Feb. 23, 2026

BIP-110 and the Fight for Bitcoin's Future with Hodlonaut | Bitcoin Infinity Show #191

BIP-110 and the Fight for Bitcoin's Future with Hodlonaut | Bitcoin Infinity Show #191
BIP-110 and the Fight for Bitcoin's Future with Hodlonaut | Bitcoin Infinity Show #191
The Bitcoin Infinity Show
BIP-110 and the Fight for Bitcoin's Future with Hodlonaut | Bitcoin Infinity Show #191

Hodlonaut joins the Bitcoin Infinity Show to talk about his controversial decision to first support and then withdraw support for BIP-110, the proposed soft fork targeting spam and data abuse on Bitcoin. The conversation covers Bitcoin Core's uncapping of OP_RETURN, the "wokification" of Core development, lessons from the block size wars, and whether BIP-110 is the right hill for plebs to die on in defending Bitcoin as money. Knut and Hodlonaut go through BIP 110's specific restrictions point by point while debating governance, urgency, and the principled case for keeping Bitcoin simple and resistant to change.

Connect with Hodlonaut:

https://x.com/hodlonaut

Connect with Us:

https://www.bitcoininfinityshow.com/

https://bitcoininfinitystore.com

https://primal.net/infinity

https://primal.net/knut

https://primal.net/luke

https://twitter.com/BtcInfinityShow

https://twitter.com/knutsvanholm

https://twitter.com/lukedewolf

Join the Bitcoin Infinity Academy at our Geyser page: https://geyser.fund/project/infinity

The Freedom Footprint Show is a Bitcoin podcast hosted by Knut Svanholm and Luke de Wolf.

In each episode, we explore everything from deep philosophy to practical tools to emit freedom dioxide to expand your freedom footprint!

00:00 - Welcome Mr. Cat

01:20 - Apology for Premature BIP110 Support

04:44 - Core’s Dangerous Pivot

06:25 - Doubts About BIP110 Governance

08:10 - Is BIP110 The Right Hill to Die On?

09:10 - Clarifying Mr. Cat's Stance on BIP110

13:59 - Supporting BIP110: F*ck the Assholes

20:19 - The Block Size Wars: An Attempted Takeover?

30:39 - Limiting Up Return as Consensus Rule

31:50 - Does It Make Bitcoin Better Money?

38:01 - Resisting Change in Bitcoin

41:45 - What Gives Us Pause About BIP-110?

01:05:30 - Arrogance and Recklessness

01:44:53 - What It Would Take

0:00 Mr. Cat, a dear, warm, super warm welcome back to the Bitcoin Infinity Show. Nice to have you here again. Thank you, Knut. Yes, you've stirred the pot a bit in the Bitcoin space like the last couple of days by first showing support for BIP110 and then withdrawing that support. So that has got a lot of attention from both sides. And I know that a lot of people are very curious about this conversation and where this will lead and what your rationale was for, first for supporting and then for withdrawing your support. So we'll look into that.

0:40 Where do you want to start this? Like, where do we want this conversation? I think, you know, the backstory that we are sitting here on the podcast now is that the two of us had a long talk yesterday on the phone. And, and we, or at least I realized that, you know, I think, I mean, after that call, I watched the mechanics latest video and I think his approach, you know, of being humble and just pretty brutally honest, that really resonated with me. And I think it's super important. I'm going to like, just explain because I consider it, uh, I mean, I apologized on X and there is a reason I apologized on X of course.

1:20 And the reason is that I think my support for BIP110 was premature. It was emotional. And I should have taken more time to reflect and evaluate and learn more basically. And the reason this happened was that I have been basically disconnected fully from the Bitcoin space for a year, the whole of 2025. After this stupid five years of fighting Craig Wright came to an end, I really kind of had the strong urge to take some time off, to put it that way. I had enough of Bitcoin conversations for a while.

2:02 I just needed to focus on other things. And I have been focusing on stuff here in Norway. I started a podcast in Norway. I'm basically a public, I'm not a public person, but I didn't like do any efforts to hide my name or identity here in Norway. The reason for that again is, I mean, I got fully doxxed. Anyone who wants to find out who I am can easily do it after Craig and CoinGeek made sure of that. So when I came back after, you know, being out of the Bitcoin bubble for a year, a lot had happened as we all know. And the main thing being this decision of Bitcoin Core to merge Core version 30 with the uncapping of OP return.

2:51 So when I came back, I was kind of like mind blown to learn how this happened, like in which way it happened, how arrogantly Core did it, despite obvious controversy. I had so many red flags popping up. I got emotional and when I saw BIP-100, learned about BIP-110, it was like, it seemed like the type of response to what I consider total lack of principles from core and irresponsibility. So it was like very knee jerk and like emotional reaction for me to just almost blindly support it.

3:34 But as I said, I came into this with like, not the most solid understanding of the whole dynamic. So what I saw as the main flags, red flags from core was, you know, the technical hand waving, which I got tons of when I started just asking questions about this. I didn't like the dismissive attitude. The whole pleb slop narrative, you know that any pleb that is in Bitcoin for very principled reasons shall just be hand waved away as a ridiculous spouter of slop. That to me is a red flag in itself.

4:15 I saw who supported uncapping up return. I saw the people who like cheered that specific change on. Obviously the narrative of uncapping up return never made sense to me. It still doesn't. They call it harm reduction, but you know, to standardize a new avenue of spamming and grifting on Bitcoin, I'm just not on board with it. And I think it's a dangerous pivot from trying to keep Bitcoin as money and the mission of separating money and state.

4:56 So I jumped into supporting the BIP110. I always did say I was not sure this was the best solution, but I always also said that I feel something has to be done to counter this seeming uncontrolled slide of principles that Core is exhibiting, in my opinion. So I kept repeating this and I kept saying that I supported BIP110, but there were things that were lingering in my mind as doubts and still is, which is why I withdrew my support.

5:36 I feel like this urgency premise that we have to do something now, it has to be done now else it's over. Bitcoin is over. This urgency thing, that's a red flag for me. I think the whole CSAM thing, I'm actually not sure about that. I think it's crazy that we have opened up a return to basically paste in CSAM if someone would be crazy enough to do that. And I do see a difference of CSAM appearing on the Bitcoin blockchain as a result of a standardized way of doing it instead of through some segvit taproot hack with the witness discount i see a difference there if if nothing else it's a huge principle difference i had and still maybe have a little bit of a problem with edge cases where coins could theoretically become unspendable if you have some crazy multi-sig with time locks for example i had and still have some issues with understanding the governance part of the BIP110 side.

6:46 For example, I'll be blunt and say it like, is Luke fit to be a leader of basically, you know, a full-on pivot of the governance side of Bitcoin? I respect Luke deeply, and I think he lives and bleeds Bitcoin. I think his intentions are as honorable as they get. But some of his rhetoric, I think, is wild. And it's a little bit hard to see that as being the official voice of Bitcoin governance in some ways. But I think it's even wilder to have Gloria Hsiao be the official voice of Bitcoin governance, just to make that clear.

7:32 So I think it kind of boils down to a question, or it boils down to different things, but should we, like, you can do nothing or I can do something, but the something can be doing harm. And also doing nothing right now with the 110 is not the same as never doing anything. So is this our best shot? Is it solid enough? good enough for us to use as the last stand, you know, the hill we die on or not? Because I'm willing to die on a hill to resist what Corey is doing. That's for sure. I'm just not sure if BIP110 is the hill. But I do feel, you know, people saying, shall we just sit around talking forever? And that's something I definitely don't want to do. I think that's really bad.

8:32 yeah if make sure the hill you choose to die on has a sufficiently uh cozy valley to live in beneath it yeah would that be a fair so so i would it be a fair um assessment of your position that uh you are not against uh bip 110 you've just withdrawn your official support so you're right now in the face of studying the proposal more properly before stating your official position. Would that be? Yeah. Because I saw some backlash in a couple of forums where they called it flip flopping and that you are now like, some people see you as an enemy now, whether I tried to calm that down by saying like, no, that's tribalism. If a guy has doubts, then like, just give him time.

9:32 and we'll see what happens. It was just, you know, back to the, it was just so retarded to, in hindsight retarded, because I was honest and it wasn't like I was aware that I was maybe premature in my support. I think maybe some of it is PTSD from fighting scammers in Bitcoin a lot that I kind of jumped the gun a little bit. But it just felt irresponsible for me to, you know, I changed the whole HODLonaut avatar with the BIP110 patch and all of that stuff. And that felt suddenly, I had my doubts, but still the principal side of it trumped everything else.

10:18 And just a short recap of the Giacomo talk, and I kind of feel bad for even tagging him because Because it's so unfair that people are attacking Giacomo like he somehow tried to convert me to leave BitP110. He never, with one sentence, tried to make me do anything. I mean, he's a friend. I've known him for a long time. I think he's one of the most honest, solid people in Bitcoin. I never ever caught him in any type of manipulation or dishonesty. And that means a lot to me because I've been here for a while now.

10:59 So of course, his opinion gave me more doubt when his opinion is that for several reasons he does not support BIP-110 as of yet. And it came off, you know, understandably very retarded and weirdly if it was understood like, yeah, no, the miners don't support it. So then it's impossible. It was more like, I think of it like, I don't think miners are going to help this happen. I think maybe in the end, they could be forced to just go along with it. But I don't think it's going to be any type of slow trickle where we have 5% miner support, we have 10% miner. It's going to be almost like like a moment where it flips if it flips. And there was like something about being reality oriented on how uninterested the miners are in this, which it was that even that was kind of like flawed thinking, but that along with his opinion of the urgency part being overstated.

12:04 And I do feel that a little bit having been in the block size wars and listened to Roger for years when with his amazing children are dying messaging you know we have to like uh we have to increase the block size for children are dying for fuck's sake but yeah so so there are there are like in some it just gave me more pause and doubt than i could have and still have this bip 110 support on X. But I feel ashamed of it. I mean, I think it's stupid. I think I wasted my credibility.

12:49 I don't think that. You wasted some cred points maybe, but not all of them. But just to be clear, I do take a lot of self-criticism for it. And now I just want to, you know, make damn sure that I don't take any hard stance on this until I have really, really deeply evaluated it. And also, it's not like I think that my, and maybe that was my mistake, that more people than I, I had been away for a long time, that more people cared about what I wrote than I was aware, which made my support being, it was harder or it was more impossible to stay in support when I had so much doubt all of a sudden.

13:32 Yeah, and I mean, at the end of the day, the day that people stop having self-criticism and just cling on to the when tribalism wins then we don have any Bitcoin anymore Getting Bitcoiners to get along is a bit like herding cats but that a good thing I'm still supporting BIP-110, by the way, officially. And I think I can sum up the reasons why by paraphrasing the great speech in Team America World Police, It's a Matt and Trey's puppet movie from 2006 or something, I believe.

14:23 I remember it well. Yeah, so the thing is, I'm going to self-censor here a bit. See, there are three kinds of people. Ds, Ps, and A-holes, right? That's what it is. Maybe I don't need to self-censor. Like dicks, pusses? Dicks, pusses, and assholes, yes. There are three kinds of people, dicks, pusses, and assholes. I think we're far enough into the YouTube video to not get like immediately banned there. Pussies think everyone can get along and dicks just want to fuck all the time without thinking it through. But then you got your assholes and all the assholes wants to do is shit all over everything. So pussies may get mad at dicks once in a while because pussies get fucked by dicks.

15:08 But dicks also fuck assholes. And if they didn't fuck the assholes, you know what you get? you get your dick and your pussy all covered in shit and here comes the paraphrasing we the plebs are the dicks we are the reckless arrogant stupid dicks we are reckless arrogant stupid dicks and the developers are pussies and the spammers are assholes pussies don't like dicks because pussies get fucked by dicks uh meaning us plebs but dicks also fuck assholes meaning the spammers assholes just want to shit over everything pussies may think they can deal with assholes in their way but the only thing that can fuck an asshole is a dick with some balls the problem with dicks is that they sometimes they fuck too much or fuck when it isn't appropriate and it takes a pussy to show them that but sometimes pussies get so full of shit that they become assholes themselves because pussies are only an inch away from an asshole oh my god uh it's brilliant actually There's so much wisdom. I don't know much in this crazy, crazy world, but I do know that if you don't let us fuck these assholes, we're going to have our dicks and our pussies all covered in shit. And I think that's the essence of this entire debate. We may be stupid and this may all be plebslop, but I do plebslop for a living and I'm not going to stop doing that.

16:32 I think fucking the assholes is more important here than pleasing the pussies. So that's why I'm taking the official stance. I'm wholeheartedly behind, you know, what you said there. So if that analogy was the whole thing, we would be, you know, supporting, both of us would be supporting it wholeheartedly. Yeah. So a bit of history here, I think, is appropriate to get this going. to we need to lay out first where we're coming from we've been friends for a very long time behind you i think you have a picture of our first like true collaboration which is the second edition of the citadel 21 magazine the correct yeah which you're reviving by the way we can get into that later or you might be reviving it uh we're both on that cover it's made by uh cypherpunk now a great Bitcoin artist. Martin Fisher. Yeah. And he made but 21 of those. I know Giacomo has one behind him when he does the interviews and so does Katie the Russian who is also on there. So does Mr. HODL I think if he didn't refuse to receive it because all of the people who are on that poster got one of them. Yeah. And it's beautiful. And yeah, right now, Now, I don't have it here in Spain.

17:55 It's still back in Sweden, but it's a beautiful, beautiful poster. And I aim to put it up behind me someday. Shout out to Martin Fisher. I have more of his art on my walls. And I think he's one of the best artists in Bitcoin history. Absolutely. When is that from, by the way, that issue? Probably 22. 22. so it's not that old I mean we go back earlier than that I know that it could be 21 as well yeah because I remember in Riga 2019 there were cutouts of the the Hodlunoth helmet and like posters saying where's Mr. Cat and everyone was looking for you and couldn't find you yeah that was so cool of the Honey Badger guys to support me like that yeah and that was Your first claim to fame had nothing to do with the katana expert, Dr. Craig Wright, but it was actually the lightning torch.

18:59 So after the block size wars, when the lightning was... It was May 2020, Knut, so it was earlier than I said. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So, yeah, this is way back. But before that, you started the lightning torch, which was basically showing the world that the lightning network actually worked. by increasing by one sat and sending a torch in form of... Yeah, it was like 10,000 sat increase per jump. All right. So, and you did that twice. I think I was in the second one, but not in the first one. Yeah, we tried to do a replay in the year after in 2020. It got kind of, it went really well until some guy misunderstood completely and just sent it.

19:46 I think he sent it to Jack without even asking Jack if he wanted it, and it just stranded there. Yeah, funny experiment, though. And before that, if we do a TLDR on the block size wars, because everyone has a different memory of it, and I'd like to pick your brain on what you remember. I know that the book, The Block Size Wars, I don't think that gives a... It tries to be neutral, but I don't think the wars were neutral. I think it was an attempt at a hostile takeover rather than just two sides arguing for different arguments. I think there were vested interests in increasing the block size in order to centralize Bitcoin and take it over.

20:27 And I think the immune response was against exactly that. I think we can confirm that suspicion or this claim just by remembering what Roger did a little later. He teamed up with Craig Wright. I think you don't need to know much more about Roger's character and intentions than that. No, and he also controlled Bitcoin.com, which listed Bitcoin Cash as the real Bitcoin. And I don't know if Roger actually invented Bitcoin Cash. I think he sort of, there were probably other people involved.

21:07 But one thing to know here is that the first attempt at increasing the block size was Gavin and Mike Hearn with Bitcoin XT, right? So they wanted... Was XT before Classic or were they like parallel? I don't even remember. I think XT was the first one. And so what happened was Satoshi pulled out and gave the keys to the repository to Gavin, effectively making Gavin sort of the official spokesperson for Bitcoin. And I suspect that Gavin kind of liked that. And also he got advisory roles in all the surrounding companies and stuff. And he may or may not have had the, like, I'm speculating here and I don't want to, you know, be too conspiracy and bash people too much.

21:54 but having said that there was clearly was an incentive for him to be on that side if not for anything else then to just increase his own influence of the project and he also he fell for the whole Craig Wright thing Craig Wright bamboozled Gavin later and Gavin said that this is Satoshi that's also part of the story he didn't only fool for it he allowed Craig to parade him around as the crown witness of his Satoshi-ness. I sat in the court in 2022 in Oslo listening to Craig's lawyers again and again read Gavin's old words about how Craig was Satoshi and Gavin just sat and looked at it and didn't come forward at all.

22:45 No, and have we heard anything from Gavin since? Has there been any official statement? Has he apologized or something? I don't remember. I don't think so. So that's interesting. So what happened basically was that there was a cabal of some of the most profitable companies in Bitcoin at the time. Some of the bigger exchanges, some of the biggest miners came together. And what was it called? BitPay, the payment processor, which Jeff Garcik was an advisor to, by the way. And so the big blockers basically came together in a meeting in New York where they decided that, okay, we'll implement this Segwist soft fork that everyone wants, but we'll also at the same time hard fork or a couple of months after we'll hard fork and increase the block size to two megabytes, the base block size.

23:41 Yeah, this was called Segwist 2x, right? Yes. And then the soft fork happened smoothly because everyone was signaling that they were for it. And then this is a very much a TLDR. There is like BIP 91 and 141 and 148, like a bunch of stuff happening that we don't need to go into that much detail. But what basically happened was that the users said no to the hard fork, which was then canceled because the miners were afraid of splitting the chain. So they canceled the 2x part of the thing because people were signaling against it.

24:22 And around the time, there's also then the Bitcoin Cash hard fork happens, right? They decide that at a certain block height, they're going to split the chain into two, effectively making the 21 million, 42 million. So like a crossover between a Christmas present and a train crash. And then a future market forms where you can sort of stake your bets on which of the chains are going to win. And I think this futures market is a big deal in what's actually going to happen in scenarios like this. But now you're talking about the 2X chain or the SegWit chain, right?

25:05 Yeah, exactly. Because the Bcash chain, since it's hard forked, that ran its course. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So this is pretty, yeah, I'm mixing things up here. But of course, the futures market is for will there be a 2X chain or not? And there's clearly a signal that there wouldn't be one. And this played a big role in why the miners capitulated, I think. And a lot of that had to do with this user-activated software. Also to be remembered, Yihan Wu and Bitmain had something called ASIC Boost, which is, it's not proven that they actually ever used it, but it was a way for their miners to mine more efficiently than competing miners.

25:52 It was like a small bug in the hashing algorithm or in SHA-256, I think, that you could hash like 10% faster or something with this implementation. And SegWit would prevent that. So it would prevent the head start that Bitmain had. That made Bitmain dig in pretty hard against it. Yeah. So, and what we have now is a similar situation, but the big difference is that this time around, core is not on the same side as the intolerant minority of plebs. Because we had an intolerant minority of plebs. That's what triggered the block size wars.

26:34 That thing too, like that prevented that hard fork from happening. So right now we're in the stages of having a, there's a proposed soft fork. We don't know if it will lead to a hard fork, but that's one of the concerns is that it might lead to a hard fork and nobody sort of wants that. Yeah, I think the dynamics are rather different, even though, I mean, I agree with what you say, but back then it was like, I mean, from my perspective, it was like everyone pretty much in Bitcoin or the huge majority viewed the big block thing as an attack on the status quo. And now it's kind of like turned around a little bit because I'm probably entrenched by the fact that core has always been on the side of and seen as good actors and, you know, solid Bitcoiners.

27:23 And right now it's kind of different. It's like, it's easy for the pro V30 people to portray the big 110 people as, you know, attacking the status quo, so to say, or like doing one thing to do reckless things And I think that a that an interesting debate on its own like because I seen quite a few people while I supported BIP110 trying to like put me like oh you basically a BSV now or like which is insane to me. So which one of these sides can credibly claim that the other side reminds most of the big blockers back then? Yeah, and that's a super interesting discussion because the first change, the controversial change that people were opposed to was the op return policy increase, which is not a consensus change, but still a change to a policy that most of the, or at least 20% of the plebs didn't agree to.

28:31 I mean, it's a standardization, right? Yeah. Yeah, so it is signaling that these things are okay now. Go and do them here. Which is a very, very, it's subtle, but it is a change from the attitude in Bitcoin back in 2017, I think. Yes, I agree. So, and I hope I'm not misrepresenting any stance here, but I think the argument from Core is that this, In the end, this results in something less harmful than if we kept things the way they were.

29:11 And on the other side, you have, we don't care if it's less harmful or not. We want to fight these things completely, and we don't want them here. We want to kick them out, while the core side is saying that it's futile, and spam can always be crammed in in other different ways. And therein lies the core of the conflict, pardon the pun. Yeah. And the more like, that's the one thing that the more I reflect on it and think about it, and the more I hear the rationale or the attempted rationale, it just makes less and less sense to me. And just like the first principle of, oh, it's possible to abuse the Bitcoin blockchain with this Segwit taproot hack and the witness discount to cram bullshit in there in very complex ways that you basically need third party applications to be able to view them.

30:02 Let's just uncap up return and make it possible. Let's open a huge new door and standardize that. The signal and the philosophical impact of that from the reference implementation is unacceptable to me. Yeah, so the question then becomes, what shall we do about it and when? And the proposal is BIP110. Yeah, and I love the concept of limiting up return as a consensus rule. Yeah, so yeah, I love that too, like because all of a sudden it's consensus and you don't have this, You're forcing the network to make a decision, basically.

30:50 So maybe we should go through the points of the fork, or maybe a bit of other preamble here. I think another thing here, and why the BIP is controversial, is that some fringe use cases that has to do with, what's it called, Tapscript and some time block functions, Miniscript. Yeah, some really, really advanced features of Bitcoin. Like you have this, I met a lot of developer types in Bitcoin that have this vision of if we can make it more complex and if we can allow it to be more programmable, we get all these nice features.

31:31 And my approach has always been before deciding your opinion on anything in this, ask yourself, does this make Bitcoin better money? And to be better money is very simple. You have the six or seven properties of money, and you have money solves two problems. It's the mutual coincidence of need problem, which allows money to be better than barter. And then there's economic calculation. It allows you to do economic calculation, And the more fixed the supply, the more predictable the schedule, the more predictable and stable everything is, the better it functions at that, basically, which is why you shouldn't fuck with it.

32:14 So fucking with it, there's always a cost to fucking with the rules because it may fuck up an incentive here or there, thereby making it less good as money because it's now less predictable. And it doesn't matter if you have a smart contract feature in which you can time lock one out of seven signing participants. That is always inferior to me. To me, that's always inferior to just, I hate the word ossifying, but to just leave Bitcoin alone and don't fiddle around with it. There's a fuck around and find out part to doing so. I always loved the term ossify, but it's probably because I'm a ridiculously stupid plebslopspouter.

33:01 I don't think Bitcoin can ossify because at the end of the day is people voluntarily choosing software. But the concept being, you know, that fuck all this innovation. We have already now something that is completely disruptive to a lot of the worst shit going on in the world because of the money system. Why should we risk it? And I just want to put something in there that I thought about when you talked now, like the arguments. One thing that triggers me and that is a red flag for me is bad faith arguments and arguments that are basically false or exaggerated or designed to create FUD.

33:46 And I want to throw in one argument that I've seen, and that's been picked up by a lot of people. It's basically that BIP-110 breaks multisig. And suddenly you have, I mean, so many Bitcoiners secure their coins with different multisig solutions, usually two out of three. And when you saw this suspicion or argument that BIP-110 is a threat to your cold storage if you run a regular multisig, that's a very bad faith argument to me because it doesn't. similarly to the argument on the other side on the pro BIP 110 side that someone is is claiming that Bitcoin is 100% dead if we don't do something now it's urgent and it has to happen now but that doesn't I mean I'm just throwing this out there because I think that's two examples of things that I personally don't uh find any truth in were you pro taproot yeah but it was based uh on uh trusting other people yeah same here based on and i think that was one of the really cool things about mechanics last video that he kind of owned up to having been to that he took self-criticism for some of the mechanics and stuff that happened in the block size war. And I think honesty, also looking back, is really important that we have to be

35:19 honest about things. Yeah. The way I see, we won one battle. So we proved that Bitcoin can be like this, decentralized enough to withstand attacks. We didn't prove that it would always be, and we didn't prove that that was always going to be the case. We just proved that we had the ability to resist a hostile takeover and taproot uh i was for it too because i've been convinced by some technical arguments about coin joins and and making making basically making transactions more private and more anonymous because of the like same lengthness of but uh in hindsight i think it came with side effects that were definitely not worth it and i'm with jimmy song's stance on this says that in hindsight, we probably should have been a bit more self-critical.

36:11 And that adds credibility and weight to the ossification argument, or call it not ossification, but like the resistance to big changes or the resistance to this innovation narrative. Yeah, because when that is actually the case, when Bitcoin is actually resistant to change, sufficiently resistant to change. Theoretically, at least, that means that Bitcoin can only change for the better, which is like the opposite of a democracy. But it means that if we have such overwhelming consensus that we will change it, then everyone thought it was a good idea, meaning that we can define what good is by that metric alone. Yeah. After we won the block size war, I think I could go back and find tons of tweets about this from hudlonot that you know let's not risk this again guys let's like let's let's stay sober now and not do crazy shit anymore now we have what we have what we need let's not get crazy and the analogy would be if i lived with my family in some almost paradise place i almost said island but i think you can't use the word island positively anymore uh but at least not when you children on it. Anyways, if I had a nice setup with my life and with the things that really mattered to me, no way in hell would I start risking that for like small potential increments of even more happiness, you know? Yeah, no, no, no. When the alternative outcome can be that

37:45 a dragon comes flying in and burns down my family and everything. That's just like very simple logic to me. Yeah, exactly. And I think that kind of brings us into this because it's a weird situation. It's like, I have this position that I don't want Bitcoin to change. And then I'm seeing core pushing change in a direction I hate. And then there is no solution to just sit still and continue need to let that happen because that's like slow motion dragon flying into torch everything I love. Yeah. But also I don't want to risk releasing another dragon that flies way faster and like the resistance leading to even faster destruction. And also it's a very difficult situation right now, I think. Yeah, I totally agree. It's hard to know what the proper stance is. And our reputation are on the line after after this is has played out regardless of which side that wins we're gonna our tweets are gonna haunt us that's always the case i don't care about outcome um i mean i care about if my intention was honest and i can't do anything more than contributing my most honest words and actions and if they were wrong so be it you know here's here's another interesting uh conversation I had with Jimmy Song about being principled versus being utilitarian.

39:17 And I think the way I see it, the lower your time preference, the more utilitarian your principles become. So being principled is utilitarian, but only if you have an extremely low time preference. If you can extrapolate your time preference into forever, then a principled approach to everything is the correct one. Whereas utilitarianism, like making your decisions not because you believe in them from first principles, but because of an outcome you find more or less likely, is sort of a high-time preference thing. And here's to me where this becomes so fucking tricky in Bitcoin, because the utility of signaling pro this fork and everything is that it might scare off spammers. And it's seemingly so because now fees are low and there isn't as much spam as there was because I think that some of these people are getting cold feet. And that's the same thing with also, you know, developers who want to do really advanced features in wallets.

40:22 I mean, the more fringe you become in Bitcoin and the more fringe things you do, the more your coins are at risk. And that was always the case. If you decide to make a transaction that you know that a part of the community does not approve of, or we don't like that transaction, we are tolerating it, but we don't approve of it, like an NFT on Bitcoin, for instance, of a stupid dick pic or whatever, monkey JPEG, then that is a riskier transaction. But because at some point, there's the risk that that feature will be soft forked away. Or by some consensus rule change, those coins are at risk.

41:06 And I think what BIP110 does and what this proposed cat thing that is probably not going anywhere, but just the threat of that thing happening and doing this whack-a-mole thing, I think that scared off some spammers. Some of them are signaling that we don't care what you do, we're always going to find new ways. but I don't really buy that. It's a, I mean, it's, it's decentralized threat against centralization. It and and and grifters they always would want more centralization Should should should we try to run through what we consider what is against BIP or what gives us pause and what gives us the desire to die on the hill?

41:52 Yes, I have the website up here, BIP-110.org and we can just go through the entire thing and see how much of it we understand to begin with. And then... I'm up for that, but I was thinking more like the, not only, you know, the actual changes, but like the whole, the broader situation of it and how we interpret it. What is like, what is the reason that you are on the hill? And what is the reason, what, if any reasons, do you see as against it? Well, the Dick's Pussies and Assholes position is my, that's my stance.

42:33 That's the hill I'm dying on. But I think Mechanic is right in saying that this doesn't require that much, much more than 10% for miners to just go on mining on this chain because they have basically nothing to lose from doing so. Miners are not making that much from putting spam on the chain as people think. But then, like, I think, you know, just to look at the percent is kind of, I mean, there are, we have to be honest and say that no, there are difference between nodes. You have like super connected, crazy big economic nodes and you have a pleb number 1438 that runs a node at home and they are different.

43:20 And I think definitely we will need some of these economic nodes to support it or we will need, BIP-110 will need. Slightly different opinion there. I think that right now the node count signaling for BIP-110 is around 7.5%, which is very close to 10, which is the, paraphrasing here, what I think is mechanics opinion is that that's around how much we need because then we will just have to fold. Because we don't know whether these nodes signaling, and correct me if I'm wrong here, but I think I got this right, that there is no way to actually know whether a node signaling for this is an actual heavyweight economic node or not.

44:07 You can only see that it's signaling for it or not. So you don't know how much significance that node has when push comes to show. in September. And so right now, we have basically no miners signaling for this yet. Then again, they have up until September to start signaling for it. And if there's a 55% threshold of miners before that, then the software will just happen. And if there's not consensus, all of the users that are willing to die on this hill will just reject any block that doesn't follow the tighter rules.

44:51 So the incentive for the miner, and sure, go comment and stuff, brush your teeth first, but tell me why I'm an idiot and stuff and why Hodl or not is an idiot in the comments, of course. But the theory is that there's no reason for them to not follow that chain because the rules are tighter. so every block that is compliant with BIP110 is also compliant with the loser rules. You understand where I'm going with this? And for the miner, there is a risk of mining the blocks with the bigger op returns and stuff because that has a risk of being rejected by the network.

45:35 So why would they take that risk when there's not that much reward in it? And for that to happen, the estimate is that we need around 10% support. Somewhat by that. I mean, the thing is, even with the block size wars, there are so many interpretations of what actually happened. And it's very hard in a decentralized system to have any kind of objective view of what was actually going on. So I think it's very hard to assess the probability of this and that happening. And I know a lot of big names in Bitcoin have very different opinions on it. I don't agree with Tone Vase triangle thingy.

46:16 I think that's misguided. I stopped listening to Tone Vase a long time ago. I don't because there is to me that's he is noise in my opinion. Yeah, I did a one of his Knotts versus Core series. like him and Jimmy interviewed me in San Salvador. And now they've done the last one, I think. Or Tone did one with Vortex after he did one with just Jimmy. But the one with Jimmy is very interesting. I'd recommend that one, even though, yeah, they are time-consuming to listen to these things.

46:56 But yeah, as I said, it's hard to get a neutral position. What I don't like sometimes in the knots camp is this tribalism or this, if you're not for us, you're against us kind of attitude. I don't think that helps. I think that sort of, I understand where they're coming from. And a lot of them are passionate and fighting for Bitcoin's soul. We are too. It's just that, like, I think there's a point to diplomacy for sure. yeah well i fully understand it and i think it comes from you know it comes from a place where you really want to defend something and i got my fair share of shit last uh 24 hours or so uh 48 hours but i mean i'm taking i'm taking it on the chin because i kind of think i deserved it a little bit and uh for the flip-flopping and like my lack of wisdom in jumping to something but But I do understand it and I do understand the disappointment when you think this is a really, really important fight.

48:04 If you think someone like, or if you even suspect that someone has, and that's kind of the problem here that it's making the jump to thinking someone is compromised happens a little bit too fast for some people, I think, which is unfortunate, but it's also understandable, in the world we live in today with all the fucking crazy shit that is coming out, you know? So, do you want me to just quickly go through my... Yeah, just one more point on the diplomacy thing before I forget it, ADD brain. But that is this, I think you can draw a line between two extremes, like the extreme cypherpunk ethos bitcoiner to uh and on the opposite side of there you have david bailey which think a bitcoiner who thinks adoption is is everything and it doesn't matter who the fuck you you steamroll over uh in the way to adoption i mean i think if david bailey could earn money on the adoption going down he would be against yeah yeah so maybe yeah yeah absolutely he's a bad example but say someone who just wants bitcoin to be adopted by as many people as possible by all means necessary i think that extreme adoption thing is counterproductive because if if someone tries shit coins for one cycle it will take them another decade before they can figure out the difference between

49:34 bitcoin and shit coins and therefore like the these confusing conferences and and and articles written about that. They're not adding to real adoption. I mean, paper Bitcoin is not Bitcoin. More ETFs adopting Bitcoin is not really more adoption of Bitcoin. It's more adoption of paper Bitcoin. Maybe it's even an adoption. Yeah, but at the same time, if you have too far on the other side of the extreme, that it's just this fringe, hate everyone else in society type of super cypherpunk ethos person, Then you get no adoption and we can play around. And that doesn't work either if we're going to take on the central banks at some point.

50:20 So I think there's a balance to be struck there. And it's very hard to know where the appropriate stance is and where you... Yeah, for sure. So we can only do our best in trying to navigate this. And I mean, that's what I've been doing. I just made the mistake of being premature. It turned out I didn't think I was premature, but now I'm going to like make damn sure that I don't take any firm side unless or until I am sure of it. Because as I tried to get across, it's not like I look at BIP-110 as anything resembling, you know, bad fate or attack or I applaud it. And I applaud, you know, anyone who wants to fight for Bitcoin. You were just in support prematurely in full support of it. All right. Correct. So yeah, let's go through it. Yeah. And it's not a long list or anything like that. And maybe it's not even exhaustive for what I'm thinking, but it's what I just jotted down before we got on this call.

51:34 And if I first do the four, the pro BIP-110 things, on top, I just wrote principles in big letters because that's like the real big deal for me. Because I really believe that if you start compromising on principles with technical hand waving and huge word salads and saying everyone who doesn't understand this is a non-technical idiot, that's like a surefire way that Bitcoin is going to be Ethereum. and worse down the road. So that is like 100% something that made me want to support BIP110. Bitcoin is money and spam is not money. I love the thought of rugging these spammers. I'm so fucking tired of all these lying grifters who misrepresent things and try to basically harm Bitcoin to personally enrich themselves. The fact that's throughout like the flags around the whole Citria launch and the timing and all of that, you know, how many red flags?

52:45 It's so bad. Yeah. And all the worst people are pro this thing. And you know, who runs Bitcoin? Obviously, if Bitcoin is run by ivory tower developers and miners, then Bitcoin is already walking dead thing. Node runners have to count here. That's for sure. I've seen bad faith arguments from the anti-Bip 110 side that alone makes me sympathetic to the Bip 110 side. For example, this like funding around loss of funds, which is a non-factor as far as I now know for basically everyone.

53:31 If you're not like some mad professor that made an insane multi-sig, custom multi-sig setup with time locks and God knows what else. So basically only if you're Luke Dasher, you're at risk. Maybe Luke Dasher is taking an even bigger one for the team by risking his funds here. Technical hand waving, like just observing the walkification of core. and I'm saying it out loud, the Voke-ification of core. Like what the fuck is when woke politics and DEI enters the, the height, the pinnacle of Bitcoin development, what the fuck?

54:11 Yeah. This is the pussies and dick's pussies and assholes argument all over again. And then the against BIP-110. I don't like this, this premise that this has to happen now or never and Bitcoin is The moment, for example, a CSAM picture lands on the blockchain, I don't think it's that clear cut at all. It's disgusting and fucked up, but it's not that clear cut. Yeah, I agree with that. Some justification for that position is that I do not believe judges to be rational people when it comes to technicalities in computer thingies.

54:54 No, exactly. So they could already find some premise. They're not going to care if Bitcoin officially supports this or not. And like, I don't buy that specific argument. No, it's just a disgusting thing to support it and standardize it. Yeah, yeah. I don't think arbitrary data has a place in Bitcoin. I'm very, like, I don't know if I want op return to exist at all. Because I don't know why you would need to put other data into Bitcoin at all. Like, I think Pierre Ocard was pro that position too, like just remove the entire thing. just remove it yeah it was put there in the first place it's kind of like the the the big increase because it was like okay you want to do at least do it here it's always been at least do it here because it's less harmful yeah you want to scam a little bit okay you can scam a little bit here yeah but no no i mean yeah to continue then yeah sure also yeah so and i think the spam urgency is in the same boat. I did sync up a node, a bit 110 node like five days ago, and it took less than 30 hours on a five-year-old laptop. It had an SSD, that's crucial here, and it had 16 gigabytes of RAM. But as of now, the spam topic, it's not like in one or two or three years, spam has ruined Bitcoin, in my opinion. It hasn't ruined initial block download

56:29 in three years or four years. Down the road, like in 20 years, maybe, I don't know. Okay. Yeah. If I may, I have a difference of opinion here because it's the foreverness of it. If we have to store it forever, then it's crucial that we fight it off as much as we can. Yeah, but if Bitcoin is going to live for 500 years, what difference is it like life or death if we stop it the year 14, 15, 16 or 17? i i think there is because i think there are second order effects that are very hard to see here if i i think there is an urgency in the sense that if we don't show uh at the early stages that no you cannot fucking take this over no we are we are going to be resilient we're going to be resistant then you're sending a signal that will lead to worse things it's a slippery slope argument And I think Bitcoin has shown that in the past and that it's not continuing to show that kind of resilience to me.

57:39 Yeah, makes sense somewhat. I mean, I think the longer you tolerate something, the harder it is to turn it around also because every day of tolerance brings strength to the status quo, so to say. Yes, and it also brings more vested interests in these things, like Citria, for instance, that shouldn't exist. But still, I oppose the narrative that this is now or never. It could be, in hindsight, that this was the time because this has already gathered momentum. And that matters. How easy would it be to even come where we are now in opposition to the directional core?

58:20 Probably really hard. Okay, I think this is where you and I differ a bit because I think that that initial momentum, this may be the only opportunity we get. But that's what I said, Knut, so then we don't differ. Then you misunderstood me. Okay, okay, sorry. But yeah, so what's the counter argument? Like I thought you were making a counter argument. This is against, this is like my argument for the BIP 110. No, it is actually against it because I am saying that, I'm just steelmanning my own argument or like devil's advocating it. Like maybe this is the chance, you know, but I'm still saying that the absolute conviction that it's now or never is not something we know.

59:08 It could be. There's a Ben Affleck Batman quote here. So like if there's a slightest chance that Superman may destroy humanity, then we have to take it as an absolute certainty. Yeah, that would make sense if there was no chance of doing harm with the action you chose to pursue. Yeah, fair enough. But yeah, so that's that. And then the fact that there is a theoretical chance and probably a real reality that some coins would be unspendable under BIP110.

59:50 Some UTXOs would just be locked. And that is an argument that has been fielded to me very passionately by people against BIP 110. And I can't just completely dismiss that argument because they made a setup that was valid within the Bitcoin rules when they did it. A change that would permanently make those funds lost is problematic. It's setting a very dangerous precedent. I can agree to that. However, I think that as I mentioned before, I think there's a fuck around and find out scale here.

1:00:32 if you just use bitcoin as intended as money then your your coins are at no risk they're only at risk if you try to fiddle around with these bitvm's things or what maybe i'm pulling this out of my ass but if you're using advanced shit like the more the more uh fringe things you're doing with bitcoin the more your coins are at risk that was always true to me that was always true but like my argument would be that you cannot own a Bitcoin. Like if you go deep into this, the only reason that I can act as if I owned my Bitcoin is that A, I find it improbable that someone else has access to the same private key and B, that I find it improbable that the protocol rules will change to such an extent that my coins will be at risk of not being accessible to me anymore.

1:01:30 And if those two are true, which I think they are, then the more complicated shit you were trying to do with it, the more at risk your coins were. That was always true to me. Yeah, but as a fund owner, as a Bitcoin hodler, you are not necessarily the one who has engineered this way of storing your bitcoins that can have been done by some expert that that that presented a whole other narrative to you as the owner of the bitcoin that this is possible this is the rules of bitcoin this is a really good way to store your bitcoin i'm just but the responsibility is still yours that's the beauty of the system that you are responsible and like if you have the i'm with stupid t-shirt on instead of the I'm responsible t-shirt on, you are around and you will eventually find out. That's my argument. Anyway, I think it's fair. And I'm just like trying to give the points that, you know, has given me pause. Because if a person came to me saying that this is my setup, and as you see, they are stored with a time lock and 600 key multisig, and I'm losing everything if this activates. I mean, it's hard for me to just say, well, you stupid fuck, you shouldn't have done that. Because I do understand some of the argument on the other side too, that's all.

1:02:59 So there's that. Well, I would say that if just to do a final rebuttal here is that if BIP110 does that, it will not go through because it's too stupid. Then people will resist it. Bitcoin already has an internal mechanism to prevent that from happening because it won't get the support it needs if that was the case. Like, I think there's a circular argument there somewhere. And I'm basing that on that I don't really own my Bitcoin. I act as if I do. But can we agree that that would be the first time in Bitcoin history that some person lost Bitcoin after having stored them within consensus rules at the time?

1:03:44 I don't think that's actually correct, because I think the inflation bug can be framed as that. Or something back in the past where the rules were changed. Here also, I should do my homework more, but I think that some of the Satoshi Dice stuff, That prevented maybe not a certain way of storing Bitcoin, but it definitely prevented a quote-unquote use case. So you can fuck up someone's business model that works on Bitcoin right now because of what the consensus rules are by tightening the rules.

1:04:27 My point is that that was always the case, and it doesn't really matter if that involves freezing sub-thousand-set UTXOs or not, or fucking up some NFT salesman's business model. The point of this whole fork is to make it costlier to abuse the network. Which I agree with. So, so there's like, if you want to make an omelet, you have to break some eggs kind of argument. Yeah. And you have to keep in mind that I just ran through a whole list of probe BIP 110 angles as well. So this is, you know, to try to explain what is still giving me some pause to go and wanting to pick up my sword and shield and die on the hill.

1:05:16 Okay. Yeah. And the last thing I think, which is something I basically need to understand better is the whole governance aspect of it. And that includes code quality. There was a bug recently, which is, I mean, Core V30 had a bug, right? So it's not like that. Quite a serious one. Yeah. Which is both, you know, argument for and against because it shows that you can still have a bug in very broadly reviewed code. And you can have a bug in code that is not reviewed that much. So it's like the code quality aspect and the whole aspect of what happens after the year is over, because this change is temporary, right? For a year. Yeah. And that year is not set in stone either. It can be revoked at any point. Like that's the fail-safe by the network, I guess, by the consensus. Like, again, I should have done my homework better, but it's not like a forever thing. No, it's just that if we open the door to like just a myriad of just one consensus fight after the other, and all of them will obviously be controversial and have infighting. And it's like, I would probably, I mean, I'm opening, I'm very open to just me not having understood the wisdom of this temporary thing, which I hope to learn more about. But yeah, it just doesn't vibe with

1:06:50 my wish to kind of like, because this is a very exhausting and damaging fight for Bitcoin. So if we're just like kicking the can one year and we will have the same fight in one year, I think that's not good. But I don't think that's the point of the various ability. Like the whole point of the fork is like, it's like hitting the developers on the nose and telling them that, guys you are not in charge we are like do as we say or we will have to do things like this which is like super cool but what still what will we do after the year who who how will we form the consensus going forward from there and who will like who will be the the leaders and the the people writing this code basically will it be luke and mechanic and dayton oh well i i don't think that's how it works. I don't think you're a Bitcoin core developer if you're not aware of how the system may change in ways that you don't approve of. That was always true. I don't think core maintainers are going to quit Bitcoin because there's a soft fork that they don't particularly like that is being implemented. I don't think that's the reason why you...

1:08:05 And I think Jimmy Song made this point on Tone's show as well, quite eloquently, like that's not how developers work. You don't devote your life to a project like this if you don't agree to the nature of the project. And the nature of the project is that this was always the case. The users could always go against the developers. That's not new. They were aware of that all the time. And if they weren't aware of that, Should they really have been there in the first place? Gloria Schauss certainly didn't seem to be aware of it. No, but she shouldn't have been there in the first place. I don't think so. Which has nothing to do with her gender or skin color.

1:08:46 It has to do with her having these fucking anti-pleb opinions. Even implying that gender or skin color or anything is a factor, is bad faith. yes and and all of those dey narratives are a side effect of the state owning money production that might be hard for people to see but politicians have too much power because of money printing and therefore we get crazy fucking clown world things like dey yeah uh and if we if we didn have that we have a functioning meritocracy when no one gave a fuck about your sexual preference or if you were a devout Catholic or if you were whatever And it was completely based on merit.

1:09:35 And that's what every single Bitcoiner I know wants Bitcoin to be a meritocracy and nothing else. Exactly. Yeah. I agree. And I think maybe I shall repeat because I'm not sure if I've said it out loud in this talk. I've said it to exhaustion on X that in my opinion, CORE carries the whole responsibility for the situation we are in right now. They caused this response by extremely arrogant, irresponsible and reckless behavior in uncapping up return in the face of huge controversy.

1:10:19 Yeah. 100%. Yeah. And that's like another thing when I see them rejecting that, like they can't even accept that fact, then what the fuck? This is why I want a response to this. I want to support something that confronts it. And yeah, as we've been through, it's just that, you know, I feel like I was premature. So, what's the best counter argument to Bit110? What's your strongest reason for pulling out your support? Like, what is the crux of it? Is it just, hang on a minute, I'll need to do my homework?

1:11:06 like or yeah i think i think it's the sum of doubts that that you know some of them were already there already there all the way as i as i posted about while supporting it like i am not sure if bit 110 is the best solution but i still supported it because i saw i was so sure that core direction needs to be opposed. And then, you know, after talking to, and once again, Giacomo did not reach out to talk to me. I reached out to talk to him. He did not try to convince me. It's just that I respect his opinion a lot and it gave me more doubt after talking to him.

1:11:50 I'm honest about that. Of course, you shouldn't trust anyone blindly, but reality is that me and you and a lot of other people also use the social compass in navigating and and we we do outsource some or like at least listen to the people who have proven themselves worthy to listen to and suddenly i found found myself it's it's not like i mean jacomo he shares all of my anger at core basically. But he does not think BIP-110 is a responsible solution.

1:12:31 So how much of that do you think is just like, Giacomo might be a bad example here. So let's not make this personal, but for influencers in general, or people who make a living out of being a voice in the Bitcoin space. I would say that there is an incentive to stay on the sidelines and not invest too much in a fight that you're not sure if you're going to win because you don't know what the result will be on the other side of that fight. So I think there's a reputational damage to be had. And I think there's influences like people who speak at conferences, people like me like uh and and uh to me that was sort of more of a reason to actually signal that i am willing to die on this hill because i i i the only thing that got me here in the first place was this principled approach to stuff and like as soon as i start compromising that i i become no better than anyone else no no not saying that i am better than anyone else but i'm just saying that yeah i i have my doubts about the actual fork as well, but I feel so strongly about fighting for Bitcoin's core principles. And to me, there's this Venn diagram of knowledge about computer networks and economic literacy. And ideally, you want the Bitcoiners to be in the middle of that Venn diagram.

1:13:58 And I feel that Core has lost the part of the economic literacy way too much. I think maybe some of the people trying to keep the monetary thing, they don't have the technical understanding required. I might be in that camp, sure. But at least I'm trying to push the economic literacy bubble to be bigger and more important for the discussion. Make of that what you will. Yeah. One thing I've observed also, which I think is, I mean, I think you're very correct that a lot of people are scared to pick a side here. And I don't think they become less scared when they see the level of the level of backlash that comes whenever you choose aside. And I've managed the amazing feat of being hated by both sides in some ways right now, which is kind of funny, but I can assure it, it wasn't out of anything but, you know, of a Bitcoin and trying to do the right thing. I've seen one thing, I think at least I've seen it, I'm not going to be bombastic about it, but it really seems like that, that there is a cohort of people who resist and try to shut down this BIP110 thing because it's making noise, it's making drama, it's hurting the price. And that to me is like, that's not a good reason to be against BIP110.

1:15:36 If you think if the only reason you're against it is because it can hurt, like drama can hurt the price short term no and and that's like this has been one of my key points uh since the whole core versus not debate started and that is that everyone should be happy that this conflict is happening because because it means that bitcoiners care yeah if we were just going along with anything like bad bad bad then that that would be much more dangerous it is going to be chaotic it's going to be super fucking scary and Bitcoin is going to be at the brink of death from certain point of views. That's part of the system. That's what we signed up for.

1:16:17 It's why it's different. It's why it's special to me. Because there is no guiding light. There is no leader that can tell you what the correct position to have here is. Which is why I'm so frustrated when I see tribalism form and this whole, if you're not with us, you're against us attitude, because I don't think that helps either. And of course, this might be self-contradictory then with talking about the pros of being on the sidelines and not taking a side and that's cowardice. But as with all things, there's a balance to be struck. Absolutely. Yeah, this is a difficult topic.

1:17:00 I'm going to spend a lot of time talking and reading and, you know, trying to address my, like, what is giving me, what is, like, unclear to me. And, yeah, I'm not going to make any rash decision for sure. Again, and if I ever, you know, were to support BIP110 again, which, I mean, I'm going to be honest. Like, I think you need to, you need to be able to, to like change your mind in the face of new information and new understanding. And once again, this just like underlines the stupidity in me to be premature in supporting it.

1:17:42 And I tried to explain it was because I was away for a long time. I came in under informed and emotional and I regret it. It would be so much better if I was still on the sidelines, you know, and just like kept learning. And then I could like take a position. But I'm not done with this discussion. That's like my... So we don't really know your position yet. Honestly, it shouldn't really matter, to be honest. You should make up your own mind. It's like the life of Brian's everyone. We're all different. Yeah. So it's not like I think that my opinion should matter a lot to anyone, but probably the reality is that some people value my opinion too, and they want my opinion. And that's why it was super important for me to be honest that shit, I think I was, I don't have this conviction right now.

1:18:39 I have to like withdraw my support right now, even if it was stupid as fuck and made me look like an idiot. So let's try a thing here. If I go to the website and just read off of it and see what our ideas are about these specific points, is that okay? Yeah, I think it has to be the last point on this call though, because I'm going to have a date with my girlfriend. Okay. Yeah, I wouldn't want to fuck that up. So how it works. Simple restrictions that preserve all monetary use cases while limiting data abuse. So output size limits.

1:19:20 New outputs are limited to 34 bytes, except op return, which allows up to 83 bytes. The output size limits, that is to make it more expensive to put JPEGs and stuff on chain, I guess, because you have to split them up into smaller part, leading to bigger fees having to be paid because more V bytes per transaction of these things, right? Is that how you interpret it? Yeah, I mean, I also interpret it like, you know, putting the op return limitation into consensus and strangling it at 83 bytes instead of 100 kilobytes. Yeah, that's also, yeah.

1:20:01 So I think in Nots, it's defaulted as, the default is like 42 bytes and not 83. But that's the mempool policy. I mean, you can just do that afterwards too, I guess. Whatever that. So data push limits, data pushes and witness elements are limited to 256 bytes maximum. Op push data payloads and witness stack elements exceeding 256 bytes are invalid. except BIP16 redeem script. So I guess this is another attempt at strangling whatever comes in there as spam.

1:20:42 Yeah, I think, you know, I think already because I'll be perfectly honest and say that I don't know anything about OP push data payloads and witness stack elements. So that tells me that it would probably be smart to have like a layman's explanation on all of these points on this site? Yeah, I think so too, absolutely. But I'm just going to assume that all of these limits are to make spamming more expensive by limiting the amount of data per transaction. I think that's the retard understanding of it that actually works.

1:21:28 Witness version restriction. restrictions, only well-defined witness versions, v0 and taproot, can be spent during the deployment. Now, yeah, I'm confused. Do you understand any of this? Does this have anything to do with Segwit discount? I don't know. Probably not. So I think I have no idea. Yeah, this is Hodlunot and Knut Naked here admitting how much plebslop retard we actually are. I think so, yeah, here is where some of these wallet developers and stuff could be irritated at this because some of their functionalities would not work anymore, right?

1:22:18 But that is motivated by the bigger incentive to just fuck with Citria and the likes of it. Yeah, but I think the broad The broad understanding I have is that, you know, none of these restrictions fuck with any like popular normal use case wallets at all. And that's very important to keep in mind. But it does fuck with the ability of mental gymnastic grifters to buy different methods, use Bitcoin for non-monetary transactions. Yeah, if I'm going to devil's advocate against this, that would be that it might disincentivize developers from working on new interesting features that could actually have monetary use case. But I don't think that's a very strong argument.

1:23:07 Anyway taproot restrictions Taproot annexes large control blocks and certain opcodes are temporarily restricted Yeah I don think anyone uses taproot for whatever it was for its intended uses anyway or very limited usage of that So it being used way more for crap So I don't think that's a big concern. Would it be fair to say that the main result or the main innovation downstream of Taproot being merged was ordinals? Is this conspiracy theory territory where we think that it was actually pushed through because of that?

1:23:51 It was actually not intended as that by me, but I certainly see that it could be interpreted like that. Yeah, and some malicious forces may have pushed it through because they wanted to do this shit. At least we have to agree that probably we should take lessons should be learned after the whole Taproot implementation, how casually and like non-investigatively that was done and like how that broad consensus formed. Was it just because all the people we got used to trusting were for it? I think that plus a fatigue from the block size war so so people were not willing to do the work and and actually reading up on what this thing actually did and as far as I remember it was also sold uh almost like like an extension of Segwit and Segwit was like you know it became seen as uh I mean, basically the fruits of winning the block size war in some way because Gihan resisted it so hard and stuff.

1:25:01 And Taproot was like always like the last piece we needed to make it so much more powerful. Yeah. At least that's how I interpreted it. Yeah, that's how I remember it being marketed as well, whilst that might not have been entirely true then. Maybe. I mean, at least it seems to me like Taproot was a huge positive for people who want the JPEGs on Bitcoin. Yeah, unfortunately, like I sometimes wonder where Bitcoin would have been today if Lightning Network was not a thing. So yeah, sure, SegWit was important for other things than just Lightning, especially the malleability thing, transaction malleability bug.

1:25:47 So what would have happened if we didn't have a Lightning Network, but if Bitcoin had just ossified and continued on, would we have had the spam? Would we have had similar attacks? We can never know because we live in the branch of the multiverse that we happen to live in, and that's just true for everyone alive. We cannot ever know what the... It's Bastia's broken window. or Bastia the seen and the unseen we cannot know what the other timeline would have looked like because we're not in that timeline we're in the one we're in yeah no it's this sliding doors or closing doors thought like what would happen if you managed to get on that subway instead of the doors closing in front of you and what would have happened if the Germans won World War 2 and all that shit we will never know Yeah, and if Jamie Oliver actually learned how to cook at some point.

1:26:46 We can never know. Let's not get into the wildest mental gymnastics. Yeah. Anyway, so the common questions here, maybe we should round this out by commenting on this stuff too. So why is this proposal temporary? The one-year deployment allows the community to evaluate the impact. That's very fair, I think. that's what allows you to have a bit of time before you make your stance on this. Like they're giving Hodlunot time to do his homework here. And me, by the way. So while developers work on a longer term solution, so it sort of implies that something else will have to follow a longer term solution.

1:27:33 And I think that's referring to like actually fixing the bugs. what Luke and Mechanic calls bugs anyway, or what Luke calls bugs. I think they are bugs or exploits. Exploits, I think, is a better word. Ordinals and inscriptions and all of these are exploits. Can I just devils advocate that? All right. It's like it's worded as of like just a positive. It allows the community and, you know, as the community is, as we are seeing right now, extremely polarized. Yeah. It allows the community to evaluate the impact. No, no, no, no, no. So that to me sounds like we're going to have like an ongoing, very hostile debate going on what is this actually doing, you know?

1:28:25 And we'll have one side who says, look here, it destroyed Bitcoin as we know it. And the other side will, no, fuck you, it saved Bitcoin. And this is like the thing that I haven't fleshed out in my mind enough, just like how will this year and what happens after, how will it look in practice? Is it any chance of Bitcoin emerging from this as one solid thing that still retains the trust of the world? I don't know. Well, I'm optimistic about that.

1:29:05 Yeah. I think it wouldn't be the case if Bitcoin hadn't had this fight. Either everyone agrees to this and then the consensus rules are temporarily tightened, or we have a hard fork, or it's dead in the water. Who knows? Well, I guess we'll see. there's some sort of Pascal's wager to it too because like the more you believe it will happen the higher the likelihood that it actually will yeah so that's to take into account too like yeah the other sentence here is I can agree that this language here is kind of it's presenting this fork as something that allows the community to evaluate the impact like it's it's very self-promoting in in the language chosen here yeah i could rewrite it and probably probably be similarly close to the truth like something like allows the community to infight and put each others on the stake and kill each other for a year developers work on on a longer term solution.

1:30:20 Yeah, some restrictions would severely constrain future upgrades if permanent, but are acceptable for a limited time to address the immediate crisis. Yeah, here I can actually be where one of my biggest concerns with BIP-110 is the same as like passports were a temporary measure at one point in time. And now they're standard all over the world. so you need a paper to be allowed to go abroad that was not always the case and this is this is my biggest concern i think that sometimes temporary things are not as temporary as we think it's like when you fix something with a gaff tape and yeah instead of properly fixing it you tend to not give a fuck about it afterwards and the temporary solution becomes the permanent solution. Yeah. I'll add something that would be pro-Bip or like that would make me less concerned about that. And that's that severely constraining future upgrades. Like that just sounds good to me. I don't want to upgrade all that. Like what is Bitcoin? Is it something that we shall always like upgrade? I understand maintain and fix bugs and shit, but I don't want Bitcoin going to be this innovation place no there is a point where enough is enough right that we don't need to uh maintaining is one thing and and fighting off future threats uh that's one thing

1:31:52 uh but that's not upgrading necessarily so if upgrading is you know quantum resistance if that is even needed i i don't know if that just fud as well but uh that would be valid uh it's both fud and not fud at the same time ronner schrodinger's fud yes limiting taproot control blocks could complicate advanced smart contracts like bitvm i don't think this is a trade-off at all i think that's a feature not a bug like i don't want programmable money because to me programmable money means programmable people i don't want i don't want fucking scripts like that i know that satoshi was for uh having the script thing in there so so that in the future bitcoin could accommodate smart contracts and stuff.

1:32:37 But I don't necessarily like that. I want Bitcoin to be as simple as possible. Yeah, I agree. Upgrade hooks are temporarily unavailable for other soft forks. Some wallet software using op-if and tap leaves may need updates. However, these are acceptable short-term trade-offs for immediate benefits. Yeah, might piss off some developers on some projects and might even fuck with their business models somehow. Yeah, however, I think this is definitely in the fuck around and find out category. Is there any risk of funds being frozen or lost? In theory, yes, but this proposal goes to great pains to avoid affecting those use cases.

1:33:17 Funds are completely unaffected if they don't use taproot, use taproot in standard ways, or can be spent by a key path or other expected tap leaves. Additionally, UTXO created before activations are permanently exempt from the new rules. Oh, that's interesting. Yeah. So it doesn't freeze anything except if you create that thing now before the whole thing. Yeah. I would be interested to find out if there are no exceptions to that statement that basically funds, UTXOs, cannot be frozen. because I've heard different stories spelled out and yeah, that should be clarified.

1:34:03 It says UTXOs created before activation are permanently exempt from the new rules. To me, I interpret that as you being able to move those coins after the rules are implemented. Yeah, a separate two-week grace period between lock-in and activation also provides great general preparation time. Yeah. Won't spammers just spread their data over multiple fields? While it's impossible to fully prevent steganography, limiting data sizes ensures abuses and non-contiguous and obfuscated. Requiring users to divide files into chunks of 256 bytes raises the costs in fees and effort, sending a clear message that data storage is unwelcome.

1:34:51 I think this is the biggest why I'm pro this thing. because I do want to send that message and I do want it to become more expensive for them to do that. I mean, even if my house, you know, theoretically can be broken into by very sophisticated thieves using advanced tooling and equipment, I still prefer that situation to opening my door wide open with a sign and like marketing that thieves can enter here. It's a huge difference to me.

1:35:32 And obviously to me, making it more difficult and need more complexity. Costly. Everything to spam the blockchain or grift on the blockchain. We should do that. Yeah. Why limit script pubkeys to 34 bytes? Script pubkeys must be stored indefinitely in quick access memory by all nodes. Modern usage is all 34 bytes or smaller, as actual spending conditions are in the witness. Large script pubkeys enable data abuse and malicious poison blocks that take a long time to validate. Yeah, I don't have anything to add to that, I think.

1:36:15 Is there a slippery slope toward banning use cases? No, these rules enshrine longstanding principles of Bitcoin. This software does not restrict monetary activity, only non-monetary data storage. The temporary nature reinforces a targeted intervention, not a new direction. Yeah, I like that point. Even if it said, yes, it is a slippery slope toward banning use cases, I would be pro it because I don't want use cases. I want there to be one single use case. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. I don't want smart contracts. It's just a fact. I want monetary transactions on Bitcoin.

1:36:56 Yeah. And even a thing like time locks, which I think are super cool. I know that if I was to put my Bitcoins in time lock, to time lock them for X number of blocks then they are more at risk than if i could interact with them during that period of course because i cannot predict the future that is a fuck around use case even though it's a cool use case it's still a fuck around use case all right does this solve spam completely no of course it doesn't and no one ever claimed it did by the way this is the that's what the yeah bad argument yeah which is which is also like something i don't like with the rhetoric from this V30 core camp that, oh, look, we could put the whole BIP110 PDF in the blockchain under BIP110 rules. Yay. So this is pointless. That's bad faith, in my opinion.

1:37:54 Yeah. The other point I want to make about the smaller, won't the spammers just spread their data over multiple fields? This is, I guess the devil's advocate argument there would be that since there are smaller fees, they will bloat the UTX set more because there will be more transactions and they will have to like spam it up. The point is though, that it's costlier. So I do think that that's a bad argument too, even though it could lead to more bloat, but that sort of requires all the spammers to have more money to spend on this. And the risk there, I'd say, is a state level attack where a nation state decides to kill Bitcoin and they have a money printer. So they have infinite money for at least short term before the fiat, their printing dies.

1:38:49 So they can just print and print and print and spam the chain with or bloat the UTXO set. However, that would require a competent government, which is incompatible with with a deep state really smart government. So I'm unsure there if retardation or 5D chess is the bigger threat. Yeah. Does this affect the UTXO set? No, BIP-110 only limits the size of new outputs going forward. It doesn't touch, invalidate, or prune any existing UTXOs. This is important. You may be thinking of the CAT. Yes, the cat is the really controversial proposal.

1:39:34 And we had a lot of fun trolling people with that by saying meow on X. Just threatening with a cat, which is actually going to these ordinals websites and picking out these transactions and just making them unspendable. When was that meow meme and cat? When did cat launch? Yeah, I'm sorry you missed it because you would have been perfect for it with the helmet on. That was like a couple of months back, I guess. It's an idea by a developer called Claire Ostrom, which is probably some kind of NIMM thing. And it proposed to actually go to all these sites that promote selling stamps and ordinals and inscriptions and target it because all the data is there where this NFT was minted or whatever, where the address of this rare set.

1:40:24 and you would just go there and invalidate all of those, which is, I love the idea as much as I hate the idea, the precedent it sets and so on and so forth, but I kind of love it just to really, really rug the spammers. I love that. I love the finding out part of it, but I don't love the precedence and like basically the principle of it. No, and someone would actually have to code the thing first. So I think the cat is probably, that's not the topic of today definitely not does this affect the lightning network no is the short answer here yeah i'm sure there will be someone in your comments depending on how many people watch this but that will create some type of exotic scenario where it would affect something on the lightning network. But I mean, I trust what is said here that basically the summarized answer is no.

1:41:25 Yeah. Taproot was designed so that... Why is op-if restricted in Tapscript? And here's a long explanation. And it's basically to... Oh, this is long and complicated. I have seen controversy around this op-if thing at least, but my takeaway from what I read is that it's extremely rarely used, if at all, and that there are substitutes for it that can be implemented if BIP-110 were to activate. Yeah. And as we have said before, BIP-110 is a consensus level change and not a mental policy that change.

1:42:08 This is where most of the criticism is like that this is and should be a policy level thing, how much you allow or not, choose to allow or not allow in your mempool. But I'd say that that is, yes, that was a good position to have up until Core V30, which fucked that up. So now that argument does no longer apply, in my view, because they went against the grain there. Is this optional for miners? During the signaling phase, miners can choose whether to signal support. If 55% signal in a retarget period, the soft fork locks in early. If not, mandatory signaling kicks in before the deadline. Locks that don't signal are rejected, guaranteeing lock in. Once activated, the new rules are enforced at the consensus level. Any block that violates them is rejected by all enforcing nodes, regardless of the miner's preference.

1:43:04 Yeah. Are people willing to die on this hill or not? I guess we'll see. Yeah. And I hope the debate continues to illuminate what it really is for me and for everyone who wants to understand that the sides of it that are still contentious or under understood will be better relate to laymen or people with less technique like plebsop people like us. And I also hope that, you know, I think I like to think that our conversation today is kind of like maybe representative for the level of technical understanding of a lot of Bitcoiners and therefore may be useful. And maybe it's useful to have more conversations like this from not necessarily from us, but from people who just like, honestly, people, maybe the main target would be people who are worried about what Core is doing, because that's where I'm coming from. I would love to just brush this aside. And like, why should we even consider this? I mean, we have a great developer group in Core that we can trust and things are great, but I don't feel like that.

1:44:25 I really feel like Core needs to be tempered. Yeah, I totally agree. And And the question becomes, is this the way of doing that? Or shall we bicker and argue until a better way comes up? And this is already gaining some momentum. So I'm very unsure that we'll get a second chance at this. And so the same argument, like, I think this was one of Giacomo's arguments to you, if I'm not mistaken, that it has such low chances of succeeding that we'll have a harder time the next time we try something. That will burn more social capital for maybe the right reaction.

1:45:10 Yes, but the counter argument to that would be, well, Batman was not the hero Gotham wanted, but it's the one they got. This is the thing that is on the table. There is currently no other thing on the table. so maybe now that this is the thing on the table then this is the only chance we get and therefore we should just fucking do it and then everyone can theorize afterwards I think doing nothing over a long time period is 100% harmful that is harm the way I see it but I also think doing something rather drastic in haste has the potential of being harmful too. It's like, therefore, the conviction level and confidence in having understood the aspects that are important to each of us, wherever you stand subjectively, is a prerequisite before you die on the hill or before you potentially decide to die on a hill because this is important for Bitcoin. This whole conflict is very important for Bitcoin. And I don't think it's very overstated to say that this is maybe not as important as the block size war, but this whole, it does feel like

1:46:46 a moment in time for Bitcoin where stakes are high and it really matters which side you choose. yeah so so before we close this out like a final question would be what would it take to convince you to signal support again for for bip 110 what would that take uh it would take for me to reflect more on this and to become more uh confident in the in the points i raised against BIP 110, basically. Maybe the biggest thing is uncertainty about everything regarding governance, one year temporary activation, what happens after. That whole dynamic is big for me. And also to have more clarity on potential for loss of funds for any users.

1:47:55 Yeah, fair enough. Do you wear flip-flops? I did yesterday or the day before. I took them off. Okay. I mean, I'll just go back to saying maybe two things, you know, that I subscribe to just, you know, being open to learning always and to be open to change my mind. And it's not like I really, the degree to which I changed my mind was a conviction level. As I think I've become clear in this conversation, I am not like one of the people who attack BIP110 in any way. I applaud it. I applaud people who want to fight for Bitcoin and who follow principles. I like to follow principles. I do that always. I try to, but I, yeah, but I'm, I'm very like, I feel embarrassed for having flip-flopped on my outspoken support. And that means I will have to be damn sure before I come back in support. Okay. So if we ever see you support it again, then that's final. Then I'm on the hill. That's for sure. All right. Yeah. Uh, I'll, I'll close out with this once again here.

1:49:13 We the plebs are the dicks. We're reckless, arrogant, stupid dicks. And the developers are pussies. And the spammers are assholes. Pussies just don't like dicks because pussies get fucked by dicks. But dicks also fuck assholes. Assholes who just want to spam on everything. Pussies make things that they can deal with assholes in their way by increasing up return. But the only thing that can fuck an asshole is a dick with some balls. Yeah. With that... Strong words, Knut. Strong words. Pick a side or don't. And remember to brush your teeth. And like, comment, subscribe, share this thing.

1:49:57 Call us idiots. Call us wise old bearded men. You're not bearded. You have a mustache or an attempted one. And I hope to see you again soon, man. We see each other way to sell them in in the flesh and uh we we have to find an island somewhere where we can hang out with our kids maybe we can do your eurasia yeah who knows it's always a pleasure anyway and i i i uh respect you insane the the levels of respect i have for you and the decisions you made in life are insane and it's always always good to talk to you and and bounce these things back and forth I'm going to continue my support for BIP110 now and we'll see what happens in the future.

1:50:45 Yeah, I respect you a lot, Knut. Thanks for having these conversations with me both on this podcast and on the phone before. And thanks for being my friend and I hope to talk to you soon. With that, this has been the Bitcoin Infinity Show. Cheerio, folks. Thank you. Bye.