it does is socialize the losses and not but but the gains are still private so so so what i mean by that is uh you have an you now have a malincentive in the whole thing because you don't have to take care of your boat that well since uh since it doesn't matter as much to you if it sinks you don't have as much skin in the game as you used to so and i find that just a picture in my head very fascinating and i'm like are there parallels here to bitcoin mining is this what fps is like there's so many thoughts that come up and and is is it really a good thing like um i definitely think that if you own something to a hundred percent then you take better care of it uh which is also the argument for why monarchy is better than democracy according to hans-herman hopper and there's all sort of philosophical strings to pull on here but yeah uh thoughts yeah that's actually very interesting um first is would your normal audience uh understand fpps
1:21:24 okay for those of you that don't fpps stands for uh full pay per share and this is when you sell hash power to a mining pool, you get paid out a fixed sum per time unit instead of when the pool actually finds a block. And this means that the pool has to add on quite a large fee because of the risk that the pool owner is taking because the pool can have bad luck for a while and not find blocks at all. So I hope you agree with this TLDR explanation. Yeah, it is. Just two points to expand on. One is, this is the way that the formula itself, it varies slightly from pool to pool. But most of them, what they'll do is they'll say, when they're deciding how much to pay the hasher, they'll say, let me look back at the previous 144 blocks, which is supposed to be one day's worth of work. I will throw out the five highest paying block rewards and the five lowest playing block rewards, and I'll average the rest. Okay. So by the way, if you think about it, that's where the premium is coming because typically the five highest blocks are further from the
1:23:00 mean than the lowest blocks so that's where they capture the premium okay so that's one thing the second thing similar to the iq bell curve yes yes exactly exactly so that's the trick right that's the trick on the surface it looks good if you don't think about it a little bit the second thing is even a fairly large pool can have a massive run of bad luck and there have been several pools that failed that were smaller and and the reason was you have to have a massive reserve of bitcoin because you still have to make bitcoin payments to the hashers right and they're expecting it on a regular cadence some get paid every block or every day like it's on a regular cadence and so if you have a run of bad luck and you do the math behind it you need a big old pile of bitcoin just sitting there in case right so uh versus like what ocean uses which we call it tides it's really a form of what's called PPLNS, pay per last number of shares. The basic concept is when you're mining, we're always
1:24:35 collecting statistics on how much work everybody in the pool is doing. And we are between, So whether we win a block once a day or we win a block five times a day, we share the proceeds only when we win the block. So if we have periods of good luck, the payment gets really good. If we have periods of bad luck, the payment is poorer. But there's no premium. we aren't we aren't taking the risk and we aren't giving a haircut based on the the way the formula works so it's why by the way in the end of the day ocean if you look at the stats i think the number last year was 3.7 percent so that was the that was the that was by the way the discount the big guys took by using like foundry and andpool they took a 3.7 discount for the consistency of knowing they could they could essentially at the beginning of the month almost calculate exactly how much the revenue for the month was going to be it just happened to be about 96 less than their expected value if they used ocean yeah this is uh reminds me of uh what misa said about entrepreneurs versus wage labor laborers. If the thing you get when you choose to get a monthly wage,
1:26:15 instead of being an entrepreneur and having skin in the game, is the stability of that payment. But the payment is obviously less risk, less reward is basically the thing. And the less risk thing is ironically that i think there's a largely a product of the fiat system but also just human incentives in general and time preference if you have more capital you can afford to take on more risk and therefore uh also uh potential higher gains uh right right something to that you know you started this though with about socialism so that was a very long-winded way of saying yes fpps is a form of socialism and it's a welfare state and i think it's also important to note that that's so if you're a big miner so right now um well global hash rate i don't know it's like 850 to 800 to 900 exahashes it's kind of bouncing around kind of in there at least 30-day average.
1:27:23 So if you were, let's say, somebody with 40 exahashes, as an example, and we'll just call that, for argument's sake, 5% of the network, you're going to win seven blocks a day. That's your expected value is about seven blocks a day. Well, the reality is, I mean, I could tell you this, As much as I love ocean and I'm the chairman of ocean, I'm an investor in ocean. Like if I have 40 exahashes, I might not even need ocean. Like the real math should be, I will just solo mine, right?
1:28:04 That I might win five someday and nine some days and 11 some days and two some days. But, but I don't know, I probably don't even need a pool. The concept of a pool was, you know, to, it's still almost, even tides is somewhat of a form of socialism, right? It's a lesser socialism. But the real version is to be a solo miner. That's capitalism. Yeah, and that's the boldest thing to do, of course. Anything else you want to bring up that we haven't talked about?
1:28:49 Well, I'd just say, you know, it was a very turbulent time. and um i think for ocean for barefoot for the people that were in the bip 110 movement you know we we we all expended a tremendous amount of energy in the last year toward this and um but it's in the past now and and you can look at it as a one or a loss i don't i don't view it that way I view it as well we we expressed our opinion I think that we did what Bitcoiners are supposed to do and but we also have to accept accept the result and move forward and make our best you know within within that result so if you were if you were on the BIP 110 side personally I I respect you're right if you want to follow the Blake two beers, but I, I don't think that's the right path.
1:29:57 I would counsel people to obviously consider it and make their own decision, but, but I think there's much more to be done, much more positive impact of focusing your energy on Bitcoin that that's where you're going to have the biggest impact. I think that's what you're doing, Canute is you know you're regathering I know you put a lot into that that effort and but now you're trying to make the best of it and I think that's I think that's what everybody should do and if you were on the others yeah if you're on the other side of it I don think it should be considered a victory I don think it good to gloat um i don think anything good comes of it i think if you um adversarial to folks who spent time in the bip 110 camp um you know i i i hope you won't hold ill toward them um you know that i think that's a very unbitcoin thing to do too so yeah in innocent until proven guilty i mean uh be adversarial but not not conspiratorial that's that's uh the message i want to send i guess uh the i i think the some some level of of uh suspicion is uh founded sometimes but we shouldn't just take everyone every public bitcoiner is not
1:31:33 a scammer that's that's just simply not true there's a lot of bad apples yes and especially in the wider crypto space where there is almost only bad apples but there's a lot of bad apples in the fiat world too that doesn't mean everyone's fucking corrupt i just don't buy it yeah i think there's a there's a lot less conspiracy going on than people think i think yeah yeah yeah you don't need conspiracy like especially when you have the fiat system that is set up in order to to incentivize people to be slightly crooked all the time and steal from their children by using dollars like there's that uh but that doesn't mean everyone has bad intentions that's that's never attribute to 5d chess that which can be explained by retardation well said yeah yeah uh oh one thing we haven't touched on is the uh uh just just to remind people that this is still a thing renting hash power i i i this is one of the positives that came out of the bip 110 movement i think because it it started with that sort of thing you can still rent hash power and it's it's a pretty cool thing uh and you can spend fiat and get hash power back you you're basically becoming a mining pool by doing that it's it's uh it's pretty cool yeah but there's a lot of there's a lot of positives and that's why i said i think it's bad
1:33:04 to to view this um whichever side you were on but especially if you were on quote unquote the winning side to think that that the BIP 110 people were horrible for doing so and by the way I've I've had a lot of nice interactions with people people have been very good to me on the whole um you know about about this um even some people I would have never expected that from have been been very kind and and open to me so I I really appreciate it I think though, you know, we have more nodes. I think we have more independent miners. I think we're going to have, you know, the use of data. I'm like, if we look at ocean, all the, it really incented a lot of people to create, create templates. So I think all these things are very positive outcomes that, that are really needed. And we have a lot of positives too. I mentioned, you know, the reversal of hash rate, the emergence of the small miners and the medium-sized miners.
1:34:10 Those are good things. I think Foundry and Antpool and some of the other pools, I think the message has been heard a little bit. I think you'll see, at some point, you'll see adoption of sv2 or or um datum by by other pools and even though that's a it's one of the key advantages of ocean i still think it's a great thing for bitcoin right so so i i applaud and ocean applauds it like we want these things to succeed so uh i think there's a lot of reason for optimism and and you know that's how that's how I'm looking at it I hope I hope we're about to start a bull run that would be really nice that will make that will make a lot of any day now yeah yeah yeah yeah I couldn't agree more will we see each other this this fall are you coming down to El Salvador in November for instance uh i just stacy reached out to me recently and asked me to please come so i'm considering it yeah i'm looking at it yeah i'm looking where are you going to be canute where are you going to be this fall uh yeah i'm gonna be in helsinki um uh i think helsinki is around the the time that this is released uh it's like no no it's this is probably released after helsinki actually
1:35:41 but i will have been in helsinki when this is released and because helsinki is next weekend okay and or two weekends what damn day is it it's tuesday right is it the last week of september because we have a couple people from ocean coming oh yeah mark is coming right yeah yeah i met mark this summer and he's coming yeah uh so that would be the 24th and 25th of September. Before that, I'm going to Bodrum to the Property Freedom Society conference with a bunch of libertarians. That's going to be interesting. And in October, I'm going to Lugano, where I'll celebrate my 50th birthday.
1:36:23 That'll be fun. There's an outside chance I show up there. I haven't decided yet. Have you been before? No, I haven't been to Lugano before. so it's absolutely beautiful that's it's a gorgeous place you you'll love it uh i can guarantee that it's it's uh it's a very very good looking little town and and uh and lots of fun and then i'll be at bitcoin historical in el salvador in uh mid-november and i might stay for a week or so there's something in el santo the week weekend after so i hope you come to that too it'll be a lot of fun okay well i i hope i hope to get to at least one of those two in either logano or el salvador and get a chance to see you yeah and uh i hope i'll show up in florida you never know when i show up in florida i'll yeah you're in florida i missed you the last time oh yeah yeah i was in naples like last summer yeah yeah so but but if If you're in Miami or Tampa or obviously Naples, please let me know.
1:37:33 I will. I will. Absolutely. So anyway, with that, thank you very much, Bob. This has been the Bitcoin Infinity Show. And you should brush your teeth. Like and subscribe. Do all the things. Buy products from my goddamn sponsors and call me a bigot. Goodbye.
Fountain
YouTube
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
RSS Feed