Financial Atheism | Sovereignty Through Mathematics Chapter 2 | Bitcoin Infinity Academy #3
This episode of the Bitcoin Infinity Academy covers Sovereignty Through Mathematics Chapter 2: Financial Atheism.
We explore the controversial yet thought-provoking concept of financial atheism in Bitcoin, the proof of work algorithm, and the philosophical implications of absolute scarcity in a commodity. Join the discussion on how Bitcoin challenges traditional human power structures and why it represents a paradigm shift in how society perceives and uses money. Don't miss out on this enlightening conversation!
Read the chapter on Nostr: https://primal.net/infinity/Sovereignty-Through-Mathematics-Chater-2-Financial-Atheism-etxrsf
Join the academy at our Geyser page: https://geyser.fund/project/infinity
The Bitcoin Infinity Academy is an educational project built around Knut Svanholm’s books about Bitcoin and Austrian Economics. Each week, a whole chapter from one of the books is released for free on Highlighter, accompanied by a video in which Knut and Luke de Wolf discuss that chapter’s ideas. You can join the discussions by signing up for one of the courses on our Geyser page!
Connect with Us:
https://www.bitcoininfinityshow.com/
https://bitcoininfinitystore.com
https://primal.net/infinity
https://primal.net/knut
https://primal.net/luke
https://twitter.com/BtcInfinityShow
https://twitter.com/knutsvanholm
https://twitter.com/lukedewolf
The Freedom Footprint Show is a Bitcoin podcast hosted by Knut Svanholm and Luke de Wolf.
In each episode, we explore everything from deep philosophy to practical tools to emit freedom dioxide to expand your freedom footprint!
0:00 Welcome to the Bitcoin Infinity Academy, brought to you by the Plan B Network and Bit Box. I'm Kwano, and, uh, I'm here as always with Luke de Wolff. Good morning, Luke. Good morning, Cano. Happy to be here. This is gonna be a fun one, isn't it? Yes, thi this is our third episode covering the second chapter of Sovereignty Through Mathematics, a a chapter called Financial Atheism. Yeah. And, uh, I know you're excited about this one and it's, uh, certainly a little bit more controversial, I think, than than the last one here. So I'm, I'm excited to dive in. And first I'll just mention that if, if you want to get involved with the discussion such as, for example, attending the recordings of these episodes live, uh, check out our Geyser Fund page where you can see all the details about how to support this project.
0:46 And as a reminder, the project is involving releasing all of the chapters of these books for free on noster, and these video explanations are also released for free. So if you, if you get value outta this and want to join the discussion, the best way to support us is to get involved and join the Bitcoin Infinity Academy. Absolutely, and you can also get the books on bitcoin infinity store.com. Alright, This is financial atheism chapter two of Sovereignty through Mathematics. Don't trust, verify is a common saying amongst Bitcoiners that represents a sound attitude towards not only Bitcoin but all human power structures.
1:27 In order to understand Bitcoin, one must admit that everything in society is manmade. Every civilization, every religion, every constitution, and every law is a product of human imagination. It wasn't until as late as the 17th century that the scientific methods started to become the dominant practice for describing how the world actually worked. Peer-to-peer review and repeated testing of a hypothesis are still quite recent human practices. Before this, we were basically just guessing and trusting authorities to a large extent. We still do this today, and despite our progress over the last couple of centuries, we still have a long way to go. Our brains are hardwired to follow the leader of the pack. The human brain is born with a plethora of cognitive biases pre-installed, and we have to work very hard to overcome them.
2:15 We evolve to survive in relatively small groups, and our brains are thus not really made for seeing the bigger picture. Bitcoin's proof of Work Algorithm is constructed in such a way that it is easy to verify that computational power was sacrificed in order to approve a block of transactions and claim its reward. In this way, no trust in any authority is required, as it is relatively trivial to test the validity of a block and the transactions it contains. This is nothing short of a complete reimagining of how human society ought to be governed. The beauty of mathematics governs the Bitcoin system. Everything that ever happens in Bitcoin is open and verifiable to everyone, even to those who are not yet using it.
3:01 Okay. Knut, what did you mean by that? Yeah, that, yeah, that's a big question for a big paragraph. Uh, yeah, it's, it's sort of, uh, saying that we, we have something now that is, uh, we, we have rules without rulers, I would say. that Bitcoin is completely auditable to everyone. Even the people not using it can, uh, uh, there are plenty of websites where you can see the, the, the blockchain. Of course, you need to run the software, uh, for yourself to actually know that what you're watching is the, the real thing. Uh, a third party websites can be corrupt. Uh, everyone should know that. and so, so running a node is really the only option if you really want to be sure that what you're seeing is actually Bitcoin and not some clone.
3:48 Uh, but yeah. Uh, the, the, uh, the point about the scientific method, That is something where, where I'm, my mind has, uh, I've changed my mind slightly about some of the stuff in this chapter. one of those things is like the, uh, trust in the scientific method. Bitcoin has actually made me trust that method slightly less. Uh, and see the beauty of, uh, the Austrian method, which is, uh, just deductive reasoning and, uh, uh, coming to conclusions, about the world using a fixed set of, uh, axiom, uh, irrefutable axioms. So, which it cannot be called the, uh, scientific method because the scientific method re refers to empiricism.
4:33 And, uh, the Austrian method is different like that because it's not really empiricism, it's an a prioritized science where, where you know things without having to test them. And any testing cannot. Deny nor confirm, uh, the hypothesis. So that's, uh, how Bitcoin differs from, from other things. But we'll, uh, this is sort of setting the stage here. We're getting into the juicy God stuff later, later in the chapter Yeah, I was, I was going to say that this sort of has ended up being, it's just foreshadowing the, the main bulk of this thing. Right. So, uh, you're, you're laying the groundwork for, for quite a lot of, quite a lot of stuff here, I would say, but it's not quite into the controversial part yet.
5:24 now. And, and, uh, Giamo pointed out to us, uh, the day before yesterday when we did a, a Twitter space as Giamo Soko from the Plan B Network that he would've called this App Chapter Financial Skepticism. And, uh, in hindsight, that might have been a, uh, better title. Even though, uh, financial atheism is a bit more on the nose and a bit more aggressive, but I'll, I'll, uh, lay out what I actually mean by atheism later in the, um, chapter. Perfect. Sounds good. Onto the next one. After the tragic events of nine 11 in 2001, Sam Harris started writing his book, the End of Faith, which happened to be released around the same time as Richard Dawkins.
6:10 The God Delusion, Daniel Dennet, breaking the Spell, and Christopher Hitchens, God is Not Great. Our religion poisons everything. These books kickstarted what in hindsight has often been referred to as the new atheist movement. Even though there has arguably never been anything new about atheism. Atheism must almost certainly have preceded religion since religious ideas require the person holding the idea to believe a certain doctrine or a story. Atheism is nothing but the rejection of ways to describe the world that are not verifiable by experimentation. A fly on the wall is probably an atheist by this definition of the word.
6:51 Atheism is often accused of being just another set of beliefs, but the word itself describes what it is much better, a lack of belief in theistic ideas. It is not a code of conduct or a set of rules to live your life by. It is simply the rejection of that which cannot be scientifically verified. Many people, religious people in particular, have a hard time grasping this. If you believe that a supernatural entity created everything in everyone's life, you might not be too comfortable with a word that describes a complete rejection of what you believe created everything, including the very atheist that the word describes. of different religious worldviews that exist is probably equal to the sum of all religious people on the planet.
7:37 All worldviews that reject these superstitious beliefs require, but one word atheism is not the opposite of religion, but it is simply the lack of it. Okay. Not only is, uh, that a big juicy paragraph, it's definitely one we disagree about quite a lot. And, uh, well, let's get into it. alright. what I would say is, in, in hindsight, it's, uh, if I had written this today, I probably wouldn't have mentioned that that fucker Sam Harris, because I really don't like him. And I think he sort of ex exemplifies what, what the risk of, uh, rejecting religious ideas might be. Because, uh, he, in my view is, is someone who replaced the idea, the, the, uh, belief in, Dogmatic, uh, religious stuff with, uh, uh, just an over belief in, in the scientific method and in, uh, uh, statism.
8:32 So during the lockdowns, for instance, he was, uh, firmly on the, um, on the wrong side of every debate, uh, and just, uh, thought that the government should decide everything for everyone. And this is, this is why, where my thinking is different on this subject today. I think it's, I, I, nowadays I view the state as, uh, maybe I did back then too, but, uh, I view the state as yet another religion. Uh. Back when I wrote this, I don't think I viewed it as the, the worst one, but I'm very close to doing that now. So, I mean, some religions are really wacky, but, but statism is a very dangerous one.
9:14 Putting your belief in that there will be some savior here on earth, uh, regardless of it's a religious savior or a political one is super, super duper uh, dangerous. So, so my stance has always been think for yourself, do your own thing. Like the, that scene from Life of Brian where we're all different, uh, that like, that's what I want, people to, to get away from this. Like, there is a way to live your life. setting your own rules. Also, I would say that there are a priori arguments against God, but that's, uh, another thing I, I think for instance, since all action is a product of, uh, or all human action is a product of a human feeling slightly uneasy and seeing something in the future that might make that future, uh, better for that human, where the EAs, uh, uneasiness is, uh, relieved, uh, that that's what triggers action.
10:10 And any omnipotent being that governs everything and knows everything, would never feel uneasy about a anything and thus never do anything. So if there is a, a, uh, um, deity, that deity is, uh, completely, uh, ha never has an incentive to do anything. So, yeah, that's, that's another thought there. Uh, curious to, to hear what you think about this look. Yeah. Thanks. Thanks Knu. And well, no, no, and, and actually, uh, first I'll just say like, uh, I, we don't disagree about a lot in, especially in the perspective of that. Yeah. Religion. Modern religions have many of their own problems. And, and knowing what this all ties into, I think is, is kind of the, the point here.
10:55 This sort of financial atheism thing. Uh, I don't want us to get bogged down in the atheism of the financial atheism topic. I wanna talk about the financial atheism, but, but there are a couple of things that specifically I'll, I'll, um, address here. O one is, I, I think you, you can't avoid mentioning Sam Harris because he is one of the so-called four horsemen of the, whatever they called it. Like, it's, it's a specific group you mentioned. That's why you mentioned Daniel Dennet, who I think you've, you've mentioned this is he's underappreciated, but he is the least, uh, uh, prolific or the, the lowest profile of the, the four, uh, notwithstanding that Christopher Hitchens died, but he was very high profile while he lived.
11:35 Yeah. And Christopher Hitchens, by the way, is the, the guy among this group that I'm most influenced by, uh, closely followed by Richard Dawkins, who I think is very un uh, underappreciated too in the Bitcoin space. I mean, the man coined the word meme for, uh, for Christ's sake. Uh, so yeah. Yeah. And what, what, what's funny is that I think he, he had a point where he could have embraced meme, different meanings of the word meme, but ba basically he's, he stayed pretty in his thinking, although I think he, he has gone on. Is it, is it even a couple of Bitcoin podcasts? Was he on what Bitcoin did? Um, No, he was, he was on, yeah, he was on the What is Money show?
12:19 Yeah, yeah, even though they, they, they didn't like nowadays, like, like Dawkins is old, right? And he refuses to touch certain subjects, economics being one of them, uh, and which is both good and bad. I, I would love to hear his ideas about it since he's been a, a bit of a status too, uh, and how that aligns with the atheism thought. Uh, but. I, I can understand that he doesn't wanna be, uh, you know, pigeonholed. I, I, I think he wants to stick to talking about biology and that he has dropped most of the, uh, religion versus non-religion stuff, uh, because he, uh, simply, simply doesn't want to go there. He wants to spend his time talking about biology.
12:59 Right. Right. No, and, and that, that's understandable for him, but I think he's, he's, all four of these guys are, are influential and, and I understand why these guys and their ideas kind of, they really set the tone for a certain decade, uh, or, or even couple of decades of, of thought, and especially thought that was in opposition to primarily the evangelical Christian right. In the United States, Yeah. And, and I, I really think, I really think the thing here I, no, I wouldn't say primarily I would say, uh, primarily against Islam. I, I'd say like, uh, but maybe packaged in a way that made, uh, the, uh, uh, evangelical right in the us uh, take offense, but, but, uh, I think like the, what triggered these books to be written was mostly, uh, nine 11 and Islam.
13:53 that's interesting. I, I, I mean, uh, I, if I'm remembering part of the cultural milieu at the time though, what happened after nine 11 was that the Evangelical right was ascendant in the United States for a while also. And those were the people that they were primarily bashing heads with. You didn't get a lot of, um, Dawkins or, or Hitchens or Sam Harris debating Islamic Scholars, for example. No, but, uh, they si uh, they, they sort of promoted people like Ayan, Harshi Ali, uh, and, uh, other, uh, people who had escaped, uh, Islam and, and pointed out that the, the underlying problem of, of, uh, is Islamist terrorists is Islam itself, and how, how the text, the, the texts are written in a certain way and which can't really be interpreted one way or another.
14:47 And like pointing out that some ideas are really, and some cultures are really worse than others. And there's, there's no, there should be no shaming in saying that. And, uh, yeah, I, I agree with that very much. is a spicy one. Definitely. But I, I think, I think the only part that I actually disagree with here, because it's not a disagreement, it's just more like they, they found themselves bombarded on all sides really. The, the, uh, the neo atheists, uh, they, they got it from evangelical Christians, they got it from Islam. Maybe they were primarily targeting Islam, but they, they definitely got into their, they got into lots of arguments with, with, uh, or debates. Some of them were actually sort of debates with, with evangelical Christians.
15:28 And, and actually this is, this is the one thing here too, is that I think you use atheism as sort of the, the absence of the, uh, Judeo-Christian Islamic, God, Uh, no, uh, the, the, the absence of any deity. Uh, so, so including like Zeus and Thor and all of that. Uh, so I'm using the same definition as Richard Dawkins uses in his, uh, uh, the God dilution. That's, that's where I got the, the it from But I'm saying your example you used is you're, you're basically counteracting specifically the, the Christian and the Islamic God, the this omnipotent, omnipresent thing. Many of the others don't do that. Oh, well, that, that was not in my, uh, definition of the word atheism.
16:11 That was in my, uh, like why I, why I personally don't think that there's an omni potent being. Sure, sure, sure, So, so that's the definition of that. And, uh, but the word itself, it's, to me is atheism. It's, it's safe self, uh, explanatory. It's a rejection of, uh, theistic beliefs. And here I agree with Christopher Hitchens that, uh, uh, extraordinary claims, uh, require extraordinary evidence. And I haven't seen any such extraordinary evidence of the existence of any deity. So, so, so until I do, I remain a skeptic and not a theist.
16:52 There we go. And, and actually I think when you said the term rejection here, this I think is important because I think many are uncomfortable, myself included with I identifying or self using the, the term atheist. And I think it is a, actually a proactive term. You, you say you're an atheist because you have intentionally rejected all of the other things. There's something else that is sort of the, I don't care, which is more, more where I'm at. Like I don't care, I don't, I don't actively reject the other things, but I, I, I don't really believe in anything specific, but I don't particularly care either enough to consider myself or identify with the term atheist. and, and, uh, uh, the word has been somewhat tainted, but to me it's, it's a word that is, uh, similar to the word liberalism or, or, or any other word that has been sort of hijacked by political forces or religious forces in the, in the, in the, uh, uh, talking about the word atheism.
17:50 I, I think that, one can shun these words or use them as they were once intended, but, What I'm trying to do here in this chapter is just, just explain a opposition, like, and, and it's, it's not really a chapter about the debate of the existence or non-existent of God or anything, or your de or Christian values or anything like that. It's about Bitcoin, and we're getting to that There we go. Which, which is, which is why I'm not going to, uh, prolong this for much longer, but I, I, I will also assert one more specific disagreement. Uh, or at least a, at least a, a light, um, shall we say, maybe semantic difference. Uh, I think it's not actually necessarily true that atheism must have preceded religion.
18:34 Uh, or at least, the, the, the idea that that humans never had ways of explaining that which was unknown. There might've been this kind of inkling of a time before consciousness kicked in, like, we don't really have an idea of that. We have biological homo sapiens, and did we have consciousness in the same way that entire time? But it's extremely likely that as long as we had what we call consciousness humans were using stories of some kind to describe, for lack of a better term, the unknown. And those weren't necessarily religions originally, especially not when humans just lived in little tribes of 20 people and stuff.
19:19 But they did have what you might call a mythology. They had ways of explaining the world. They, they. Passed down the lessons of society to each other in ways that could be considered the beginnings of religion or story. In other words, that's mostly to say I don't think atheism was ever like a conscious thing until we intentionally rejected it through thes the discovery of the scientific method, Yeah, I mean, I mean the, the word atheism cannot exist without there being such a thing as theism. So, so I would say in the beginning there was nothing. Then there was religion and then there was atheism. The rejection of it, like, because a rejection of something, something regret.
20:00 Is that something to, to exist first? although there likely was a state where, where humans existed without having some concept of God or, or even some concept of even things that you might call Gods. Uh, but, but now we're getting into like way where, where we're way, way too far off the path Yeah, yeah. We're going off on a tangent here, but I kind of like this one. I mean, the, the, we have observed chimpanzees, uh, performing, uh, and Bonobos, uh, performing re what looks like religious, uh, rituals. And I, the way I see it, you can interpret that two ways.
20:41 Either chimpanzees and bonobos also know that God exists, or this idea of this proto protos scientific method that is religion exists in other primates as well, because what I think it is, is like trying to explain the world, uh, to oneself by, by trying out different ideas. And it might, it might take a long time before you, uh, are wise enough to reject the specific ideas. And some of these ideas may have, uh, a very long lifespan. Well, and, and I, I think I would assert that you don't necessarily need to reject them, you just need to make them useful. And also, uh, I don't like it when religious people try to push their religious beliefs on others.
21:25 And those religions that have made that a central part of their religion, uh, sometimes they can be a bit of, they can be jerks, uh, when, when, when applying that. So real, real, real goofballs. And this applies to all religious people, including governments that, uh, kidnap kids and put them into schools for 12 years. Yeah. Live and live and let live. Definitely. And, and I, I know and respect many Christians. Uh, I Christians specifically. I don't actually, I don't really know many non non-Christians, religious, non. you know a handful of Jews, don't you Don't die. Yeah, yeah. yeah. Yeah. We have, uh, many you Jewish friends and I think we have some Muslim friends too.
22:09 I think so. I think so. And, and live and let live. As long as, as long as they're not saying, you know, convert or die or convert or go to hell, uh, we're good. And, uh, the government basically says that with, uh, uh, convert as in, you know, take the jab or, uh, be ostracized from society. So it's all the same thing. Right. Yeah. Alright, good. Here we go. Next one. In 2008, another subculture movement of unbelief was born, let's call it financial atheism, the rejection of unverifiable value claims. With the invention of Bitcoin, a way of rejecting fraudulent expressions of a token's value was born.
22:53 Those of us fortunate enough to have been born in secular countries all enjoy not having the ideas of religious demagogues dictating our lives. On a daily basis, we can choose which ideas to believe in and which to reject. What we still have very limited means of choosing, however, are the ways in which we express value to each other. We're told to use a system in which we all have a certain number of value tokens assigned to our name, either as a number on a screen or as digits on paper notes. We all live in the collective hallucination that these numbers are somehow legit and that their authenticity is not to be questioned. A Bitcoin balance assigned to a certain Bitcoin address might seem just as questionable to a layman, but if you have a basic understanding of the hashing algorithms and the game theory behind it, it's not at the time of writing.
23:41 The hash of the latest block on the Bitcoin blockchain begins with 18 zeros in a row. These zeros represent the proof of work that ensures that this block is valid and that every transaction in it actually happened. If you can grasp the concept of a hashing algorithm and if you have an intuition about mathematics, you realize the gargantuan amount of calculating effort that went into finding this particular hash. It's simply mind blowing. To forge a false version of a hash beginning with 18 zeros just wouldn't be economically viable. Of course, you can never actually know that a 51% attack or some other attempt at corrupting the blockchain hasn't occurred, but you can know that such an attack would require more than half of the network acting against our own economic interest.
24:25 Bitcoin is not something to believe in. You don't need to trust any authority because you can validate the plausibility of its authenticity yourself. It's the financial equivalent of atheism or unbelief. Satoshi wasn't Jesus. Satoshi was Brian of Nazareth telling his fathers to think for themselves. I wonder how many people know that reference. Yeah, if, if, uh, if you don't know the last reference there, I highly recommend Monty Python's life of Brian. It's one of the best comedies ever made, in my opinion. anyway, this is, uh, this is the view. I, I somewhat still hold, or, or not somewhat. I, I still hold this view. Uh, Bitcoin is a way to, uh, verify everything like the, the only way you can know that no one is counter-fit.
25:14 Uh. The more units of the money you are using is to know every single transaction that happens and that ever happened in, uh, in that system. And the only way to do that is to run a Bitcoin node and actually verify it for yourself. So, so, so this, in this sense, Bitcoin is the, the first skeptics money or atheist money or whatever you, uh, word you prefer. the, the only one that doesn't require belief in the central bank and the politicians behind the money printer to be ethical. Uh, and this, this is what intrigued me about Bitcoin in the beginning.
25:56 There's, there's a, a reason that this is a quite early chapter in, in my book series here, because this is one of the most mind, uh, was one of the most mind blowing things to me. And I know many other people, this is what's so funny about the whole, um, atheist versus religious people thing in Bitcoin because I know just as many people that came to Bitcoin from a, uh, a religious worldview and that view it sort of as a cult. I view Bitcoiners as the, the ones leaving the cult, not the ones in the cult. So, but it's fascinating to me how you can end up with, uh, loving Bitcoin for so many different reasons. And there are so many different paths to the same, um, group of insights.
26:37 So this, um, and this is my path and uh, what I've tried to explain in words here. On this section, we are in complete lockstep. I, I, uh, I completely agree with you here. It's, it's definitely a spicy take. I, I, yeah. It's a spicy take, but I agree with it. all the other money requires some kind of trust or belief and yeah, I, I just, I just, it's one of those things that once you get it, you get it, right? Like, we've talked about this before in terms of that, that there are just parts of the Bitcoin thing that once you understand the implications, it, it, it's definitely not a good thing that all of the rest of the money in the world requires verification, right?
27:21 Like, I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna sit here. I, I might be able to go and make the argument that there's some purpose for religious systems and, and people can find meaning in that, but no one finds meaning in the fiat monetary system. No. And, uh, regardless of if you find meaning or not, like to actually know whether something is true or not, you do, you need the don't trust, verify mentality? Uh, so, so sure you can derive value from a story. I, I, I buy that, but that doesn't necessarily make it like true in the sense of this is objectively true. So, so in my view, Bitcoin is built like, uh, skepticism is at the very foundation of what Bitcoin is.
28:04 Don't trust, verify is skepticism. Yeah. And well, uh, I think, uh, I think another interesting thing here that you, that you include in the book at, at the time of writing, that the, the amount of work that goes into verifying each Bitcoin block, it was 18 zeros. This was back in 2019 though, right? It's, it's way more than that now. So it just keeps getting, it just keeps intensifying right. Yeah. And, uh, uh, and uh, I think that like the, the very core concepts of, of, uh, Bitcoin are here in, in this text, uh, that it's, it's expensive to try to cheat the system that's, that's at, it's more expensive to try to cheat it than to just follow the rules and that that's what makes it great.
28:51 Shall we continue? Absolutely. Alright. The first law of thermodynamics, also known as the Law of Conservation of Energy states that energy cannot be created or destroyed in an isolated system. The second law states that the entropy of any isolated system always increases. And the third law states that the entropy of a system approaches a constant value as the temperature approaches absolute zero. In the Bitcoin network, participants known as miners compete for new Bitcoin in a lottery with very fixed rules. The more hashing power, computing power a miner contributes to the network, the higher his chances of winning the block reward a a specific amount of Bitcoin that is halved every four years.
29:34 The difficulty of this lottery, in other words, the minor's chance of winning it is recalibrated every 2016 block so that the average time it takes to find the next block is always roughly 10 minutes. What the system produces is absolute scarcity. The amount of Bitcoin in existence at any moment in time is always predictable. The more time that passes, the slower the rate of coin issuance and the block rewards slowly approaches zero. By the time it does around the year 2140, the individual miner's incentive to mine for award will at least theoretically have been replaced by an incentive to collect transaction fees from the participants of the network.
30:15 Even now, the sum of all fees make up a non-trivial part of the miner's revenue. Yet from a user's point of view, the fees are still very low, and as the network scales up using layer two solutions such as the Lightning Network, they're expected to remain low for quite a long time ahead. So another connection of Bitcoin to physics, right? I. Yeah. Um. Not, not directly tying it to physics here, uh, which is good. Uh, but yeah, uh, there, there's, there's a wonderful meme going around, uh, about, uh, it's a Venn diagram. Uh, and in one circle there's people who, who, who are against Bitcoin or Bitcoin's opponents.
30:59 And on the, in the other circle are people who can, uh, accurately explain the difficulty, uh, adjustment algorithm. And in the middle, in the cross section are people who don't exist. Uh, be because you cannot, you cannot be against Bitcoin if, if it clicks for you the difficulty adjustment algorithm and how, how amazing, uh, a discovery that is. Uh, it maybe, it would be fair to say that the group of people in the middle are liars and con men. Yeah. But that means that they're either. They either are Bitcoin proponents that they just pretend to not be, or, or they simply don't understand the difficulty adjustment algorithm.
31:43 Or they're fans of Ethereum? Yeah. Yeah. Uh, so, so yeah. So they are fans of Bitcoin then because the only purpose of Ethereum is to make the founders of Ethereum earn more Bitcoin, yes, there we go. That's, that's a, that's, yes. Very good point here. No, and, um, and I like the explanation here. This is just intensifying, like these first two chapters of this book. Just, just speaking, um, from the, the level of reading these both together, like someone reads this as the introduction to Bitcoin. I don't know exactly who's doing that, but you know, if you were, you're getting hit with, I. Big ideas right at, right off the bat.
32:23 This, this isn't for the faint of heart, but, but they're big important ideas that, that really underpin what Bitcoin is and what Bitcoin is about. And I, I never thought of sovereignty through mathematics as a, as a beginner book, but in a lot of ways it, it does explain a lot of the, the concepts that are important to know about Bitcoin. Just, just not in, in one of these structured ways that, that sort of handholds, you know? Yeah. No, I, I, I view it as a beginner's book, um, uh, as very, maybe a very specific type of beginner. Uh, is there a, like you said, faint of heart there. Is there such a thing as faint of brain? Oh yeah. Uh, I know some people like that.
33:05 Okay, good to know. Let's get on with it, shall we? Okay. Absolute scarcity is a concept that mankind has never encountered before. Arguably this makes it the first manmade concept to ever be directly linked to the laws of physics. Everything anyone does requires a certain amount of energy. The very word doing implies that some kind of movement, some type of energy expenditure needs to occur. As mentioned earlier, how we value things is entirely subjective. Different actions are of different value to different people. How we value different things is also inevitably linked to the supply of those things.
33:47 Had the trapped under ice winter diver mentioned in chapter one, being equipped with a scuba tank, he probably wouldn't have thought of his next breath. As such a precious thing, the price, a person is willing to pay for a good. In other words, the sum of one or more person's actions can be derived from two basic variables. The highly objective demand for the good and the always constrained by time and space supply of that same good. Note that if supply is sufficiently limited, there only needs to be a minimal amount of demand for a good for its price to increase. One could argue that no one needs Bitcoin and that therefore Bitcoin would have no intrinsic value.
34:27 One could also argue that there's no such thing as intrinsic value. Since demand is always subjective. In any case, there will always be a cost to mine Bitcoin, and the more mining power in the network, the higher that cost. This cost insured by the Bitcoin network's proof of work algorithm is probably as close to a pure energy cost as the price of a human activity will ever get. Once the mining rig is in place, a simple conversion process follows energy in scarce token out. Should the cost of production exceed the current price of the token, the miner can just choose not to sell, thereby limiting the supply of Bitcoin and circulation even more, and eventually selling them for other goods whenever he sees fit.
35:12 In this sense, Bitcoin is a battery, perhaps the best battery ever invented. Now I know you have some things to say about this section. Yes. This is about how every action requires energy. So, so it's, it's sort of about how physics and, uh, uh, the, the. Objectiveness of physics and the subjectiveness of ology are linked together. Like we, we, we link the two realms. Uh, I mean, I believe that the dichotomy of subjective, uh, objective is somewhat false, but we're, we're not going there just yet. That comes in clown world way next year. So, but, but the thing that links the two worlds, so that bridges the two worlds is human action.
35:57 And, uh, in Bitcoin, this is, this is very clear. What, what, what, what's going on? You're, you're sacrificing a very specific amount of actual energy. Duals even, uh, for a, a slice of the world's, uh, only digital pie, like the only. I, I, I use the word absolute scarcity here. Uh, a lot. If I'd written this book today, I would say that Bitcoin are not absolutely scarce, but absolutely finite. Uh, scarcity is always, uh, contextual. So like, uh, it's, it's not, uh, as it's not describing Bitcoin as well, I think, so they're, they're not absolutely scarce.
36:41 Well, they are too. But first and foremost, there's absolutely finite, which is what creates the absolute scarcity afterwards or the scarcity of them. Uh, scarcity is not absolute. It's always, it always fluctuates. Uh, and it's always in the eye of the beholder, which finiteness is not, I would say scarcity is, is scarcity, is, uh, subjective, somewhat subjective, while, uh, being finite is something objective. So, so it's still, uh, this hearkens back a lot to the, the, the last chapter because this is all, all about the. Uh, demand being subjective and, uh, supply being objective. How, how this, uh, how it links the objective and the subjective.
37:25 and I think that's very, a crucial thing to understand when trying to understand Bitcoin and the problem it solves. I. Absolutely agree and well, you know, I think, I think I'm still more of a proponent of the battery analogy than, than you are here now. Uh, but I, but I still think it's, it's useful. It's, it's a really useful, analogy here because, because the, the idea that a miner, a bitcoin miner can expend energy and get Bitcoin back anywhere in the world, thereby, being able to capture stranded. Energy sources or, uh, more difficult to, to access, but, but maybe not as expensive to access something like that.
38:06 It, it is a way of, of taking energy from somewhere and converting it into something that can be then sold for other goods and services. So the battery analogy, it's not, it's not a literal battery, it's not a literal battery in the sense of an electrical battery. It's not a way of taking that energy and storing that energy for further use in the literal energy sense, the physical movement of something. But it is it is, it is a battery for battery for well in the sense that, that you, you can hold some of that value. You can capture that value and move it over the internet and use it later. So in that sense, I think the battery analogy still works.
38:50 It's it. If you will, subjective energy, uh, which is a very weird term, and it's like, so, so the physics nerd in me prevents me from, from using the term, uh, like using the analogy anymore. I, I, I'm not a super fan of it, but not only because it doesn't link to physics, but because it's sort of under appreciates Bitcoin because more than it's, it's more than a battery. It's an amplifier too, because as long as the total economic pie grows over time, the, the, the energy store stored or the value stored, it's not only staying the same, but, but growing over time. So it buys you more the, the longer you wait.
39:31 and uh, another part of not using the, uh, um. Digi the Bitcoin is a battery analogy anymore, is that I don't like the term digital energy because I, I think digital to begin with, uh, is not anything crucial to Bitcoin. It, whether it's digital or not, doesn't really matter. and the energy metaphor omits that a Bitcoin miner is not the asic that some, uh, that is plugged into the wall or the hangar full of them. It, uh, the computers involved. It is the, the, the actual miner is the guy who owns the asics and decides to run the, the code, uh, which we explain further in, in clown world too.
40:14 Uh, so, so I think all, almost all metaphors and analogies in Bitcoin are somewhat, uh, insufficient to describe what Bitcoin is because Bitcoin is so much more than the sum of its parts and it's very hard to isolate one or. One thing or another that it is when it's, when it's so much bigger, uh, than that. So, so, so every, every single metaphor is underwhelming or insufficient in some way. I can agree with. That on the one hand, while on the other saying that each of these metaphors is a way to maybe get into someone's brain Yep. and, and it only takes one, right?
40:57 I think that's, that's one of the points of Bitcoin is that once, once one thing clicks for you, you suddenly discover all the things and then everything clicks. You take the orange pill and suddenly you are a toxic Bitcoin maxi. Something like that. Uh, so, so the battery analogy is useful, uh, uh, in, in that sense as, as being a, a way of propagating an idea that might take hold with some people, especially those that value, or, or actually, especially with those who think that Bitcoin mining is this evil thing and don't understand what it's actually doing. And the, the real world effects that I really, really doubt that Satoshi could have ever envisioned for, for bitcoin.
41:41 the effects that, that bitcoin mining, chasing down all of the, the cheapest energy in the world actually have. No, he probably didn't predict that. Like, uh, one thing I thought of now when you're talking about that it might have a usefulness, is that. That's akin to the religious stories, right? So, so this is, uh, Bitcoin as a battery is, might not be literally true, but it might have some, some, uh, storytelling value. Just as you know, the meek shall inherit the earth or, or some religious thing, uh, that you can interpret in a way that has value to you. And that's how I view, uh, metaphors for what Bitcoin is in as one aspect or another.
42:23 I love it. I love it. I think we will touch more on mining plenty, uh, over the series. There's gonna be way more on that, but, uh, it, it's an important area and, and. A lot of the opposition to Bitcoin that is, that is really hung up on that, that bitcoin mining uses more energy than Norway or something. Uh, those, those arguments are unfortunate and, and probably are holding back some people from taking a close look at it. And so I it, in, in one sense, I really do think it's important for us to f bust to, to really directly take out those ideas. And so, um, discussions of mining and, and, uh, even things like talking about it like a, like a battery, I, I think are important for those reasons.
43:11 Yeah. And, uh, there, there is at least one chapter about environmentalism in, in each and every one of these books. A about, uh, FD busting the energy. Uh, stuff. So, yeah, and like I can just throw out the little thought nugget here that is also going to, uh, come back in this series. And that is that miners do not create bitcoins. They get paid in Bitcoins by the users of the network that actually create the Bitcoins Miners, uh, create blocks and they create block space by finding blocks. And they, we allow them to, uh, make a Coinbase transaction to themselves, thereby getting newly into Bitcoin.
43:56 But it's not them that, uh, they are the slaves of the users or the, the no runners and the, the economic incentives of the network. They are not the ones creating the Bitcoins. Now this stuff is important. This stuff is definitely important, and two things can be true at the same time. Here again, uh, one, it can be true that these metaphors are useful for people to understand it. But the other thing too, I think, and I, and I think, I think every. Thing that we dig into. And that the reason for going all the way down to, uh, the root and really finding what's true about things is that it's also important to know what is actually the case. And, uh, and, and I, I think it's, it's always, it's always good to, to be precise and to understand what's actually going on here.
44:41 Use these metaphors as ways of explaining to your normie friends what happens with Bitcoin, but, but understand what's really happening at the core. That's important. And yeah, I, I think we, we strive for both those things in some kind of balance. I. Absolutely. I mean the, the books about Bitcoin I've written were easier to write in the sense that I could throw words around more than I could when I wrote the ology book, because in ology when writing about that subject, you need to be super precise. Every word needs to be 100% defined and used only in the context that it was like in the way that it was supposed to be used. Uh, here I can say things like Bitcoin is a battery and stuff more easily.
45:25 So the the, it makes these books maybe not as precise, but it makes them more colorful, I think. And, uh, maybe that's, uh, can orange pill a person or two if it just, if my books only orange pill one person I'm, I, I still view them as a success. Perfect. I'm, I'm sure they have orange peel more than one person, but let's, let's keep going, shall we? Storing and moving electrical energy around has always been costly and wasteful. Bitcoin offers a way of converting energy into a small part of a specific number, a mathematical battery, if you will. It is important to remember that it does not convert energy into value directly, but rather electricity into digital scarcity.
46:11 Digital scarcity that can be used to express value. Energy cannot be created or destroyed in an isolated system as the first law of thermodynamics clearly states. Bitcoin can express how much energy was sacrificed in order to acquire a share of the total sum. You can also acquire Bitcoin by buying it rather than mining it. But in doing so, you also spend energy. You somehow acquired the money with which you bought the Bitcoin, You or someone else sacrificed time and energy somewhere. Bitcoin lets you express that you see that there's a connection between value and scarcity by letting you sacrifice effort to claim a part of the total sum.
46:51 I thought when I started reading this paragraph that, that maybe we had already kind of covered the, the point of it, but, but no, I, I think the, the actual point of this section that, that you always expend energy somehow to get the Bitcoin. That's, that's, that's a different nuance than what we were talking about and an important one. Yeah. Uh, and it's absolutely true. Like you have to expend some kind of energy to get something back. Like this is a, this is a completely voluntary system. You can't just threaten someone and say, give me all your money. Like, uh, that. You need to provide something of value to the other person, whether that is mining or providing a good service, that's another discussion.
47:33 But this is the point of the system. It's like an isolated system where, uh, people have to provide something that the other person values in order to get a part of, of this finite pie, and that's what makes it so beautiful. Yeah. And, and this was one thing that just didn't click for me earlier on in my crypto journey, so to say, like, I, I didn't really understand what was the purpose of, of proof of work mining kind of generally. uh, and the, the proof of stake stuff, those, those, those folks were making like really serious arguments, especially back when Ethereum was thinking of dropping the proof of work. Um.
48:14 Understanding things like this, that, that no matter what you do, you, you always are expending energy somehow. Uh, I think somehow that what that did was, was get it so that the mining isn't actually doing anything different than anyone else. They're, they're performing the function for the network, like we talked about earlier, the, the, the block creation. But no matter what, someone is performing energy somewhere, uh, or maybe a even better way of describing it is someone is doing something of value to someone else to get a nice token in exchange for that value. It just, it all comes, it all comes back. Uh, everyone is doing something in order to get these value tokens that we call money.
48:56 And Bitcoin is no different. It's just, uh, it is just perfectly finite. So I, I don't know, uh, the, the overall point is the un understanding. This one, I, I think this one was really quite important to grok what Bitcoin actually is. And, uh, uh, it also highlights why proof of stake, like we're living in proof of stake. Now, the Federal Reserve is a proof of stake system. the, the, the ones with the biggest piles of cash, uh, can afford the biggest guns and therefore set the rules for everyone else in the system. And, and if they have a money printer, they, they win that race.
49:36 And, uh, especially if the, the world's reserve currency. So, uh. Proof of proof of work is so different and Bitcoin in particular because you can't just copy proof of work, then that sort of takes away the point of proof of work, uh, in that, uh, this is the, the costliness thing. So it's, it's sort of you. Computer. Up until 2009, computers had been used for copying stuff. Everything on a computer is a copy of a copy of a copy. Like when you send an email, you, you don't actually send it, you copy the data and put it on the other computer. Like, so, so everything, uh, is a copy and we can flip that on its head.
50:18 Like, how can we use computers to, to, to create something that cannot be copied? And it's by flipping the script completely and expanding as much computing power as possible rather than as little computing power as possible, which is true for all, like, which is what programmers strive to do, uh, in every other aspect of computing. But this is just like, you just flip that on its head and you get something that you cannot copy. And uh, yeah, I just love that I. Uh, love it too. All of this stuff, uh, all of this intricacies of mining and why it works. Stuff super fascinating. Uh, not a tangent exactly.
51:00 'cause I don't think we'll spend much time on it, but I, I really enjoyed, uh, uh, when we visited Slovenia, the, the Nice hash conference and got to have lots of good conversations about the, the mining stuff and deepen our, uh, understanding of, of that side of things always interesting. Yeah, super interesting. Okay, let's continue. The excitement we so-called Bitcoin Maximalist feel about Bitcoin does not come primarily from the enormous gains that those who hopped early onto the freight train have been blessed with. Nor is it because we're in it for the technology as can often be heard from opponents. Those of us who preach the near divinity of this invention do so above all, because we see the philosophical impacts of absolute scarcity in a commodity, the idea of a functioning solution to the double spending problem in computerized money is an achievement that simply can't be ignored by solving the double spending problem.
51:57 Satoshi also made counterfeiting impossible, which in turn makes artificial inflation impossible. The world changing potential of this invention cannot be understated, not in the long run. The more you think about it, the more the thought won't give you any peace of mind. If this experiment works, if it's real, it will take civilization to the next level. What we don't know is how long this will take. Right now, debates in the Bitcoin space are about Bitcoin's functionality as a medium of exchange and its potential as a good store of value. We might be missing the point we cannot possibly know if a type of monetary token for which you're completely responsible with no third party protection will ever become a preferred medium of exchange for most transactions.
52:45 Nor can we know if the price of Bitcoin will follow the hype cycle path that we all want it to follow, so that it can become the store of value that most maximalist claim It already is. we've been focused on the wrong things all along. Maybe Bitcoin's greatest strength is in its functionality as a unit of account. After all, this is all that Bitcoin does. If you own 21 Bitcoin, you own 1000000th of the world's first absolutely scarce commodity. This might not make you rich overnight, but it just might have something to do with the opportunities available to your great-great-grandchildren.
53:28 Yeah, this, uh, I used the word divinity here in the beginning and it makes me think of like how, how all these wonderful paradoxes, gigge made a talk about this once, uh, like how Bitcoin is, uh, fuck you money and love at the same time, and how Bitcoin is, uh, financial atheism and a religion at the same time. And I, I. This is one thing, one thing I've thought about in, in terms of like religious stuff and, and Bitcoin is, uh, Pascal's wager, which says that you might as well the, the, the TLDR on Pascal's wager is that you might as well believe in God because, uh, if you do, you may go to heaven and if, if you don't, you, you can go to hell.
54:13 Uh, the, the problem that I have with Pascal's wager as a concept is that it, it, it simply doesn't take any of the other 5,000 religions out there into, uh, into account at all. But with Bitcoin, Pascal's wager, AC actually works because if you believe in Bitcoin and if you devote your life to the God that is Bitcoin, you actually make. Uh, the likelihood of this coming true and this, this utopia here on earth be, uh, is closer. The more, the more in in time, the more you believe in, in the concepts, uh, and the more, the more you devote your life to it. So Pascal's wager works, but only if by God you actually mean Bitcoin coin.
54:55 It's so funny. It's, it's, it's such a, uh, it's so funny that the wager actually works like that. And I mean, it isn't something that people are necessarily going to take up, uh, automatically. And, and actually maybe this pascal's wager framing is actually going to make some people viscerally oppose that somehow, uh. But, but I think it's a, it's a good, uh, a good analogy that, that, uh, if this is going to work, it's either gonna go to an infinity or to zero, basically, uh, being on the side of getting some piece of that pie. And again, this comes back to the, the absolute finite pie of what Bitcoin is.
55:39 There's, there's so many layers to this, but, but really that's the core of what did it for me once I understood well, I mean, okay, what really did it for me was, I, I got that there's no inflation to Bitcoin now. Okay. Ignoring that it's still technically inflating until 2140, but it, it's, it's not though, like I, I, I got immediately that it's 21 million of these things and you get a certain amount of that, that's, you've got that piece of that pie forever, right? As long as you can maintain control of your keys, which isn't trivial, but, okay, let's pretend it's trivial. But that one thing means there's a, there's now a fixed denominator.
56:22 You can put a fixed denominator on the economy. That's the unit of account part, basically. And if you do that, GDP growth is literally, should mean that prices are, are deflating. It's just that the, the denominator keeps increasing. At the same time also, this constant, this constant chasing of GDP growth is actually saying that, that, uh, there is more in the pie as a whole. And so prices should be deflating. It's the Jeff Booth hypothesis. Uh, which, which we have talked about how you also have similar, um, takes on, on this, I think later coming up in this book. Right. We'll, we'll touch on this more. Yeah.
57:02 And, uh, uh, especially in the next book, independence Reimagined. That's is, that's is all about that. So, so I have a couple of other things to say about these two paragraphs and, and this book in general. I, all of my books, like the primary reason or what I want the reader to take away from them is just, I want, I want them to trigger a thought in the brain of the reader. So, so they're not like, I'm not advocating for one thing or another, really. Uh, these are meant to be thought nuggets. That's the, the Pascal's wager thing is a brain fart. Everything else in here is sort of brain farts that are, and if, if, if you, uh, happen to sniff on a particular part of your, uh, of your liking, then uh, I have succeeded like that.
57:48 You, you. That is, that is what the books are, are all about. Uh, another thing to mention about these, these two paragraphs in particular is the word bitcoin Maximalist, which is a dero. It was intended as a derogatory term and invented by Vitalic Butrin, the creator of Ethereum. To, to sort of, yeah, to promote his shit coin basically. And, and tell every Bitcoin believer who didn't also want a Ethereum, that they were not open-minded enough. But as Terry PR said, the problem with an open mind is that people would come along and try to put stuff in it, stuff like Ethereum. So, uh, uh, well, the Bitcoin, the Bitcoiners took the term to heart and, uh, uh, wore it as, uh, as armor.
58:34 Instead. We are proud Bitcoin maximalist, the whole point of Bitcoin is that there can be only one. It's uh, Highlander money. No, absolutely. And, uh, yeah, as funny as the term is the, the origins of the term Bitcoin maximalist, it, it's not just a badge of honor. It's, it's an actual correct term, I think. And, and it's, it's important to say that, yeah, you, you, I don't think you can really be a Bitcoin or if you advocate that other cryptocurrencies, shit coins are. Any good at all? Um, because you, once again, it's just the whole case of once you see the thing, once you get Bitcoin, that's it, and you're not really there if you still think the other cryptos or the, or fiat currencies for that matter, still have value of any kind.
59:24 I think we still carve out a little bit of, a little bit of, um, uh, space for stable coins as a, as a good intermediate measure, uh, a good way of bridging the gap between the fiat system and Bitcoin. But it's, um, that's not the same thing as, as a, as a token that exists solely to separate, uh, a fool from his money. No, I mean, stable coins are a tool, uh, to use in the fiat system that you are still forced to use to some extent. Uh, it's important to remember though, that. All fiat systems are pyramid schemes, uh, uh, as any other shitcoin like there, there's, uh, I think I go into this in a later chapter.
1:00:06 I, I was, uh, I view them as cryptocurrencies, which are the cryptos and K cryptocurrencies, which are the, the fiat tokens. They're all designed to enrich their issuer. Bitcoin doesn't have an issuer. This is crucial to understand. Uh, and, uh, I don't remember where I was going with that. That's okay. I think we'll cover it more later. And I think now, now let's, uh, let's sum up, I think, we'll, we'll take the, the last couple of paragraphs here. Okay. Throughout history. Whenever a prehistoric human tribe invented ceremonial burial, that tribe began to expand rapidly.
1:00:49 Why? Because as soon as you invent belief in an afterlife, you also introduce the idea of self-sacrifice on a larger scale. People who held these beliefs were much easier for a desperate to manipulate and send into battle with neighboring tribes. Religious leaders can use people's fears and superstitions to have them commit all sorts of atrocities to their fellow man, and they still do so today. Belief in a greater good can be the most destructive idea that can pop up in a human mind. The Nazis of World War II Germany believed that exterminating Jews was for the greater good of their nation's. Gene pool belief in noble causes often comes with unintended side effects, which can have disastrous consequences.
1:01:32 Religious leaders, political leaders, and other power hungry sociopaths are responsible for the greatest crimes against humanity ever committed. Namely Wars. Europeans often question the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution, which protects the right to bear arms whenever a tragic school shooting occurs on the other side of the Atlantic. everyone seems to forget is that less than a hundred years ago, Europe was at war with itself because its citizens had given too much power to their so-called leaders. The Nazis came to power in a democracy. Never forget that our individual rights weren't given to us by our leaders. We were born with them. Our leaders can't give us anything. They can only force us to behave in certain ways.
1:02:15 If we truly want to be in charge of our lives, we need to find the tools necessary to circumvent the bullshit ourselves. Chapter. Yeah, this is, um, the, the Road to Hell is paved with good intention comes to mind that, that saying that this is basically what this, uh, this says, uh, and. Comparing the Nazis of World War II to religious sacrifices. That's another thing. I mean, the, the, the point here is that no man has the, uh, inherent right to rule another man. Uh, uh, it's basically the non-aggression principle I'm alluding to here, and, uh, basic libertarian philosophy that, uh, the le the leaders of the world, whether they're religious or political, They, they have no inherent right to call themselves that and to, and to take your stuff and to tell you what to do.
1:03:17 Uh, and the sooner you realize this, the, the, the more fulfilling your life can be because you can reclaim the driver's seat and start, um, start taking your life to where you want to take it and, and not wear some power. Hungry sociopath, which is the word I use here, uh, tells you to take it. Yeah, the, this conclusion somewhat is a little disconnected from the rest of the point of the chapter. And, and I, I, I mean, I, I, I think we'll come across that as this, this was more your, your writing style early on. Nothing, nothing wrong with that. It was just that the, the, um, many, many of these conclusions were ultimately tangents to a certain extent, um, in the, in, but in, in this case, it's not, it's not that it's totally unrelated at all.
1:04:03 The, the, the self-sacrifice part goes back to the financial atheism generally. And, and this is, this is again, where it's sort of, I, I think, I think that's one aspect of the, the self-sacrifice thing. But, but we touched on this in the, in the. The first episode here, the first chapter. That, that the, the self-sacrifice thing is also what enables society to grow generally. Right? It, it is double-edged sword or two-sided coins. In all cases, advancements always lead to increased productivity or prosperity somehow, or else they wouldn't be advancements. But there's, there's downsides. AI is one of these things that we might be dealing with quite a lot here, but automation, ai, all, all this like, uh, greatly increased cognitive, um, advancements, but maybe, maybe there, there's an over alliance on technology and, and, uh, less jobs to go around for people, right?
1:04:52 And this, this self-sacrifice thing is another one. The, the, uh, very concept of these sort of proto religions are, are also coincided with adoption of. Organized hunting, organized agriculture, the beginnings of civilization. But, but of course the, the downside to that is that civilizations can be, can be weaponized somehow. And, and I don't think we've ever gotten around that, that charismatic people who, who want power can persuade others and, uh, uh, having those people being also in charge of the money printer is probably also a very bad thing, not probably, definitely.
1:05:35 There's nothing wrong with humans organizing themselves in groups. We need that for survival, and we need intersubjective belief systems like language to, to, to get anywhere. Uh, it's just that, uh, when, when these belief systems come at the expense of the individual, uh, their, their object objectively bad, or I at least I view them as bad. So sacrifice is a, a, an interesting word. Uh, what what you really want is not sacrifice, but delayed gratification. So you want, you want something, you, you want to give something up in the now, uh, to, to get something later. Uh, the, the afterlife belief in an afterlife, uh, analogy is because, uh, yeah, you, you can clearly see this, that when, when ceremonial burial is invented, then.
1:06:26 Civilizations grow. But that's not necessarily because ceremonial burial was a good thing. Uh, if aliens saw that, they would probably, uh, view us as idiots. Like, why are you digging dead bodies into the ground and putting stones next to them? Because, uh, more so than good for the individual who is already dead, the, the ceremonial burial is good for the leader who can tell you that if you do this and that in this life, you'll get a better life, uh, next time you're reincarnated or whatever, or in heaven or something like that. So there, there's a potential that these things, uh, can be used by, by people who you don't want to use these tools to, to make the 18 year olds go and kill the other tribe on the other side of the river.
1:07:15 Uh, in, in my opinion, I. Civilization happens when we trade with one another, not when we kill one another. So it's basically a war cry for individualism versus collectivism like everything else in these books. Well, what's funny here about this, and, and I, I certainly agree with that. But, but I, I think maybe you, you overemphasize like possibly I underemphasize the, the or, or overemphasize the opposite. The, uh, I, I think you, you overemphasize the top downness of religion. Uh, uh, I, I think there's ample evidence that that's not really how religion works most of the time. It's No, no, I'm, I'm not saying that it's, uh, mandated, top down.
1:07:57 I'm saying that the psychopaths use the, the fact that other people have this set of beliefs for their own gain. So, so it, yeah. And that's very important to set, uh, to, to clarify, I don't think that some psychopath came up with the idea of God, that's, that's not what I'm saying at all. Or the concept of heaven and hell or anything like that. I, I'd say that, uh, there's a risk involved that these people will use these ideas against people. Uh, uh. People's best interests. There we go. And I, I full, I fully agree with that. And, and, and you know, I, I think the meta thing that if, if I can sum up my thoughts about this, this whole thing, that, that Bitcoin becomes a tool for the individual to safeguard against others, being able to use money against them.
1:08:50 But that's also sort of all that it is, the, the entire rest of the, the coin here is that responsibility still lies with the individual to do with it, what they will and, and the risk of the. World going to shit irrespective of what any of us do. That's, that's always going to be present. But we can now do things, we can do one specific thing to take back some of that control and live life, how we want to associate with the people we, we want to, the community that is cropping up around Bitcoiners is a, is a pretty awesome one and it's, uh, it's a lot of fun to be involved in that.
1:09:31 Um, so yeah, bi Bitcoin is financial atheism. We might have a couple of disagreements on, on semantics of, of the word atheism or, or of the term sacrifice or whatever it is. But, but broadly, broadly, uh, I think it's, it's a very astute observation and, and it's not atheism in a way that means to antagonize religious people. It's, it's really the, the concept of money that that does not need to be believed in, which is extremely important. Yeah, no, you can, don't trust, verify is the, uh, the TLDR of this chapter? Perfect. Is that, is that, uh, where we'll leave this chapter?
1:10:13 I think so. I have many other thoughts, but, uh, we have plenty of time to discuss them in later chapters. So, so don't trust, verify people, uh, like, subscribe, run a node and brush your damn teeth. Yeah. Uh, I'll echo that exactly. And, and, uh, uh, now that we're at the end of the chapter, let us know what you think. Uh, leave a comment in YouTube or Rumble if you're watching there. Uh, if you're listening on, for example, fountain, uh, send us, send us a note on, on Noster or, or Twitter or something like that. Uh, let us know what you think. Share the episode. Definitely don't forget to like and subscribe wherever you are.
1:10:54 Every little bit helps us reach more people. And the other thing you can do, by the way, is uh, go to our Geyser page and you can see all the details of what we're running here at the Bitcoin Infinity Academy. You can join our telegram group where we have all of our, all of our news, everything we're up to, and you can chat with us about everything that's going on. And we also have the Bitcoin, uh, sorry, the, and we also have the Miral Adamantium tier where you get the chance to watch the, uh, the recordings of these episodes live and, uh, get them early. If we're doing them any degree of early today, we happen to be releasing same day. So that's, that's pretty fun for me, the editor. But, uh, uh, uh, now we're having lots of fun and, uh, come join us.
1:11:36 Come join the conversation. Anything more to say about that Knut. Yeah, just one thing I thought of. Uh, we are posting these on highlighter. The every chapter is posted on highlighter for free every week, so you can go to highlighter, uh, and highlight stuff and, uh, uh, share it on, uh, over noster and, and use all the perks of highlighter. So I hope that, that, that becomes a thing too. So highlight your favorite quote. Yes. And, and if you have comments or questions after the fact here, we'll address them in the, the next episodes. Uh, definitely we, we will see them if you're in the Miro Atium group and you ping us there, but we'll, we'll try to stay on top of any comments on Noster or Twitter or, or wherever.
1:12:19 So. I think, uh, I think the, the last thing is just to, to mention that, uh, uh, thank you again to Plan B Network for really enabling this, this series enabling us to release these, uh, the chapters and the episodes for free for everyone. And, uh, it's, it's great to be partnering with them. They're, they're really trailblazing in terms of Bitcoin education and, and this initiative is just a, a perfect fit. We were on a spaces with, with Zuko just, uh, just the other day here. And, uh, uh, I think I, I, I just, I just see nothing but, but positives from, from this collaboration and, and they're doing great things. So go to Plan B Network, uh, and you can check out some other great Bitcoin education resources and, and on their YouTube channel.
1:13:04 There's also gonna be condensed versions of these episodes, so when we go on these really long tangents, we'll, we'll maybe cut those out a little bit so it's a little more direct and accessible for, for people who just want the, the information. So really excited about this partnership. totally echo, echo what Luke said about plan B. It's a, it's a great, uh, uh, a great initiative and there will be plenty more to come there, uh, uh, going into the future. Looking forward to all of it. Absolutely. And, and finally, we, we also, uh, are, are happy to be, uh, also supported by Bit Box. Big, big shout out to them. And, and thank you for, for continuing to support these initiatives here. They're, they're also a sponsor of our, our main show.
1:13:45 They've, they've really been a great partner. They're our favorite hardware wallet. It's easy to use and they're right on top of the, the latest in, in bitcoin security here. So go to Bit box.swiss/infiniti, check out the Bit Box zero two Bitcoin only edition. And yeah, if you need a new hardware wallet for yourself or, or you know, a, a new Coiner who, who needs a hardware wallet, go to Bit Box and, uh, they'll have what you need. So, uh, thanks again to Bit Box. Alright, Knut, this has been an awesome episode. Uh, I really enjoyed this one. Financial atheism. Looking forward to the release and we'll be tackling another episode in a week. This Yes, next week's episode is the About the Gullible Collective.
1:14:28 See you all then. Take care. has been the Bitcoin Infinity Academy. Thank you for listening.
Fountain
YouTube
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
RSS Feed